Skip to main content

While visiting Marty and Dotty last Saturday and being inspired with his extensive collection of passenger train sets, I casually asked him what his favorite set was. Understand that his collection probably has the best from all O-Gauge manufactures. He thought for a bit and then answered, the K-Line 21" NYC Empire State Builder set.

 

That made me ponder this question. For me, undoubtedly, it is the K-Line 21" Sante Fe Hi-Level set. All that bright shinny aluminum finish on a Hi-Level car, what's not to like. Plus they are from the ever popular Sante Fe, and who can honestly say they don't like this famous road name.

 

I have come to really appreciate K-Line passenger cars. They were way ahead of their time and they appear to very popular today, many years after production ceased.

 

Please keep your answer restricted to K-Line passenger cars. So what is your favorite K-Line passenger set? This question is not restricted to K-Line set owners, only those who have an opinion about the K-Line passenger car sets. It will be quite interesting to see what set is the most popular.

 

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Nearly all my 21" and 18" lightweight and heavyweight sets are PRR cars.  I have the K-Line PRR version of both lengths and they are really nice.  However, I like the detail better on the GGD cars.  After trying to decide which of these PRR sets I liked better, I decided that the set I really liked best was my K-Line 18" Golden State set.  With all 10 cars being pulled by my matching Lionel E6 AA (both powered to pull them), it is really a pretty sight.

 

Ron

 

Pictures added:

 

K-Line GS Dome-Golden Outlook

 

KL GS Imperial range L2

 

Unfortunately, I do not have a good picture of the E6s (currently in storage).  This one at least shows their colors.

 

E6 and Q2

Attachments

Images (3)
  • K-Line GS Dome-Golden Outlook
  • KL GS Imperial range L2
  • E6 and Q2
Last edited by CAPPilot
The very rare K4670J 18" 1938 20th Century Limited set is a favorite of mine. It matches Lionel's Dreyfus model in every aspect except the shade of gray, which is still true to prototype anyway. Snagged them off eBay for a great price considering their rarity. The seller had worded the listing title poorly; had it shown up in a wider range of searches I probably would have been too late.

If only K-Line would have stuck around long enough to release them in 21"...

IMG_3339IMG_3342IMG_3343IMG_3344

Attachments

Images (4)
  • IMG_3339
  • IMG_3342
  • IMG_3343
  • IMG_3344
Last edited by PC9850

I have both K-Line's 16" Milwaukee Road 4 plus 2 sets, one heavyweight and one streamliner in the orange/maroon/black color combo. I would love to have their 18" or 21" (I don't remember in they made both) streamliner in the U.P. colors. But then, I would need to get a set of  E-7 or E-9 ABA which I would like to have anyway!

As has been stated by many a Forumite, we lost a major producer and innovator in the O gauge hobby with the demise of K-Line. Does anyone know if the tooling for K-Line's passenger cars are still floating around out there for a enterprising company to re-issue? Needless to say, I think that K-Line's sets are top-notch and well worth adding to your railroad.

Last edited by MilwRdPaul

The 21" aluminum Milwaukee Road set in Hiawatha orange and maroon. The cars are too long to run on my home layout, I can only run them at the toy train museum, but they make a spectacular train with any matching diesel or electric locomotive. I have the 15" version to run at home, but the scale size cars are the best.

 

My other K-Line sets are:

21" Milwaukee Road streamliners in UP Yellow

15" Milwaukee Road streamliners in Hiawatha orange and maroon and in UP yellow with matching ABA diesels

18" Milwaukee Road heavyweights

15" Milwaukee Road heavyweights

15" PRR Fleet of Modernism with small GG-1

18" ATSF "Black Bonnet" with matching ABA diesels

 

Here they are on display, behind a Weaver Little Joe (top row). Only five cars will fit on the 12-foot shelf, but I run nine or ten at the toy train museum. 

Wall_1

 

 

And the same cars with an Atlas Erie Built. Train on the bottom shelf is a K-Line Milwaukee Road set with 15" cars and ABA F-units. I also have an identical set in Hiawatha colors to run at home; the layout is too small for the 21-inchers.

Wall_4

Attachments

Images (2)
  • Wall_1
  • Wall_4
Last edited by Southwest Hiawatha
The tooling was used by Lionel (as "K-Line by Lionel") for several passenger sets, including the 21" Milwaukee Road cars in UP yellow. The tooling is owned by Kader, the big Chinese toy maker that also owns Bachmann-Williams. Sanda Kan, a Kader subsidiary, built the K-Line cars. I have heard of no current plans to use the tooling. There have been rumors that one or more major manufacturers looked into using the tooling and decided the product would be too expensive to sell profitably. 
 
Originally Posted by MilwRdPaul:

I have both K-Line's 16" Milwaukee Road 4 plus 2 sets, one heavyweight and one streamliner in the orange/maroon/black color combo. I would love to have their 18" or 21" (I don't remember in they made both) streamliner in the U.P. colors. But then, I would need to get a set of  E-7 or E-9 ABA which I would like to have anyway!

As has been stated by many a Forumite, we lost a major producer and innovator in the O gauge hobby with the demise of K-Line. Does anyone know if the tooling for K-Line's passenger cars are still floating around out there for a enterprising company to re-issue? Needless to say, I think that K-Line's sets are top-notch and well worth adding to your railroad.

 

Originally Posted by John Meyncke:

My favorite K-line set is K-4470B, the NYC 28th Anniversary HW set, 5 cars of sheer wonderfulness!

I recently looked at this set after I had stored it for a while and the conductor figures in each coach are loose and rattling around inside.... I wonder why just the conductors and not the other passengers? Strange indeed.

Regards, John

 Mine as well. The swing out steps are a cool feature too.

This was the set I picked up when I purchased the K-Line Scale Hudson.

 

Pete

Last edited by Norton

The favorite that I own is the 21" California Zephyr set pulled by Lionel F units in Western Pacific.  My K-Line 18" Union Pacific City of Los Angeles is another favorite.  It is pulled by K-Line E units.   I agree that you Santa Fe Hi-Level El Capitan in 21" cars is a show stopper.  I would like a K-Line 21" Santa Fe Super Chief set.

 

Art

Last edited by Chugman

I have the K-line 21" Santa Fe set, plus a 21" business car. Santa Fe is certainly

no NYC to me, but it's one of my Favorite 5.

 

As I recall, these cars also came in a foreshortened but equally gorgeous 15" (scale

60') version, and I wish that I had gotten those instead. Almost as impressive,

scale girth if not length, and much more useable on my layout. I find 15" cars - like Lionel's PW aluminums - to be a nice compromise. Even on 072 curves, 21" cars look

pretty silly.

Last edited by D500

I like the Interurban sets.

 

I will stick my neck out and say the smaller o27 style postwar Lionel influenced streamliners car are great fun. Especially the later ones with good interiors. The New Haven set with the odd one off car 1000 paint scheme was fun too. The flat end observation cars done in this series are great I wish they offered one in Pennsylvania Broadway Limited scheme.

 

Martys NYC Empire State Builder and Brians Hi Level Santa Fe Sets are two of my favorites. However if I had to pick one it would most certainly be the K-Line F3ABA in the fabled Santa Fe Black Bonnet livery pulling the 8 matching passenger cars. I'm sorry I don't have a video to show, it really is one heck of a consist.

 

 I found these pics on the net.

 

In addition to the 8 matching passenger cars, there are also 16 matching freight cars (4 each: two kinds of hoppers, tank car and box car) and matching caboose - also a very cool consist.

 

 

 

 

 

Last edited by Railrunnin

I believe one of the biggest strong points about K-Line passenger cars is they were smart enough to make their Lightweights in 15", 18" and 21" sizes, all with equal quality. From the posts so far, it is apparent that members have purchased K-Lines based upon the capacity of their layouts with equal enthusiasm for this product.

 

Wonderful posts so far.

Add Reply

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×