Just bought an Erie Lackawanna Ltd set with the SD-40

@Rich Melvin posted:

Just so we’re all on the same switch list here, the locomotive under discussion here is an “SD40” not an “SD-40.” EMD did not use dashes in the basic model numbers. They did use them in the “Dash 2” series, as in SD40-2.

IIRC Lionel printed it as "SD-40" on the box. We just use what they call it.

I’ll bet the single motor SD40 was a dog… I have the dual motor Chessie version and that’s a big, heavy engine for only one motor.

@BobbyD posted:

IIRC Lionel printed it as "SD-40" on the box. We just use what they call it.

The box is wrong.

It would be a nice thing to have SD40 dual motor frames sell the single motor SD owners a new frame and second power truck.  I would be happy to buy a frame and 2 power trucks   I missed out on Lionel's parts sale on that

@Ed Samsen posted:

   I missed out on Lionel's parts sale on that

The parts sale is good till tonight at 11:59 PM. 9/25/22.

You still have time

Doug

@Rich Melvin posted:

The box is wrong.

Not Lionel's first or only mistake Rich! Unfortunately that is what Lionel labeled it so folks search by what the label says.

@Rich Melvin posted:

Just so we’re all on the same switch list here, the locomotive under discussion here is an “SD40” not an “SD-40.” EMD did not use dashes in the basic model numbers. They did use them in the “Dash 2” series, as in SD40-2.

@BobbyD posted:

IIRC Lionel printed it as "SD-40" on the box. We just use what they call it.

@Rich Melvin posted:

The box is wrong.

Seeing as what Lionel sells is not an actual EMD SD40 but rathera model of an SD40, and actually printed “SD-40” on the box, correcting someone in this case seems like an effort in futility and off-topic at best.

If this were in the real trains forum it would be more welcome and expected to correct mistakes like this.

@BobbyD posted:

Not Lionel's first or only mistake Rich! Unfortunately that is what Lionel labeled it so folks search by what the label says.

Yes, Lionel has incorrectly used dashes in EMD locomotive names many times and when looking for an elusive model, you often have to search by what they called it, not what it actually is.

@rplst8 posted:

Seeing as what Lionel sells is not an actual EMD SD40 but rather a model of an SD40, and actually printed “SD-40” on the box, correcting someone in this case seems like an effort in futility and off-topic at best.

If this were in the real trains forum it would be more welcome and expected to correct mistakes like this.

Yes, Lionel has incorrectly used dashes in EMD locomotive names many times and when looking for an elusive model, you often have to search by what they called it, not what it actually is.

Whether it is a model or the real thing, "SD-40" is wrong and "SD40" is correct. It's just that simple. Just because Lionel got it wrong all these years is no reason for knowledgeable modelers to repeat the same mistake.

All I'm trying to do is pass along a little accurate information about the trains we model. If you truly think it's an effort in futility, then you can continue to get it wrong.

It was a great set for its time. Lionel was in transition back then. A scale diesel with some non scale cars was all we had. Scale was still limited to 2r then and this was the next best thing offered for 3r. I sold this set years ago as I discovered more accurate and detailed scale in 3r and became more advanced in my modeling efforts. I also sold off 85% of my non scale toy items as well. If DCS-sounds and Premier were never offered, I probably would have returned back to H.O

Some like to stay the same, some like to advance to the next level.

It's all good.

Ed Samsen,

How do you like your new set?

True the 80s were a time when Lionel came out with entirely new items not just repackaged / repainted  same old same old F3 sets  GP7/GP9 sets and Baby Hudson Sets.  THis SD40 was entirely new in that era.Late 80s brought us more new items  Lackawanna MU cars, Scale Hudson and Semi Scale switcher with the semi-scale cars of the 1940 era plus 2 new ones It was the start of a new direction for Lionel

Ed

This was the set that changed the O gauge world  I remember when it first came out   It was that ground breaking  A completely new tooling  Not a retread  I immediately bought it and then the dummy SD-40.  It ran smooth as silk  I liked it so much I bought two more

As for powering the dummy it will cost you more in parts than it would to just buy another and swap shells   You can sell the other as a dummy

Enjoy your set and dont worry about what the dash police say 

Lionel could benefit by making the frame on dummies the same as the powered unit and put an adapter plate over the motor cutout, upgrade kit could be sold consisting of  power truck cores with motors and plug and play wiring kit.  No changing handrails detail parts etc  I think Williams did this with some of their locos to power dummies or add additional power trucks to single motored units

In the past I powered the trailing A unit on a silver spike set for a young man I knew as the single power unit would not pull a full load of 6 cars.....slaved it to the lead unit reverse using Marklin plugs as the jumper.  I also powered the dummy A of my SP Daylight F3s for the same reason  2 motors not enough for 8 aluminum cars

I had the CP Rail set with the SD40 and two dummies. Later I sold those and bought the IC SD40. I converted it to TMCC using maybe Digital Dynamics, can't remember. Lionel made replacement coil couplers for the SD40s but they would not center, I spent all this time including filling in with JB weld only to get mediocre performance.

I also had two frames for Santa Fe 2343 F3 diesels, the earlier ones with horizontal motors and a coil coupler on the nose, and made both dual powered with TMCC. Yes could pull, but also pulled alot of current. I used Rich Melvin's notes on TMCC "lashups" to control the pair.

I am predicting if you build the quad motor beast you will end up with something that has to be on its own transformer and still will not have cruise control.

I agree with some other peoples advice, just buy some engine that fills the bill - maybe find a K-Line EL Trainmaster that has TMCC (will have CC at the end). I do not know if K-Line made any with cruise control - I recently bought a K-Line NH EP5 and it does, and I have a K-Line 4-6-6T that has TMCC and K-Line's cruise control that still works.

Failing that, I like the previously mentioned idea of shell swapping with some other powered SD40.

I did a search on eBay, and plenty of EL SD40s pop up. But I did not see one Legacy engine. TMCC, yes, Legacy no. I tried MTH and boom boatloads of Erie Lackawana (sp?) engines with PS2 or PS3, maybe it time to try out DCS.

Jim, You are very welcome for the EL crane pic

Can anyone comment if Lionel produced an SD40 set in 1986

Here is the SD40 1980s production (to the best of my knowledge)

1982 - Santa Fe (Engine only - No set)

1983 - UP

1984 - EL

1985 - BN

1987 - Conrail

1988 - Chessie

1989 - CP Rail