Skip to main content

I would like to install a Lionel 610-8057-200 Smoke Unit in a Lionel E-6 with TMCC  (6-18095) to replace the mechanical unit.  

Connection for the resistor is straightforward (connect to the existing smoke unit power.)

My question(s) are for the fan.  I plan to replace the cherry switch with a reed switch with magnets on a driver, as the actuation for the "chuff" and smoke is currently only one per revolution.  

1.  Is there an output pin on the motherboard that the fan should be connected to, or splice into one of the wires going to the tender for the RailSounds chuff?

2.   I have seen suggestions to connect it directly to the switch.  Wouldn't this cause the fan to run constantly if the locomotive stopped with the switch "closed"?

Thanks

-Jim

 

Last edited by Jim Harrington
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

The correct way, at least IMO, is the Super-Chuffer, and to generate the 4-chuffs, I obviously like the Chuff-Generator.  The magnets and reed switch are a major PITA to get working right, which is why I developed a better alternative.

I may be a tiny bit biased as those are products I developed, but they do a great job.   I think you'll find that simply tying the smoke motor to the chuff switch will probably not be nearly as satisfactory.  The Super-Chuffer will give you better defined chuffing, smoke at idle, and optionally you get the lighting effects.  Here's a couple of clips with the Super-Chuffer and Chuff-Generator.

Jeff, can you be a little more specific?  As for the Super-Chuffer and the Chuff-Generator, they're designed for Lionel TMCC environments. Adding the fan driven smoke to a locomotive that has a mechanical smoke unit is largely a mechanical task with some simple wiring.

I posted some documentation in the TMCC Documentation thread about these products and their installation.

Super-Chuffer, Chuff-Generator, & Installation Diagrams

In the future I can point to this post and not have to upload multiple copies of these items.

John: I really meant that I was just wondering if this could be replaced in the Lionel and MTH engines that are more in todays offerings, and not something post war. It was pretty neat to see these items on U-tube and how things became enhanced. I had another thought just now. I have a couple of the Weaver Milwaukee Road Hiawathas 4-4-2s, and they only have the Seuth smoke units (??) are these possible? Just tossing things out, as I had not heard of these systems before. Thank you for your reply.

 

Jeff

Jeff B. Haertlein posted:

John: I really meant that I was just wondering if this could be replaced in the Lionel and MTH engines that are more in todays offerings, and not something post war. It was pretty neat to see these items on U-tube and how things became enhanced. I had another thought just now. I have a couple of the Weaver Milwaukee Road Hiawathas 4-4-2s, and they only have the Seuth smoke units (??) are these possible? Just tossing things out, as I had not heard of these systems before. Thank you for your reply.

 

Jeff

Jeff,  You do not need this for MTH, in facts John's design pay a royalty to MTH.  MTH Has adjustable and fully integrated Smoke and sounds in their DCS based boards.  Newer Legacy also has better smoke and integration.

So John's application as he stated is for Lionel and others with TMCC that did not have this capability. 

So depending on what engine and what upgrade you want determines your approach.  For example a PS-3 upgrade to a Brass engine would not need any of John's components at the PS-3 board does all that.  An ERR TMCC upgrade to that engine would need John's product to get those enhance smoke and chuff features.  G

GGG posted:
Jeff B. Haertlein posted:

John: I really meant that I was just wondering if this could be replaced in the Lionel and MTH engines that are more in todays offerings, and not something post war. It was pretty neat to see these items on U-tube and how things became enhanced. I had another thought just now. I have a couple of the Weaver Milwaukee Road Hiawathas 4-4-2s, and they only have the Seuth smoke units (??) are these possible? Just tossing things out, as I had not heard of these systems before. Thank you for your reply.

 

Jeff

Jeff,  You do not need this for MTH, in facts John's design pay a royalty to MTH.  MTH Has adjustable and fully integrated Smoke and sounds in their DCS based boards.  Newer Legacy also has better smoke and integration.

So John's application as he stated is for Lionel and others with TMCC that did not have this capability. 

So depending on what engine and what upgrade you want determines your approach.  For example a PS-3 upgrade to a Brass engine would not need any of John's components at the PS-3 board does all that.  An ERR TMCC upgrade to that engine would need John's product to get those enhance smoke and chuff features.  G

OK thanks for that bit of information.!!!

Add Reply

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×