Did Atlas acquire the tooling for the Premier CenterBeam cars ? if not this would be an ideal Master line car for production in the future, these are one of the most common cars on the railroads today.
Original Post
Replies sorted oldest to newest
@hibar posted:Did Atlas acquire the tooling for the Premier CenterBeam cars ? if not this would be an ideal Master line car for production in the future, these are one of the most common cars on the railroads today.
No, we did not acquire that tooling.
If there are any MTH people reading this, I and I believe many others would like to see another run!
If ATLAS O did not acquire the Premier Center beam flat cars, then who has them right now?
MTH still retains the tooling unless Lionel bought it and hasn't told us.
@bigboy25 posted:If there are any MTH people reading this, I and I believe many others would like to see another run!
I FINALLY got my first, and had to pay top dollar. MTH should definitely consider another run of these soon. Great modern freight car.
- Jason
@hibar posted:Nice cars, only the early runs of these cars had the trucks mounted in the correct positions , all later models had a retooled under side to move the trucks out to the car ends to correct operational issues [I assume]. I have one converted to 2 rail , see pic MMW models is showing their new brass model painted w/load ck the price!
The ones in the 2019 Volume 1 catalog run had the correct truck placement too, I have one the NS road names from that production run
I checked the original catalog listings AP 1998 vol 3 and AP1999 vol 3 and the pictures of the first 4 cars appear to be HO models small pictures and very small couplers. 2000 catalog vol 2 shows full pictures of CP Rail car with trucks mounted at the car ends. My car UP 20-68658 is pictured with end mtd trucks in catalog vol 2 2008 . It would seem that MTH retained the same catalog # when it was made again in the early 20s. MMW showed a Brass super detailed center beam car at the .Chicago O scale show this past weekend with loads and empty delivering late this year, still time to get the pre delivery price with a paid reservation.
Catalog illustrations were probably done before the retooled chassis moved the trucks. Just like the autoracks, the trucks were out at the ends of the carbody on the initial runs, and later ones moved them more inboard.
Here's the photo from MTH's site:
Here's the actual car from my collection:
My example was from the most recent run of these cars. I think it and the three others accompanying it were the only ones issued with the repositioned trucks prior to MTH's reorganization.
---PCJ
Attachments
I have several and I've snagged all of them off that big auction site at various prices. The early ones had the trucks at the ends, but MTH retooled the chassis and placed them in the correct spots (same chassis is used the the Auto Carriers). They're pretty easy to convert to scale (as many have done). I've replaced the plastic loads with wood loads from "TrainDetailsMike" which look better, but add quite a bit of weight. By the way, it turns out that the supporting center sill "spine" in the chassis was not part of these particular cars as the center beam provided the structural support. But I'm too lazy to remove the center sill and reconstruct the cross bracing.
Attachments
Images (3)
I picked up 4 of them off here recently. I got the BN and Tobacco Valley Lumber ones since they had the older opera windows in the center beam. So should the trucks be moved back like Matt showed?
@AGHRMatt posted:...........By the way, it turns out that the supporting center sill "spine" in the chassis was not part of these particular cars as the center beam provided the structural support......
This isn't correct. Centerbeams do have center sills. They aren't as deep as those under autorack flats though. Usually they are about the same depth as the side sills, or incrementally deeper, so they aren't typically visible when the car is viewed from the side.
Photos used with permission. This is an NSC built car.
Jim
Attachments
Images (2)
@big train posted:This isn't correct. Centerbeams do have center sills. They aren't as deep as those under autorack flats though. Usually they are about the same depth as the side sills, or incrementally deeper, so they aren't typically visible when the car is viewed from the side.
Photos used with permission. This is an NSC built car.
Jim
I stand corrected. And I need to see how I can modify the sills on my conversions.
@Texas Eagle 77 posted:I picked up 4 of them off here recently. I got the BN and Tobacco Valley Lumber ones since they had the older opera windows in the center beam. So should the trucks be moved back like Matt showed?
It depends on the prototype, for the Opera window cars, there seem to be examples of those with that configuration.
Burlington Northern: https://www.flickr.com/photos/8716587@N08/4952952814/
Tobacco Valley: https://ogrforum.ogaugerr.com/...52#44510792671835252
While at York, I brought this up with Rich Foster. While he wasn't too keen on (the sales potential, I guess) such "huge" cars, he did put them down on the suggestion list. While that in itself doesn't mean anything, it's a start.
While I was at it, I also put in a good word for the wood-chip hoppers (another "honking big" freight car that hadn't been made in a good long while).
---PCJ
