Skip to main content

I purchased this engine from Steve Bales who was a Lionel employee in the early 50s. Steve passed away last year and this engine was in his possession till he died. I was able to talk to Steve before he died but all he could say was yes and no as he had suffered many strokes. When the engine was sold in his estate sale it was listed as a Lionel prototype .The engine has no tender and looks to me to be a prewar Lionel #225. There are no Lionel markings on the engine and no e-unit from what I can see. Take a look at all the photos and let me know your thoughts. Again Steve owned the engine till the end but had sold the rest of his huge collection (550 engines and 2000 rolling stock) a few years before he died.

Attachments

Images (6)
  • IMG_4702
  • IMG_4701
  • IMG_4700
  • IMG_4699
  • IMG_4697
  • IMG_4696
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Hey Duane,

This is a tough one. I know you and I have talked about some of the stuff Steve had over the years and so yes there is a chance that this might have some heritage as a Lionel mockup, etc. That being said, having worked with a number of items out of the archives, I'm leaning towards a very slim chance. Lionel liked to number prototypes as a four digit 0000 especially in the postwar years. In the prewar years, things were given specific paint markings on the underside which I do not see here. The added parts look like 700E scale Hudson parts, especially the coupler and headlight. There are too many missing things for me to look at this and say "Yup, that's a prototype." You'd have to turn up some kind of documentation or photos that tell that Lionel was considering this design for production before it's got a leg to stand on as a possibility. Even if that turned up, then you have to find a way to prove other than just Steve's word that it was indeed a Lionel mockup.

All that being said and interesting conversation item and from a collection that was wonderful.

Hope you all are well.

Derek

Hey Derek,

Nice to hear from you.......I understand what your saying and respect your opinion. I really wish I could have talked to Steve about this engine. As far as I know he did not customize his trains. He even was against weathering his stuff. That's why I find it hard to believe he messed with the engine. His caretaker told me the only trains Steve would not sell till after he died were his two Vision Line GG1s and the engine we are talking about. I ended up purchasing all three. For some reason this engine was important to Steve and for that alone it's a neat piece to me.........Stay safe my friend.

Yes Don.......Steve was in 1990 Classic Toy Trains Magazine with his layout when he lived in the Los Angeles area. He later retired to Flagstaff Arizona and that's were I learned of Steve and his incredible model building skills. The whole story is on Notch 6 "The Lionel Employee in the Neighborhood " I think it's episode #103.

Thanks everyone for your help! Enjoy your trains.

@Dwayne B posted:

Yes Don.......Steve was in 1990 Classic Toy Trains Magazine with his layout when he lived in the Los Angeles area. He later retired to Flagstaff Arizona and that's were I learned of Steve and his incredible model building skills. The whole story is on Notch 6 "The Lionel Employee in the Neighborhood " I think it's episode #103.

Thanks everyone for your help! Enjoy your trains.

Thank you. I met Steve many years ago. He came to our museum to visit. His brother Joe was a member.

Joe moved nearby and downsized. The bascule bridge is at another members home layout. That member has passed but layout is still up.

Add Reply

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×