GGD vs MTH Premier Passenger Cars?

@Mike W. posted:

Simple question...do they fit together scale wise?

GGD models are scale length, and MTH passenger cars are not. Thus, you will have to be the judge as to how well they will look coupled together.

Will a GGD slumber coach look correct with an MTH Premier Amfleet set?

Probably not, in my opinion. Remember that the MTH cars are NOT scale length, then there are the windows & other details.

@Hot Water posted:

Thank you.  I was suspect of this.  But the GGD cars, including the Amtrak Slumber Coach, are so beautiful that they are worthy to have.

Cars can vary in height, width, length, color/sheen, prototype manufacturer, eg Budd, ACF, etc. Any of the these differences will stand out like a sore thumb.

Pete

Ypu will not get "Napolean hat" trucks on MTH premier passenger sets...

Beautiful passenger cars.