Skip to main content

I have a small collection of Kris Model Trains that I usually pick up for 15 to 25 dollars mint in box. This week a seller on the bay was selling a Marine Midland boxcar in very nice condition and last night I made a bid on it and went to bed. This morning I looked to see if I won it. I almost had a heart attack, it sold for 127.00 dollars plus shipping. What am I missing that this car sold for that amount. 

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Wow, that does seem high. It might have been a Frank's Roundhouse paint job on a Kris body. They did lots of small runs for commemoratives, organizations and businesses.

While my collection is predominately the earlier AMT, KUSAN and KMT, some of the later Kris boxcars are very nice and I did manage to grab a dozen or so of them, NIB, on Ebay a few years ago at under $10 each. The seller didn't know what he had, apparently. I don't feel any remorse when I have them weathered at that price.

Last edited by Arthur P. Bloom

Most of the Cars are collectors Items I believe I have 15-20 KMT Cars, they are worth a lot of money, so any I see that are cheap, I buy them.

I hope you are purchasing the Kris Model Train cars because you like them. Very few, if any, fetch a premium price. At one time I had quite a few cars, purchased from Andy Kriswalus when he was cleaning out his inventory. I needed the space and pared down my collection of Kris Model Train cars to about a dozen.

I even had some gondolas, which I have not otherwise seen. I should have held onto those.

C W Burfle posted:

Most of the Cars are collectors Items I believe I have 15-20 KMT Cars, they are worth a lot of money, so any I see that are cheap, I buy them.

I hope you are purchasing the Kris Model Train cars because you like them. Very few, if any, fetch a premium price. At one time I had quite a few cars, purchased from Andy Kriswalus when he was cleaning out his inventory. I needed the space and pared down my collection of Kris Model Train cars to about a dozen.

I even had some gondolas, which I have not otherwise seen. I should have held onto those.

The gondolas from the AMT Indiana factory and later Kusan/KMT Franklin, TN facility are somewhat harder to find than the reefers, stockcars and almost all of their boxcars they produced.  AMT and KMT/Kusan made available only one roadname for the gondola - L&N (they did come in shiny and flat black finishes, so you've got a tiny bit of variation) - an odd instance where gondolas are more scarce than the more expensive in the day boxcars, stockcars and reefers.  AMT and KMT/Kusan didn't make many sets, which probably accounts for the small number of gondolas (a favorite car to include in a set for the play value of being able to easily add a load, plus a lot less add-on parts during production).  

The 2nd KMT, Kris Model Trains from Andy Kriswallis (sp?) in New York are the same way - very few gondolas compared to boxcar, stockcar and reefer production.  Kris made lots of very short run cars which explains why some go for pretty good money.  It may be impossible at this point to document production numbers for the Kris cars, so if you run across something you like and it's cheap you might want to buy it - another one may not pop up for a long while.

Any of the KMT and its ancestors are nice pieces; the boxcars are a scale 40", I believe - bigger than the near-scale 6464's. They (not sure which generation - probably AMT) had some metal couplers that generally looked better than Lionel's, but would mate.

If memory serves...the AMT/KMT/etc boxcar molds wound up with Williams (and WBB)...I'm looking at a Williams pre-WBB boxcar right now, and it (the body) sure looks like my KMT/etc pieces. Very nice shells, and sturdy. If it had stirrups (metal, of course) at the corners it would be all I ask of rolling stock - basic, accurate, scale, tough. (Except for that Williams "brake cylinder" - wrong.)

D500 posted:

Any of the KMT and its ancestors are nice pieces; the boxcars are a scale 40", I believe - bigger than the near-scale 6464's. They (not sure which generation - probably AMT) had some metal couplers that generally looked better than Lionel's, but would mate.

If memory serves...the AMT/KMT/etc boxcar molds wound up with Williams (and WBB)...I'm looking at a Williams pre-WBB boxcar right now, and it (the body) sure looks like my KMT/etc pieces. Very nice shells, and sturdy. If it had stirrups (metal, of course) at the corners it would be all I ask of rolling stock - basic, accurate, scale, tough. (Except for that Williams "brake cylinder" - wrong.)

Here's the sequence of moves for the dies that were originally cut for Jack Ferris' American Model Train train line based in Auburn, Indiana:

AMT/Auburn (Indiana) to Kusan/KMT (Tennessee) to Kris Model Trains/KMT#2 (New York) to Williams (Maryland) to Williams by Bachmann (China).

AMT boxcars, stockcars, and reefers had diecast frames, trucks and metal operating couplers with a simulated airhose that could be opened with an uncoupling track section that had a mechanism that lifted and pushed the airhose up and uncoupled the car.

Kusan/KMT (Tennessee) continued with the same features as the AMT cars.  Kris/KMT#2 (New York) came with a sheet metal frame like the Lionel 6464 series cars used.  Early examples have Lionel diecast trucks, many have MPC plastic trucks, some turn up with the AMT diecast truck with airhose.  I'll let someone familiar with Frank's Roundhouse and Bachmann/Williams by Bachmann fill in the details on what trucks were used with those cars as I collect AMT/Auburn and Kusan/KMT cars witha few Kris cars added to the mix.

Last edited by MTN

There were actually three different "scales" of boxcars from this family tree. There were small ones that matched, roughly, the Lionel 027 el cheapo cars.

There were the ones with a fixed closed door / fixed open door that were exactly the same size as Lionel's 34xx/6464 series. This batch came as kits, which included the body, the floor, and two plastic .trucks with integral plastic couplers. They could be assembled in 5 minutes with a screwdriver

And then there were the largest series, that everyone covets.

In that largest series, there were the really heavy ones with great graphics, such as the B&O, the NYCRR Pacemaker, and the "Better for Baby" cars, followed by a series of rather bland ones that were painted in a variety of boxcar red paint schemes, and finally the last batch of this size, that transitioned to the huge variety put out by Frank's Roundhouse.  

It's possible for a modeler to have a long train of dark red boxcars, in many different railroad names, or a freight yard thickly populated with them. 

Last edited by Arthur P. Bloom

Good to know. Always liked the scale-er pieces - and I had the fixed-door 6464-sized boxcar at one time; traded it. Unfortunately, I became aware of KMT, etc, a little too late, and they are no longer cheapies, I guess (I'd better go do some Bay-lurking). But, I can enjoy a modern product of old dies - or copies of old dies - in a way that appreciates the DNA - that Wms boxcar shell, for example. 

Add Reply

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×