Skip to main content

LionChief Plus Product Review

     LionChief Plus • This video is a Product Review about the LionChief Plus RS-3, Diesel Locomotive. I will be running a Rio Grande but will show all 4 road names for this Lionel Locomotive. I will also talk about the features on the remote and how to use them, along with all the control switches on the underside of the locomotive. Also a brief history on the full size RS-3.

     Any question or comments, please post.

Gary - Cheers from The Detroit and Mackinac Railway - "A Toy Train Layout"

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Gary,

Thank you for another very well done review.  How did you know the RS3 is one of the few diesels I like?  I liked your introduction, use of graphics to give more information on the engine or to highlight what you were saying! and showing how it runs smoothly at slow speeds.  You showed us the main features, how to put it through the paces, and how easy it is to control.  The constant speed feature is a nice one, I agree.  The RS3 looks good, and sounds pretty good.  Personally, I think the sound quality is the only downside to the LionChief Plus, but compared to the Legacy, I think it is good for the price.  I do appreciate the effort you take to make these videos, your workmanship is top notch!  Thank you!

Originally Posted by Ken-Oscale:

I enjoyed your review - thanks!   BTW, what track are you using?  

Hi Ken - I started this layout in 1983 with Lionel "O" Tubular track with home made wooden ties, on a cork bed with ballast.

      In about 1997, the layout went through a major do over and at this point I started using K-Line shadow rail on a cork roadbed. The cork roadbed is spray painted a flat gray, and in part of the layout I have painted the outer edge of the tubular track with a rust colored paint.

     What you see in the video is all K-Line Shadow Rail, that I purchased from a K-Line Super Store. K-Line and Lionel Switches. If I ever do a major do over again. I would use GarGraves O Gauge Flex Track with Ross Switches.

     Hope this helps, what track do you use on your layout?

Gary

Cheers from The

DETROIT AND MACKINAC RAILWAY PASSENGER CAR v3

Attachments

Images (1)
  • DETROIT AND MACKINAC RAILWAY PASSENGER CAR v3

My grandchildren, have been over for the past two nights and they are coming back for an over night again this week.  We have a lot of fun running the trains. Using the LionChief Plus Controller and conventional trains. The LionChief Plus, gives the operator two ways to run trains. See diagram below., from the Lionel Manual.Manual Page 5 Final for iMovie

Cheers from The Detroit and Mackinac Railway

Attachments

Images (1)
  • Manual Page 5 Final for iMovie

Hi Dave:

The LionChief Plus, only works with the LionChief Controller, that is assigned to that locomotive. Think of it as a garage door opener, you would not want to share that radio channel with your neighbor. I also belong to two Radio Controlled Airplane Clubs, we all now fly on one frequency. That is 2,4GHz. the Receiver & Transmitter will find each other and keep them together. Just like a garage door opener. 

Legacy, TMCC & DCS are not compatible, with LionChief or LionChief Plus. Lionel is going to be shipping a Universal Remote, this spring that with remember any 3 locomotives that are assigned to the universal remote and can be changed at any time. 

I just purchased today my 3rd LionChief Plus Locomotive, Rio Grande FT, A-B-A Units. I like this system because when I have visitors to the train room, they each get a locomotive and a controller. No sharing a Legacy Remote or a DCS Remote. One more thing, if my MTH / TIU / or DCS Controller does not work, I have 19, locomotive that are dead on the tracks. If a LionChief Plus loco goes down, only one engine is dead on the tracks.

Hope this helps, always enjoy talking with you about trains. GaryDETROIT AND MACKINAC RAILWAY Cheers from PASSENGER CAR v6

Attachments

Images (1)
  • DETROIT AND MACKINAC RAILWAY Cheers from PASSENGER CAR v6
Garfield posted:

If you switch it over to conventional transformer controlled do the engine sounds still work?

Can you activate the horn and bell with your transformer?

 

For LionChief Plus only, you can switch it to conventional mode and run with a transformer.  Yes, you have the whistle and bell available with standard transformer controls.  For the plain LionChief, it ONLY runs with it's remote or the new 3-button LC remote.

Last edited by gunrunnerjohn
Pine Creek Railroad posted:

Gary & Guns,

   Bummer I was hoping Lionel Engineered the Lion Chief Plus to run both ways, with it's own remote control, and with the Legacy Cab2.  I understand the stand alone LC package, but why not make the Plus a real big engineering Plus!

PCRR/Dave

COST, Plain and Simple it comes down to the MONEY. LC electronics and an underpowered wall wart are cheaper to put in starter sets, LC+ would have been better produced as TMCC/Legacy compatible, but IMHO Lionel dropped the ball.

YMMV,

Doug

I tend to agree somewhat with both Doug and John above; Cost, and not competing with higher end products.  The competing point has been discussed in length in other posts in this forum.  as for cost, it would take not only the cost of the Legacy R4LC( or whatever they are using) radio board, but also the design time to incorporate an entirely different protocol in the LC+ microprocessor.  I can't see it being cost effective to place both systems in an LC+ loco, when the electronics package chosen is insanely low cost to produce as is.  

On the other hand it would also be painfully simple for Lionel to release a product that connects to a TMCC/Legacy system that would allow control of LC/LC+ engines.  I used an arduino and a salvaged LC remote for a test and things worked fine, however having the actual wireless protocol in use would make things much simpler.  

JGL

gunrunnerjohn posted:

I've thought about the possibility of building a product like the Legacy PowerMaster Bridge that would connect to LC/LC+ locomotives and use TMCC commands to drive them from TMCC/Legacy, that would be cool.  As you say, having the command protocol would be really useful if you wanted to do that.

 Hi John - Interesting proposal, I am not sure it would sell. I like the LionChief Plus for a lot of reasons but the old engineering term would be at the top of my list, "K. I. S. S."

This term can be found in most Engineering Text Books, old as dirt.

Keep It Simple Stupid = K. I. S. S.  lol

If you do go forward, I would like to be a beta tester.

Gary

Last edited by trainroomgary

This has been discussed, and you will see just as many post about why can't an LC be controlled by TMCC or Legacy.  So I do think it is viable from a sales perspective.  Allows LC/LC+ to be controlled by third source.  May increase LC+ purchases by Legacy users while retaining the simple for Larry approach.

(Larry, I really wonder how hard this is for you considering how well you can manipulate computer software and create slide shows with notes and such.)

The marketing concern would be does this off set Upper end Legacy sales.  Seems like it would be easy enough for Lionel to execute.   G

I think the easiest way to do it would be to make something like I suggested, the LC/LC+ Legacy bridge.  It would be a single product that would handle anything that the universal remote would handle in a similar manner.  I don't know that Lionel has any incentive to produce such a product, but it certainly wouldn't be difficult for them to do so, given they have all the specifications for the protocols involved.

gunrunnerjohn posted:

I think the easiest way to do it would be to make something like I suggested, the LC/LC+ Legacy bridge.  It would be a single product that would handle anything that the universal remote would handle in a similar manner.  I don't know that Lionel has any incentive to produce such a product, but it certainly wouldn't be difficult for them to do so, given they have all the specifications for the protocols involved.

Same thing I said a year ago when all this was being discussed.  Wouldn't surprise me if this comes out in a few years after everything levels out, and you need another product to boost sales.  Especially if customers are asking for it.  G

Hi John:

Check out this link about the history of the K.I.S.S. Principle. It is about the design process, not about you as a electrical designer. We will find out Lionel’s new direction for LionChief Plus in the next catalog for 2016, about the 2nd week of February. No suggestion being made, I am still interested in your project, because I have 3 LionChief Plus on my layout and may add more if Lionel does more with LionChief Plus in the next catalog for 2016.

 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/KISS_principleKISS principal

Click on above screenshot to read.

Gary

Attachments

Images (1)
  • KISS principal

GGG,

   I agree 100% Lionel will make the interface, as time goes on and the people like us start asking for it.  I actually think this is a Lionel long range engineering plan, Guns if I were you I would beat them to it, with a simple in-expensive transfer unit of some type.  If I was an Electrical Engineer I would already be working on it.  Heck Lionel might even purchase the engineering from you!  Really like the simple Hand Held Remote for the kids, one of my 6 year old nieces was playing with my new Hallmark/Lionel Santa Toy Maker Express this afternoon and having a ball, the kid friendly Hand Held is a great sales tool, I would not eliminate it, I would do as you indicated and engineer some kind transfer box to allow additional Legacy control also.  IMO the sales market would be there, I would purchase one right now, a lot of other owners would also.

PCRR/Dave

Last edited by Pine Creek Railroad
poniaj posted:

Gary,

Great job on the video!  Very enjoyable, and thanks for including the type of equipment you used in its production.  A very professional presentation. 

Hi Jerry - Thanks for the compliment about the professional presentation. I have to admit, I had help. Took several classes at my local Apple Retail Store. The classes were on "How to use iMovie version 10.1.1. The instructor also had a lot of objectives for using iMovie with You Tube. There are also a lot of How Too Channels on YT, like this one.

Hope you find this Tutorial on iMovie 2016 helpful, this new version of iMovie works just like Final Cut Pro, but with out the big price tag. The reason Apple changed iMovie and made it like Final Cut Pro was to get video editors to move up to Final Cut Pro.

When it first came out it sold for over $2000, now it is $300 and iMovie comes free on Apple Computers.

Gary - Cheers from The Detroit and Mackinac Railway

Last edited by trainroomgary

Add Reply

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×