Skip to main content

I have been looking on the QT for this engine, but for the right price. During my first York trip one popped up for 575.00. It had some "side swipe"cosmetic damage but for the price I figured it was worth the plunge, I am and operator / runner and a few touch ups it will look top notch.

The first thing I noticed was the HEFT! Holy smokes, is this the heaviest diesel locomotive that Lionel has ever made? Next to my 1601 Allegheny I have not seen anything so heavy...

The smoke units I have not fully understood their functions, but when they came on I immediately started to wheeze, so I have not figured out the full function of these. I think my glasses had smoke oil on them!

The Details are amazing and everything is metal or cast metal ... this thing is a real HAUS.  Even the tender has all die cast metal details and if feels of quality with its separately applied details and hand railings.

Functions of the front head lights are stellar; working green markers, front red warning stop light, complete with flashing headlights when its on the move.  When you hit the reverse both the tender light and rear head light of the locomotive chime in. Very nice.

The volume of sound was  above average. Not too loud and distorted, and not a disappointing muffle like some of the new legacy diesels. I like the turbine noises when they kick in as you turn the speed up a bit. I could not find the volume switch on the locomotive. My directions were missing on this unit. But I will have to look them up.

As far as running in TMCC mode with a Legacy Cab 2 - I was able to effectively get a very slow start by adjusting the stall speed backward and forward. I still notice a slight speed jump on certain speeds, but with some light oil and a little grease, I was able  to effectively eliminate these. Of course an ERR cruise commander M will be on the list of upgrades, and I am sure it will operate even smoother.

Considering the complexity and quality of this engine I figured it would not be on the reissue list for some time soon... and if it was, the price will probably be over 1,800.00!

Pictures:

 20160501_23203020160501_23202420160501_23195620160501_231949

 

Attachments

Images (4)
  • 20160501_232030
  • 20160501_232024
  • 20160501_231956
  • 20160501_231949
Last edited by J Daddy
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

I have one this is my 3rd I had to sell the last 2 to finance my train room, It has always been on my wanted list and I found one and its a BEAST , Do I wish they do it in legacy oh yeah but it is a awesome runner and it goes great with my #80 coal turbine DD40X and Propane Turbine, For that price you did great enjoy and keep running

fl9turbo2 posted:

I have one this is my 3rd I had to sell the last 2 to finance my train room, It has always been on my wanted list and I found one and its a BEAST , Do I wish they do it in legacy oh yeah but it is a awesome runner and it goes great with my #80 coal turbine DD40X and Propane Turbine, For that price you did great enjoy and keep running

You have to show us some pictures! I googled some photos and it looks like I could run some steel side reefers behind it and my JLC or Vision Line Big Boy as well!

veranda_02up-veranda-65up-62-veranda

Attachments

Images (3)
  • veranda_02
  • up-veranda-65
  • up-62-veranda

Truly a spectacular locomotive on all counts! Are you sure you want to mess with the electronics via an upgrade, fine as ERR products are? A friend who owns over a dozen LARGE/LONG Lionel locomotives considers his UP Veranda among his best and smoothest runners. Perhaps a hold ‘til the TMCC or Odyssey board(s) fail .  .  .  ? 

fl9turbo2 posted:

there was a additional piece of paper that came with the manual that told you how to turn on the smoke units from the tmcc remote so they can work correctly its a tricky series of keys to make them work if I could make a copy I will post it

Yes  - on the manual If found these notes... not sure I will be able to commit them to memory...

UP Smoke

Attachments

Images (1)
  • UP Smoke
OddIsHeRU posted:

Truly a spectacular locomotive on all counts! Are you sure you want to mess with the electronics via an upgrade, fine as ERR products are? A friend who owns over a dozen LARGE/LONG Lionel locomotives considers his UP Veranda among his best and smoothest runners. Perhaps a hold ‘til the TMCC or Odyssey board(s) fail .  .  .  ? 

I totally agree. If its not broke don't fix it... and with the curse I have with killing electronics with one fatal touch... I will wait until the need arises.

Besides I have a set of Lionel Burlington E-5's that will need the board replacement first.

I think if you mess with the electronics the smoke units no longer work correctly, some people (including myself) have had problems with the smoke units not  working the way the should sometimes wile the loco is moving the back smoke unit works and not the front.  This was a problem and it had at the time was the first generation odyssey system and you had to practice to set it, That's why I am hoping for a legacy version with the latest systems.    

Last edited by fl9turbo2
fl9turbo2 posted:

I think if you mess with the electronics the smoke units no longer work correctly, some people (including myself) have had problems with the smoke units not  working the way the should sometimes wile the loco is moving the back smoke unit works and not the front.  This was a problem and it had at the time was the first generation odyssey system and you had to practice to set it, That's why I am hoping for a legacy version with the latest systems.    

Well I am still reading up on the smoke units but I believe in the manual the front unit is supposed to turn on and the rear unit turns off after a certain speed is reached... Cool feature but lots of smoke... choke, choke...

Thanks for the heads up on the DCDS swap... seems to me the more I work on these the more variants I find.

 

if its just like the tmcc version I would buy it the sound would be better the odyssey would be  better and the smoke may be better but I would bet lionel would forget the smoke system its hard to make it  work reliable, look what happened to the vision line genset it had something like the veranda smoke unit. And that had issues then lionel went to a single smoke unit

I have this, it's a fun model.   The rear smoke unit is the diesel prime mover, that runs at slow speeds.  When you get up to a certain speed, the main stack (the turbine) takes over.  I'm not sure what the talk about setting stall speed is, this engine has Odyssey, so you shouldn't need the stall speed setting.

It should be a pretty reliable runner, it has four pickups and lots of wheels on the outer tracks.

gunrunnerjohn posted:

I have this, it's a fun model.   The rear smoke unit is the diesel prime mover, that runs at slow speeds.  When you get up to a certain speed, the main stack (the turbine) takes over.  I'm not sure what the talk about setting stall speed is, this engine has Odyssey, so you shouldn't need the stall speed setting.

It should be a pretty reliable runner, it has four pickups and lots of wheels on the outer tracks.

I set the stall speed to reduce the initial lurch when it starts up.

Above:

"Holy smokes, is this the heaviest diesel locomotive that Lionel has ever made?"

Couldn't be. It's not a "diesel". It's a gas turbine. Like Airbus and others use to make airplanes fly.

Not a diesel. It does have a small diesel engine on board to run accessories (the turbine spins at tens of thousands of RPM's) and to move around the yard (the turbine gulps fuel and is efficient only at high, fairly constant, speeds - just like steam turbines.)

I have one; runs well, weak smoke, and it can stop a wee bit suddenly - and I mean a wee bit. It's fine. No lurch.

The auxiliary diesel (see above) background sound is much too loud to be realistic at track speeds.

Yes no lurch . watch in Norm's second video frame 1:03. The adjustment of the stall and momentum setting can be optimized to reduce the "sudden start" as seen here.

My older Allegheny cab no. 1601 had the same issue, but no stall adjustment could help it....  thus I replaced the original DCDS board with an ERR board

Last edited by J Daddy

I see nothing in Norm's video that looks like a lurch, and his complete description of the video doesn't seem to suggest any issue.  All I saw at 1:03 was the turbine smoke unit kick in.

In December 2007, I filmed this fully diecast beast running under Legacy control. Using the RR Speeds, the TMCC speed steps could be incrementally applied, giving nice and gradual wind-ups in speed. At some fixed step, the Veranda's firmware would kick in the main turbine smoker while shutting the 'donkey motor' smoker off. A very cool and unique feature. I sort of regret selling this engine off, but it went to a good home...

Is there an online instruction manual for the 18149 turbine? Have no idea where to look for it on the Lionel site. I just picked up one at York for a bargain price but there are a couple of issues that I need to try and figure out. Like how to make the tender backup light work and the coupler work on it. Not real fluent in Tmcc. The instruction manual wasn't in the box when I bought it. Any help would be appreciated.

gunrunnerjohn posted:

I see nothing in Norm's video that looks like a lurch, and his complete description of the video doesn't seem to suggest any issue.  All I saw at 1:03 was the turbine smoke unit kick in.

In December 2007, I filmed this fully diecast beast running under Legacy control. Using the RR Speeds, the TMCC speed steps could be incrementally applied, giving nice and gradual wind-ups in speed. At some fixed step, the Veranda's firmware would kick in the main turbine smoker while shutting the 'donkey motor' smoker off. A very cool and unique feature. I sort of regret selling this engine off, but it went to a good home...

Never mind John...

J Daddy posted:
gunrunnerjohn posted:

I see nothing in Norm's video that looks like a lurch, and his complete description of the video doesn't seem to suggest any issue.  All I saw at 1:03 was the turbine smoke unit kick in.

In December 2007, I filmed this fully diecast beast running under Legacy control. Using the RR Speeds, the TMCC speed steps could be incrementally applied, giving nice and gradual wind-ups in speed. At some fixed step, the Veranda's firmware would kick in the main turbine smoker while shutting the 'donkey motor' smoker off. A very cool and unique feature. I sort of regret selling this engine off, but it went to a good home...

Never mind John...

Don't go away mad, I'm really trying to understand the issue.  Am I missing something?

John,

Told you it was a "BEAST"! I bought mine a few years ago from Fl9turbo2 here on ogr and extremely happy that I got one. They initially sold for $1100 street price and now you can get one for half that price. I'd rather buy one of these than a Legacy diesel. I say this is the ultimate in diesel/turbine engines to have!

Really thinking of getting a 2nd one to double head and almost bought another one at the last York. Saw a few at around $600.

gunrunnerjohn posted:
J Daddy posted:
gunrunnerjohn posted:

I see nothing in Norm's video that looks like a lurch, and his complete description of the video doesn't seem to suggest any issue.  All I saw at 1:03 was the turbine smoke unit kick in.

In December 2007, I filmed this fully diecast beast running under Legacy control. Using the RR Speeds, the TMCC speed steps could be incrementally applied, giving nice and gradual wind-ups in speed. At some fixed step, the Veranda's firmware would kick in the main turbine smoker while shutting the 'donkey motor' smoker off. A very cool and unique feature. I sort of regret selling this engine off, but it went to a good home...

Never mind John...

Don't go away mad, I'm really trying to understand the issue.  Am I missing something?

LOL.  Not mad. I guess you have to see it on video.  I can manipulate the start on this thing from a crawl. Where as before it just jumped into motion. 

Ted Bertiger posted:

John,

Told you it was a "BEAST"! I bought mine a few years ago from Fl9turbo2 here on ogr and extremely happy that I got one. They initially sold for $1100 street price and now you can get one for half that price. I'd rather buy one of these than a Legacy diesel. I say this is the ultimate in diesel/turbine engines to have!

Really thinking of getting a 2nd one to double head and almost bought another one at the last York. Saw a few at around $600.

Ted - If you got two of these things and MU ed them together that would be crazy. I bet they could pull over 100 cars. 

JDaddy,      I agree with all, there is something, everything, about this engine that makes it the best.  I have never had any problems with mine, other than I have not been running much of late, and it is sitting in a display case.  However, when I started working on my layout years ago (before all the storms hit us) I ran it along with other U.P. motive power, and pulled some very long consists around my incomplete 24 x 28 space.  It is a beast, and if anyone should ever figure a way to keep PS1 sounds and have TMCC control, would like to double head with my MTH version.

Jesse     TCA

Attachments

Images (3)
  • 100_7574
  • Lionel Mod 6-18149  U.P. Veranda Turbine no.73
  • MTH 20-2185-1 UP Veranda #75
Last edited by texastrain

I still regret parting with this engine but it did go to a nice home. The first speed step was always a bit faster than a typical Odyssey diesel of that mid 2000s era. It most certainly didn't have Odyssey lurch, which was fixable issue of the time. This was characterized by a full open loop launch upon application of the first speed step after initial power up, or more annoyingly, a power cycle due to power loss, etc.

Phil Gresho had one of these with an Odyssey on/off switch that was installed backwards from what I remember. You may want to verify that you are actually in cruise mode (hold onto a coupler while applying the first speed step and see if pulls harder or stalls).

This may be one of the first diesels Lionel made with back-drivable gearing, you can actually push this by hand and roll the drivers.

The back driveable gears was a feature that surprised me when I first fired it up, I thought that didn't come until Legacy.  I bought mine in the forum recently, and I'm glad I got it, it is a unique piece.

I agree with Norm about checking the switch.  I start out smoothly at the first speed step when running in TMCC mode with the CAB2.  It doesn't start up quite as slow as my Legacy stuff, but there is no lurch anywhere in the speed spectrum with mine.

texastrain posted:

JDaddy,      I agree with all, there is something, everything, about this engine that makes it the best.  I have never had any problems with mine, other than I have not been running much of late, and it is sitting in a display case.  However, when I started working on my layout years ago (before all the storms hit us) I ran it along with other U.P. motive power, and pulled some very long consists around my incomplete 24 x 28 space. It is a beast, and if anyone should ever figure a way to keep PS1 sounds and have TMCC control, would like to double head with my MTH version.

Jesse     TCA

There was Digital Dynamics, a TMCC card which kept the PS1 sounds. There is a HUGE, HUGE market for these today. Too bad it went the way of the Legacy upgrade kit...

Ted Bertiger posted:

... They initially sold for $1100 street price and now you can get one for half that price. I'd rather buy one of these than a Legacy diesel. I say this is the ultimate in diesel/turbine engines to have!

...

Absolutely agree.  

This hobby is completely unpredictable at times.    We have folks tripping over themselves to buy die-cast ES44 Legacy diesels at nearly twice their original MSRP, and then there's this wonderful beast of a die-cast diesel going for nearly half of what it once did.    Go figure!

Under $600 for this gem is an absolute steal.  If I still had mine, I'd keep it rather than let it go for so little today.  It is really a unique piece.  I suppose folks are anticipating a Legacy version, which may account for the current price-drop.  But even that doesn't quite make sense -- since we know Lionel would make folks pay through the nose and then some for a die-cast Legacy version. 

As it was... The TMCC locomotive took forever to get manufactured.  Originally it was planned to have an Odyssey MOTOR, but then Lionel scrapped that idea and went with just the Odyssey SYSTEM.  Following that whole marketing debacle, there were then reportedly more delays due to issues with the die-cast shell.  So lots of folklore behind the Lionel Veranda.

David

Last edited by Rocky Mountaineer
Norm Charbonneau posted:

I'd really like to see someone lower one of these beasts, put Kadees on it, and weather it like the above photos.

Sounds like a challenge - would be nice if lowering it was as easy as the F3's. I have some brass sheet in the scrap box that I may be able to tackle that pilot first...

BobbyD, yes, I have one DD board installed in another engine, and wish I had gotten more, but who knew they were to go under?

John, yes, I have been following that thread and also wonder what became of the optimistic chatter that was being read on there.  The market is "out there" no doubt.........

I have upgraded other pieces of U.P. motive power I have to TMCC/RS with ERR.  A thought..... why have ERR, or other upgrade available, or have they, considered a version of "RS" making use of the QSI turbine sounds?   Would this really be so difficult to do, to the point it would not be practical financially?   Even to re-format the same turbine sounds into the RS version and take it from there?  I have several other turbines I wish to upgrade ( my opinion, mind you) to TMCC, but wish to fully retain the unique turbine sounds.  Along with the sounds that are in the MTH DD40AX........

Just wondering... and hoping..... and wishing......  LOL!!!!

 

Jesse    TCA

Attachments

Images (4)
  • MTH 20-2178-1 U.P. DD40AX
  • MTH 20-2185-1 UP Veranda #75
  • MTH 20-2214LS  U.P. 80 Gas Turbine
  • MTH 20-2261-1 U.P. Propane Turbine no.57
texastrain posted:
A thought..... why have ERR, or other upgrade available, or have they, considered a version of "RS" making use of the QSI turbine sounds?   Would this really be so difficult to do, to the point it would not be practical financially?   Even to re-format the same turbine sounds into the RS version and take it from there?  I have several other turbines I wish to upgrade ( my opinion, mind you) to TMCC, but wish to fully retain the unique turbine sounds.  Along with the sounds that are in the MTH DD40AX........

Just wondering... and hoping..... and wishing......  LOL!!!!

Don't hold your breath.  I'm fairly certain that the lack of unique sounds for ERR upgrades is as much or more a marketing decision as it is a technical consideration.  Lionel doesn't want to impact the sales of their new products with lower profit upgrade packages.

Last edited by gunrunnerjohn
J Daddy posted:
gunrunnerjohn posted:

Sounds like the cruise is switched off or has a problem.  I see nothing like this.

Norm makes notes about it too in his UP Veranda video. I took notes from him a few years back in how to tweak the older TMCC units using the CAB 2. It really makes a difference!

 

I wish I could get mine to smoke like that..    Both smoke units especially the front one has never put out more then a few wisps of smoke on its best day.  The smokeless dog has been sitting on a shelf now for at least the past 5 years.   

Joe 

JC642 posted:

I wish I could get mine to smoke like that..    Both smoke units especially the front one has never put out more then a few wisps of smoke on its best day.  The smokeless dog has been sitting on a shelf now for at least the past 5 years.   

Joe 

It should be pretty easy to get it smoking properly, most likely a simple maintenance on the smoke unit is all that's required.

gunrunnerjohn posted:
JC642 posted:

I wish I could get mine to smoke like that..    Both smoke units especially the front one has never put out more then a few wisps of smoke on its best day.  The smokeless dog has been sitting on a shelf now for at least the past 5 years.   

Joe 

It should be pretty easy to get it smoking properly, most likely a simple maintenance on the smoke unit is all that's required.

I replaced the batting and removed the covers over the heating elements and it smoked me out of the room  

Steam Guy posted:

Hi Guys,

 

Great topic with loads of useful information.

I have a question and I know it hijacks this thread but does anyone have information on that UP 3 unit turbine No.80 that is pictured in one of the above photos?  Lionel or MTH?  Has anyone posted photos/videos of that model?

Thanks in advance,

Steve

 

lionel has only done the veranda MTH has done the the veranda the 3piece big blow turbine and the #80 coal turbine and the propane turbine, one can only hope lionel will do another turbine as for videos not sure if there any other ones

Moonson, you say your MTH Veranda is number 61?  Mine is numbered 75.... and is PS1.  Is yours a later version, hopefully PS2 or PS3, and what year production?  Mine runs very good, just not as detailed as the Lionel, and not die cast.  I do like running them at the same time, just on different tracks, the Lionel in TMCC and the MTH conventional with the Cab1.  Yes, a very fine looking layout you have, sir.  I will be glad when I can show pics of my layout after I have gotten back to it and with an input of the needed hours.

Jesse     TCA

Steam Guy Steve,      the MTH Union Pacific #80 Coal Turbine is an older PS1 model from the early, early 2000.  The cat number is 20-2214LS, do not know whether MTH or anyone else has produced this model since then.  I did my best to acquire all the various turbines at the time, wishing now I had kept my Big Blow Turbine, but sold to a club member and used the funds to purchase one of the JLC Challengers, so I feel it was well justified, and am quite pleased.

Hope you are able to find one at a very good price.  I do like mine very well, as I do all my turbines... well, all my U.P. motive power!

John and GGG...   How difficult would it be to acquire a Lionel RS for the DD40AX, as Lionel did release one, themselves?  I do not believe ERR has a sound card for the DD40AX sounds, do they, that could go with a TMCC upgrade?  Perhaps I can get this one done, myself, and see about what comes from the idea of TMCC and retaining PS1/QSI sounds.

Jesse     TCA

 

John, I don't get to look through all the Lionel catalogs, but did they not make a DD35 or something similar a couple years ago?  I recall seeing them advertised somewhere in both powered and dummy units, and if so, wouldn't the sound used be that of the same type engine arrangement for motive power?   Just thinking.... I know, a dangerous path to go down........ LOL!!

Jesse   TCA

texastrain posted:

Steam Guy Steve,      the MTH Union Pacific #80 Coal Turbine is an older PS1 model from the early, early 2000.  The cat number is 20-2214LS, do not know whether MTH or anyone else has produced this model since then. 

John and GGG...   How difficult would it be to acquire a Lionel RS for the DD40AX, as Lionel did release one, themselves?  I do not believe ERR has a sound card for the DD40AX sounds, do they, that could go with a TMCC upgrade?  Perhaps I can get this one done, myself, and see about what comes from the idea of TMCC and retaining PS1/QSI sounds.

Jesse     TCA

 

1.  MTH released a PS2 version of #80 coal turbine model a few years back. Sound and control are of course a big improvement on the PS1 version. I have run both and both smoke like chimneys.

2.  Lionel has not made a DDA40X whereas MTH has made them in PS1 and PS2 (not sure about PS3) and some of the PS1s were in non-UP liveries. The DD35s made by Lionel 2 or 3 years ago are not as impressive as the MTH DDA40X, IMO, either for detailing or operating features. I've always thought Lionel missed a trick by not issuing a DDA40X but then MTH has probably grabbed that piece of the market.

3.  There are DCC sound sets for the DDA40X but as far as I know only MTH has made a 3Rail/AC O scale version.

Hancock, thanks for the information and updates.   I have been out of the "loop" for a few years with working out of town and occupied with construction management for far too long, have a lot of catching up to do.  Now that I retired, when I can, doing my darnest to fill in the voids and see what I can do to upgrade and have all my motive power under one control system..... preferably TMCC.  Good enough for me and what I have invested into.  Again, thanks you for the input.

Jesse     TCA

Add Reply

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×