Skip to main content

Originally Posted by Adriatic:

Magoo have you tried out Anyrail or SCARM free track design programs. The realtrax is not in them. I think MTH sells a program. But some measuring, pick its size equal, and you should be able to come very close I would think. Ill see if I can repost that photo if you want. 

 

Adriatic, any help would be greatly appreciated.  I just downloaded scarm program on my work computer.  I have no idea what I am doing.  At home I have a mac.  I have the program from MTH but its not compatible with the MAC.  I am looking at the picture to get ideas and I am trying to figure out what works and what will not.  But I have to first learn how to use the Scarm program.  Thanks for all of your help!

Here' s posts by Mixey below, he is the author. It seems it is designed for Windows, Anyrail too, but I think you should read this paying note to Moonmans posts in particular, later a post by Mixey about the WINE program. You may be able to use it after all, maybe. Make your needs known by posting a Mac request too.

  In the meantime, if I had some solid dimensions on table size, MTH track dimensions, track you have, wall clearances, max kick-out and overhangs, loco & car lengths, etc. All listed in one place, or close to it. I wouldn't mind helping by "virtual building" and posting for you. It may not be speedy, or exact, because it wont be MTH, but I think we could get it close. Image files, real, or from programs, could be used by you, with "paint"(sorry Im mac illiterate), or similar program, to convey your ideas back to me. I think with some searching you will find a free mac program, but I cant suggest one over another, and I might not be able to run it on a windows/ibm format to help, but its worth a shot. https://ogrforum.ogaugerr.com/t...ello-from-the-author

As/if we go on, remember, I don't own plastic type track, nor do I do a lot of switching, or point to point. I'm a postwar Lionel looper, 40+ in conventional, Grandson of a truly serious collector. Some knowledge rubbed off. I don't consider myself an expert at anything, but like it proved when Im wrong(stubborn). I have played with MTH, TMCC, DCC, Digitrax, and more but never owned digital controls. No cab locos, and only a few diesel switchers I seldom run. A GG1, Virg. rectifier and steamers do my bidding. I have some electronics repair experience, but that was work("mouse house pizza/games") it included board, and power supply repair, spanned about 6rys before changing fields. Similar but not the same as train stuff. My schooling in electronics is zilch. I approach things logically, and its always worked out. Ive read at OGF for about 2 yrs, joined in the spring, couldn't resist any longer

 

An elevated addition, or an offset figure 8 to make one loop larger are my 1st thoughts. Grades for an elevated will require working the throttle more if in conventional. Dark grey you might be able to get the loco reversed by switching, but not the whole train. With a turn out added (yellow) your fig 8 is completed.  

 

This is what I had posted earlier

 

Just a note: Your name makes me smile every time I see it. "Mr Magoo" was one of my favorite cartoons growing up, Im a bit jealous too.

 

 

 

     

Originally Posted by Adriatic:

oops try this!

oooooohhhhhh, I like that!  I like the idea about having the track connected and adding another two switches!  I guess I need that cross track piece where your able to cross through???? ( I am so ignorant with the terms, so please be patient)  I am thinking about doing this in stages.  The reason is the wife!  What started out for just the kids has turned out to be my mad obsession!  The first thing i would like to do is possibly adding a siding to the track where it comes down the middle, have an O30 switch going left right after the other switch at the loop, and adding track to about the end with a bumper.  I will be able to add more trains to the table and yet keep some usable space for model building and such.

 

I like the diagram you made, I just dont have the funds to purchase all of the switches needed.  I like your ideas!  I was having some severe issues trying to see what I can and cant do!  I want to build some buildings preferbly a train passenger platform and would ultimately love to have a Intermodal container staging area!  I originally wanted a power plant with working smoke stack but there is nothing for O-scale!  

 

I really like the ideas you have come up with!  Today is my last day off for awhile so I was thinking of farting around with some stuff.

 

The nickname has been with me since I was a grade schooler!  I am 42 now and it has yet to leave me.  It all started with an upset coach and who couldn't spit out my last name fast enough so he said MAGOO!  Its been with me since!    Thanks for all of your assistance!  This site is truly amazing!

My teacher once told us this about computers, Apple = intuitive for the user, IBM(windows) = better user control. I still think it applies today. Just sayin.

The diagram is a bit of a spaghetti bowl, Im just trying to "grease the brain" with ideas. Until you have detailed scenery locked down, it can change in an afternoon.

I don't know your situation with the wife and don't mean to pry, But...... 

How my Gramps got by, till Grandma joined in, was a hobby/shopping fund equally split.

Eventually Grandma laid claim to ALL 1800's trains, and insisted on them being the only trains around the Christmas tree. Find out which ones your wife thinks look cool too, ask for her opinion on some things, if you can do so without lighting the fuse. Make it known when you use wallet constraint. Find someone "married" into trains too, split a couples evening between trains and ?, who knows. A mistake Gramps did make was being too involved with my Dads set when he was a boy, "too fast" "that doesn't go there" etc. The "rivet counting" drove my Dad away from trains. Gramps lightened up for the younger kids, and Grandkids, we are all owners of at least one set, but my Dad never played with any of us. Cheaper trains belonging to the kids themselves aren't a bad idea. Don't forget to ask before using them, if you expect the same

An industrial building with stacks is not too hard, I cant reference one, but they are out there. Seuthe (spelling?) makes smoke units small enough to fit in HO or even smaller things. Larger smoke units w/wo fans can be had new and used. Check this use of smoke units out https://ogrforum.ogaugerr.com/t...moking-stacks?page=3

Also remember, hobbies dont have timeclocks. Some guys plans aren't fully realized for years. Like, many years 5-10 or longer. 

 

Originally Posted by Adriatic:

My teacher once told us this about computers, Apple = intuitive for the user, IBM(windows) = better user control. I still think it applies today. Just sayin.

The diagram is a bit of a spaghetti bowl, Im just trying to "grease the brain" with ideas. Until you have detailed scenery locked down, it can change in an afternoon.

I don't know your situation with the wife and don't mean to pry, But...... 

How my Gramps got by, till Grandma joined in, was a hobby/shopping fund equally split.

Eventually Grandma laid claim to ALL 1800's trains, and insisted on them being the only trains around the Christmas tree. Find out which ones your wife thinks look cool too, ask for her opinion on some things, if you can do so without lighting the fuse. Make it known when you use wallet constraint. Find someone "married" into trains too, split a couples evening between trains and ?, who knows. A mistake Gramps did make was being too involved with my Dads set when he was a boy, "too fast" "that doesn't go there" etc. The "rivet counting" drove my Dad away from trains. Gramps lightened up for the younger kids, and Grandkids, we are all owners of at least one set, but my Dad never played with any of us. Cheaper trains belonging to the kids themselves aren't a bad idea. Don't forget to ask before using them, if you expect the same

An industrial building with stacks is not too hard, I cant reference one, but they are out there. Seuthe (spelling?) makes smoke units small enough to fit in HO or even smaller things. Larger smoke units w/wo fans can be had new and used. Check this use of smoke units out https://ogrforum.ogaugerr.com/t...moking-stacks?page=3

Also remember, hobbies dont have timeclocks. Some guys plans aren't fully realized for years. Like, many years 5-10 or longer. 

 

 

 

Very well said!  The wife just likes to break my chops!  LOL  I have too many hobbies now or so she says.  I do have to lighten up a bit with the kids.  My 7 year old is very interested but is equally interested in the computer.  My 4 year old likes it as well put lacks the understanding of trains do break!

 

Yeah, I have moved away from the industrial setting and now figure having a sort of intermodal depot setting that may work.  And your right.  I was in the car driving to the hobby store to buy the necessary stuff to modify the layout and I held back.  I may need to stand still a bit before I can go forward.  Your words and wisdom have been very helpful.  I still may do something soon, just need to play with the ideas in my head!

 

Thanks for all your help and if any other ideas some way comes around I will be grateful!

Unless the reversing bit is driving you nuts, ignore it for now. Teach/let that 7yr old switchman re-rail things, while the yardmaster watches with his feet up.     

Find a crane, build a crane, *whatevaaa! You keen do wut you wan*. If not now......ask Santa! I think you really need this to satisfy the itch. And the track plan might have to change some to have it. Heck, the way it looks it could be an investment(dont count on it) Find out the measurements of that Lionel one at least. Then you can map out its home(scratch,scratch). It seems like the only buy option anyway. Any modeling skills? Building a working stationary one, really might not be so hard. I'm telling you those scale crane guys use kits that work. Half cinderblocks, +sand, lifted nicely. Most I've seen are tower style, but I bet you can at least find a decent claw assembly to build from, or copy ideas off of.  

*Miley & Eric Cartman both.

Well I ordered the MTH Realtrax left hand siding pack(40-1026). I think this will give me more options in the future. I have another engine on order and will be used with the smaller LIRR rolling stock. My CSX will haul the intermodal rolling stock. And I will have space to dedicate a passenger platform to my Lionel LIRR M7. I am thinking of building the passenger platform myself. I think it will be an easier build. I was going to purchase the MTH passenger elevated platform but it appears dated and bulky. I have a intermodal container stack tractor (Joal) that will be used for the siding dedicated to my container cars. So it's slowly coming together. My next purchase will be the DCS remote. Where I will have the ability of more control of the trains.

What engine did you get? The coolest station platform Ive seen is the Knapford station for Thomas the train (Bachmann), but it is ho scale. I wonder if its big enough(wide) to raise it so an O train could fit. Even if only the roof could be used it would be cool. I saw a layout with 4 or six of them de-Thomas-ed. All that glass, WOW! was it sharp.

jj,

 

I think the suggested bump and go trolley track on an upper level would work out well on your layout.  It can be located above all the other tracks supported with homemade uprights (as in un-$$$)

 

The MTH bump and go's work great and cost about $50.  I set mine up with a pushbutton so that the kids hit the button and the trolley goes out and back, then stops, waiting for the next button press.

 

The MTH M&M's trolley is also bump and go and would work on the same PB-operated elevated track... again, only about $50.

 

Enjoy!

Ed

 

Originally Posted by Adriatic:

What engine did you get? The coolest station platform Ive seen is the Knapford station for Thomas the train (Bachmann), but it is ho scale. I wonder if its big enough(wide) to raise it so an O train could fit. Even if only the roof could be used it would be cool. I saw a layout with 4 or six of them de-Thomas-ed. All that glass, WOW! was it sharp.

 

 

I am going to try to build my own.  I figured it can't be that hard???

 

I placed an order for this:

http://mthtrains.com/content/30-20194-1

 

And then I think its safe to say I am done for awhile but the elevated train option certainly interest's me!!!

I did it!  I added the new siding!  I think it looks good!  I purchased the left hand siding package from MTH and it fit like OJ's glove!  The cool thing is in my opinion it doesn't make the layout look busy or crowded with stuff.  I enclosed a before and after pictures.
 Its coming together!!!
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Originally Posted by jjmmagoo:
Originally Posted by Adriatic:

oops try this!

oooooohhhhhh, I like that!  I like the idea about having the track connected and adding another two switches!  I guess I need that cross track piece where your able to cross through???? ( I am so ignorant with the terms, so please be patient)  I am thinking about doing this in stages.  The reason is the wife!  What started out for just the kids has turned out to be my mad obsession!  The first thing i would like to do is possibly adding a siding to the track where it comes down the middle, have an O30 switch going left right after the other switch at the loop, and adding track to about the end with a bumper.  I will be able to add more trains to the table and yet keep some usable space for model building and such.

 

I like the diagram you made, I just dont have the funds to purchase all of the switches needed.  I like your ideas!  I was having some severe issues trying to see what I can and cant do!  I want to build some buildings preferbly a train passenger platform and would ultimately love to have a Intermodal container staging area!  I originally wanted a power plant with working smoke stack but there is nothing for O-scale!  

 

I really like the ideas you have come up with!  Today is my last day off for awhile so I was thinking of farting around with some stuff.

 

The nickname has been with me since I was a grade schooler!  I am 42 now and it has yet to leave me.  It all started with an upset coach and who couldn't spit out my last name fast enough so he said MAGOO!  Its been with me since!    Thanks for all of your assistance!  This site is truly amazing!

 

IMG_1338

IMG_1339

IMG_1340

IMG_1341

Attachments

Images (4)
  • IMG_1338: Before
  • IMG_1339: After 1
  • IMG_1340: After 2
  • IMG_1341: after 3
Last edited by jjmmagoo
Originally Posted by Adriatic:

Hey I missed this, must have accidently tossed the email notification. Hows it working out for you?

 

 

So far so good!  I was able to smooth out some spots on the layout.  I then vacuumed the tracks and cleaned them.  Didn't want any metal residue messing up the works.  I am still on the fence on what i should do with the few sections of track that has a small gap.  Once again, thank you for your ideas and help!

 

IMG_1366

Attachments

Images (1)
  • IMG_1366: The finished wall!  Getting there!
Last edited by jjmmagoo

Add Reply

Post
The Track Planning and Layout Design Forum is sponsored by

AN OGR FORUM CHARTER SPONSOR

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×