Skip to main content

All:  over the last couple of years I have become very interested in pre war and want to build a layout to display it. I have noticed that most layouts seem to shy away from switches and are basic loops. I would also like to add a loop of standard gauge on the outermost part of the layout.  Questions .  are the older switches unreliable or do they restrict what size locos you run. and I know the larger the curve the better but what would i need in both gauges to cover running most tin plate. I have been in the 3 rail scale end of the hobby so I am not new to the hobby  just this portion of it.  Thanks  Rick

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Switches are good, but they do "screw up" more than just plain track. Lionel's switches are pretty reliable and some locos may have issues but only those with single 3-rail pick ups. or overly long wheel bases or overhangs. 

Lionel did not use them in their display layouts (even the ones on the showroom layout were primarily for show, as to simplify operation and avert catastrophies!

All tinplate O-gauge will run on O-72 curves. If you have the room, I highly recommend going with at least O-72. As for switches, that's a can of worms for sure. I'm building a layout much like your description (outside loop of Standard-Gauge and 2 loops of O-Gauge) and opted for the O-Line Reproductions switches with 12 of them on my layout (formerly RMT, formerly K-Line SuperSnap). Like any switches, they have their quirks, but so far everything--from 1920s tinplate up to  modern--runs through them and they've proven to be reliable. And an added bonus--they take up a lot less room than the traditional Lionel switches.  I did a LOT of research on the different switch brands before going with these. If you don't have the room for O-72, that will limit what you can run, but not by much. Off the top of my head, the prewar trains that need O72 curves are:  763E Hudsons, Hiawatha, and M10000 City of Portland. The 700E Hudson / Rail Chief cars also need O-72 but also require T-Rail track.  There may be more, but that's a good start. 

As for Standard Gauge, all prewar trains will run on the old 42" curves, but now there are a lot more options of other diameter curves. As usual, the wider, the better if you have the space. I suggest contacting Kirk at USA Track, www.standardgaugetrack.com . His track and service are second to none. For switches, nobody beats the Standard Gauge switches made by Ross Custom Switches: smooth operation, reversible switch machine, and all-around solid construction. 

Hope this helps.

John

Add Reply

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×