Skip to main content

Having a tough time with a track plan -most layouts I’ve had in the past were always more rectangular - my new trainroom is 20’ x 21’ - I’m looking to build the platform around 16’/17’ long by 14’ or so wide - any thoughts suggestions or good sources for “square” layouts

Thanks in advance

Joe S

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

As previously noted, the main problem with a 14x17 platform is easily reaching anything more than 2.5 feet away from any edge.  And, if you only put buildings and scenery in the middle, you will be wasting a lot of good railroad space.  Narrower tables laid out and connected to form an E, G, M or S shape, either partially along the walls or built completely in the center of the room, will allow for easier access to correct any problems that might arise.  Even if you prefer continuous running to modeling "operations," you can place "bulb" tables (maybe 7x7 so you can use O72 curves) at strategic points near the end of some letter part (but not against a wall) to allow reverse-loop to reverse-loop running.

Of course, any honest answer you get should inquire about the size of equipment, the number of accessories, and how you like to run your railroad.  In fact, copies of your earlier track plans along with that info I just mentioned will help anybody that wants to answer your question do a better job.

Chuck

Without knowing your age... If you expect the layout to exist after age 55 or so, avoid any situations where you will have to crawl to reach an access hole.  Good suggestions above regarding around-the-walls with a peninsula for a loop.  If you need access, consider building a lift-up or lift-out bridge.  Trust me - do as I say, not as I did.

Build it high enough so that you can sit on a rolling stool to do wiring and other work under the table.

I go along with geyser gazer and say go around the walls with a peninsula.    You can keep the around the walls area as narrow as you like - 30 inches is an easy reach but narrower may work better with a peninsula     with o7 2 curves the peninsula would only need to be about 6 1/2 feet wide.   Put a divider down the middle so you can't see across and you get 2 nice 3 foot wide areas for track and scenery.     You could have 3 foot aisles on each side of the peninsula and still have room for 3 foot areas along the walls.

There are a lot of great track plans with minimal 072 curves that require minimal 12 feet on the shorter side of the room if you desire to have that as min curve and want return loops. This type of design will narrow your reach with the consideration of two ways to access the return loops.

How do you like to run your trains and what kind of equipment do you like to run?

My layout room is square, but a little smaller than yours.  I had a lot of help from several Forum members to use the concept 42trainman used, keeping in mind the advice Mallard4468 gave about no crawling or popups; I'm 66 and have had orthopedic problems.  You never know what cards you will be dealt, as my late father-in-law used to say.  To get more runtime in we went with an upper and lower levels with 2 inclines connecting the two.

Mark Back to the Drawingboard jrw5c mab2

20230422_212427547_iOS

20230422_212905716_iOS

If I had more width, I would have added a peninsula as Lew suggested.  I used 054 curves, so it wasn't possible in an 11x11 room.

Attachments

Images (3)
  • Mark Back to the Drawingboard jrw5c mab2
  • 20230422_212427547_iOS
  • 20230422_212905716_iOS
Last edited by Mark Boyce

Add Reply

Post
The Track Planning and Layout Design Forum is sponsored by

AN OGR FORUM CHARTER SPONSOR

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×