Skip to main content

Was poking around on-line looking for a caboose for the Canadian Grain Train that Im putting together. Found a CP extended vision caboose on Ebay for $24.99 @ "buy it now"! Clicked on it, payed for it, bought it. Received it in the mail yesterday and was looking it over and noticed a bottle of smoke fluid in the box. I said, "whats this for". Read the instructions that comes with the caboose and what a surprise, It's a smoking caboose. I fired her up and smoke started billowing out the stack. What a deal!! Ive seen these things go for $50 and up. Way Cool!!

And it wasn't listed as a smoking caboose!!!

Last edited by Popi
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Originally Posted by Popi:

Im headed to Wisconsin on thur to visit my brother. we are going to Chicago great mid west train show on sunday. Ill be looking for a CP, CN or BC Rail Loco to go with my grain train. when I get it all put together, Ill post pics.

Don't forget to stop at the North Freedom Railroad Museum.

Last edited by josef
Originally Posted by Big_Boy_4005:

That one is from the Canadian Pacific limited set from 1989.

I saw that, and considered buying the SD40 that came with that set,

but after closer inspection found out that that locomotive is a cheap

MPC loco, with plastic trucks and plastic frame. very light weight with

no pulling power.

Originally Posted by Popi:
Originally Posted by sinclair:

I think your stack is missing the T top.  But nice caboose.

Is there suppose to be something on top of the stack???

I think the T-stack is, indeed, missing.  See link of similar Lionel item...

 

CP Caboose

 

Shouldn't be too much of a problem.  The style of caboose is common enough that a replacement part should be easy to obtain.

 

Nice deal, though!

 

KD

Originally Posted by Popi:
Originally Posted by Big_Boy_4005:

That one is from the Canadian Pacific limited set from 1989.

I saw that, and considered buying the SD40 that came with that set,

but after closer inspection found out that that locomotive is a cheap

MPC loco, with plastic trucks and plastic frame. very light weight with

no pulling power.

 

Originally Posted by sinclair:

I think your stack is missing the T top.  But nice caboose.

 

Guys,

 

I realize that people are trying to be helpful, but there's a lot of wrong information presented here.

 

1) The matching locomotive (6-18203 from 1989) has none of the low-end features you list. It has dual Pullmor motors, die-cast metal trucks, a metal frame and Magnetraction. "Old school" -- yes, but "cheap" -- no.

 

2) It doesn't look great, but there wasn't a smoke stack top designed for this particular caboose. It came from the factory just like your photograph.

 

TRW

Originally Posted by Norton:

Run it for about 5 minutes and check to see how warm the side of the car is. If this is a plastic caboose its common for the side closest to the smoke unit to melt.

Otherwise good deal.

 

Pete

I don't think its been run that often. It was basically brand new in the box. There was some shelf dust on it, looked like it was displayed. other than that its in great shape.

Originally Posted by dkdkrd:
Originally Posted by Popi:
Originally Posted by sinclair:

I think your stack is missing the T top.  But nice caboose.

Is there suppose to be something on top of the stack???

I think the T-stack is, indeed, missing.  See link of similar Lionel item...

 

CP Caboose

 

Shouldn't be too much of a problem.  The style of caboose is common enough that a replacement part should be easy to obtain.

 

Nice deal, though!

 

KD

Oh Ya! Ill have to chck the box again, other wise Ill make one to fit. that should be an easy fix. Thanks KD!!

Originally Posted by PaperTRW:
Originally Posted by Popi:
Originally Posted by Big_Boy_4005:

That one is from the Canadian Pacific limited set from 1989.

I saw that, and considered buying the SD40 that came with that set,

but after closer inspection found out that that locomotive is a cheap

MPC loco, with plastic trucks and plastic frame. very light weight with

no pulling power.

 

Originally Posted by sinclair:

I think your stack is missing the T top.  But nice caboose.

 

Guys,

 

I realize that people are trying to be helpful, but there's a lot of wrong information presented here.

 

1) The matching locomotive (6-18203 from 1989) has none of the low-end features you list. It has dual Pullmor motors, die-cast metal trucks, a metal frame and Magnetraction. "Old school" -- yes, but "cheap" -- no.

 

2) It doesn't look great, but there wasn't a smoke stack top designed for this particular caboose. It came from the factory just like your photograph.

 

TRW

I must have been looking at the wrong pic of The CP SD-40. It had plastic side truck frames.

Originally Posted by Popi:
Originally Posted by Norton:

Run it for about 5 minutes and check to see how warm the side of the car is. If this is a plastic caboose its common for the side closest to the smoke unit to melt.

Otherwise good deal.

 

Pete

I don't think its been run that often. It was basically brand new in the box. There was some shelf dust on it, looked like it was displayed. other than that its in great shape.

Its not so much how much track time its got on it but how long you run the smoke unit at one time as the heat gradually builds up inside and can result in this:

 

 

wp_caboose

 

Pete

Attachments

Images (1)
  • wp_caboose
Originally Posted by PaperTRW:
Originally Posted by Popi:
Originally Posted by Big_Boy_4005:

That one is from the Canadian Pacific limited set from 1989.

I saw that, and considered buying the SD40 that came with that set,

but after closer inspection found out that that locomotive is a cheap

MPC loco, with plastic trucks and plastic frame. very light weight with

no pulling power.

 

Originally Posted by sinclair:

I think your stack is missing the T top.  But nice caboose.

 

Guys,

 

I realize that people are trying to be helpful, but there's a lot of wrong information presented here.

 

1) The matching locomotive (6-18203 from 1989) has none of the low-end features you list. It has dual Pullmor motors, die-cast metal trucks, a metal frame and Magnetraction. "Old school" -- yes, but "cheap" -- no.

 

2) It doesn't look great, but there wasn't a smoke stack top designed for this particular caboose. It came from the factory just like your photograph.

 

TRW

TRW

your right on! I found this on Lionel web site.

http://www.lionel.com/CustomerService/ReplacementParts/index.cfm?doAction=productPartFilter&number=6-19705&productID=B96B43FF-68C9-49CD-90771CA598EB7C10&CFID=46204415&CFTOKEN=6778db3ae04ea4e8-97DDA7D7-F36D-FDFC-D659A6C7A56C3FA5&jsessionid=8430e9c448dbf8abbe98795d755063e2a645

Originally Posted by Norton:
Originally Posted by Popi:
Originally Posted by Norton:

Run it for about 5 minutes and check to see how warm the side of the car is. If this is a plastic caboose its common for the side closest to the smoke unit to melt.

Otherwise good deal.

 

Pete

I don't think its been run that often. It was basically brand new in the box. There was some shelf dust on it, looked like it was displayed. other than that its in great shape.

Its not so much how much track time its got on it but how long you run the smoke unit at one time as the heat gradually builds up inside and can result in this:

 

 

wp_caboose

 

Pete

Well I don't want that to happen. Think Ill pull her apart and see If I can put a heat shield inside her.

Originally Posted by PaperTRW:
Originally Posted by sinclair:

I think your stack is missing the T top.  But nice caboose.

2) It doesn't look great, but there wasn't a smoke stack top designed for this particular caboose. It came from the factory just like your photograph.

I did say "I think" not "you are" because I wasn't sure.  I personally haven't seen a smoking caboose without a T on top, but that doesn't mean it wasn't possible, just something Popi might want to look into, which he did and found out there wasn't one.

Well, I for one stand corrected!  After seeing the exploded parts diagram from Lionel, it's clear that they had no 'T-Stack' on this model.  There ya go!  Your ebay deal is as good as you first thought!  Attaboy!

 

I keep hoping for one of those..."deals"...a special find.  Ah, well, York is just a couple weeks away.   Just maybe......!

 

KD

I thought this was the only CP Rail Extended Vision caboose (6-17640) with a working smoke generator...

CP Rail...This one was listed for $95 on eBay. It came out in 2002.

 

The caboose in the first picture looks like it was from a CP Rail set from 1989. I think Lionel made 2 CP Rail "smoking" cabooses and the one in the first picture isn't one of them.

Attachments

Images (1)
  • CP Rail
Originally Posted by Russell:

Popi;

I was thinking the same thing.

I would cut open a soda can and space it half way between the wall and the smoke unit.

Also, I was thinking the Top of the stack may be missing due to temp of the area.

A plastic stack will certainly melt. A metal one will be very hot so keep kids fingers away.

I like that Idea, enjoy a soda and reuse the can for my caboose.

We train guys know how to "think green"!!

Originally Posted by catnap:

I thought this was the only CP Rail Extended Vision caboose (6-17640) with a working smoke generator...

CP Rail...This one was listed for $95 on eBay. It came out in 2002.

 

The caboose in the first picture looks like it was from a CP Rail set from 1989. I think Lionel made 2 CP Rail "smoking" cabooses and the one in the first picture isn't one of them.

yours also looks like it has an antenna running across the roof, which mine does not have.

Originally Posted by catnap:

Nicholas Smith Trains has the same caboose for $65.

 

I was surprised to see that is in fact a smoker. I'm not sure if it has lights or a detailed interior though.

 

That's still a great price ($24.99), however, lights/interior or not.

Mine did also come with lights.

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×