Skip to main content

Ordered late Thursday and gt it today. Pretty good service all considered.

I really like this structure. It is a little modern for my mid 1950's era layout....but I'll say it's brand new!! It looks great although if you look really close you can see a few of the 'tab and slot' connectors....most are well hidden. I see them as I have designed structure kits and have a much more critical eye than 99.999% of people.  Once on a layout no one will ever notice!!  The design is very good with lots of visual cues that make the building look much bigger than it is. Details are well done.....TONS of LED's all over....I keep finding new ones!  It looks like the structure is mostly laser cut MDF and ply. This may be the first mass produced laser cut assembled building....at least this large in O scale. Some parts look like milled wood. The vertical lines in the siding are actually engraved too.......Between all the laser cutting and engraving there is a lot of time put into this building.

The bad???  One VERY  small section on brick foundation was loose, not falling off, just a drop of Gorilla Glue and perfect. I worried that the stickers applied to the building side instructing power, plug location and sign options would mar but I took my time and they came off cleanly. 

The only improvement to be made would be a terminal post for power in case you do not want to use a barrel plug.....but very minor.

Between the size, details, lighting this may be Menard's best yet....and maybe the best value in assembled O scale structures. I give the building a A- overall. Packing a A-, value a A+.  If this is a sign of the direction Menard's is going......I see them becoming a modern 'Madison Hardware' of sorts. Thanks!!power

Attachments

Images (1)
  • power
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Mine comes tomorrow, excited, now more than ever after your great review! I think these buildings just keep getting better and they were very good to begin with! If I had the room I could picture a Menards only layout with just their buildings, their rolling stock, and their track, and just keep adding to it as they release more products! This would of course be in a separate building because my Dear wife would banish me from the house!! Lol

I have been checking my order status so much I wore out my keyboard. It was not that I am frugal and wanted to save shipping costs having it sent to the store. I thought one trip would be better then two but now that I see how long it takes to get to the store I think the next train order will be to the house so I can enjoy it more because I am jealous of those who are enjoying theirs now. But in the same vein I am so focused on Thursday for the next announcement..................Paul

AMCDAVE;      Did you ORDER the FREE Truck? It doesn't come automatically. It has to be ordered at the time the building was ordered. The cost is $14.99, but that gets subtracted when completing the order. My FREE trucks always come with the other item purchased and are in fact banded together so they are handled at the same time, and one box doesn't go one way and the other box another. If you did NOT order the truck, you are probably out of luck.

Hope that wasn't the case for your sake.

AMCDave posted:

It's on the invoice....we'll see....not a biggy.....thx

AMCDave,

Thanks for your review, we hope you thoroughly enjoy this building!

As far as the free truck goes, if it was on the invoice, it should be coming. Just let us know if it doesn't and we'll take car of it.

-Mark the Menards Train Guy

Got mine today as well.    Everything was perfect, no issues and the "Free" truck was "Piggy-Backed" onto the large box with plastic strapping material.  The building is very cool with plenty of LEDs for the lighting effect.   The Santa Fe truck was a nice "Perk" too.   This building will go very nicely with my Lionel Rotary Tipple, (actually, it's a Rotary Car Dumper).   Nice job Menards! 

Chief Bob (Retired) 

UnclePeteRR posted:

AMCDAVE, Can you peek at the neon sign please. Does it appear if you can gently

peal it off? I wanted to modify mine by putting on my own creation, I know some of the signs on the engine shop were removable. Thanks Chris

Looking at the sign it seems like it is surface mounted and would pop off if the edge was lifted. The thing is the replacement sign needs to be just slightly larger as there are engraved marks on the structure to help with location during assembly.....so those will need to be covered. thx

Hi all, Received mine yesterday in perfect condition and it's one nice building for sure.  Like Dave there was no truck,I opened the invoice and it was on there? There was no extra tape on the box or a mark from like a nylon strap to hold it.  

As far as adding the smoke the stacks sit on the roof with no hole which is no problem, the big thing I see is the stacks appear to be about 3/4" on the inside and would look silly (to me) if it only had a small wisp coming out of them.  I have to do some testing and see.

Doug

trnluvr posted:

Hi all, Received mine yesterday in perfect condition and it's one nice building for sure.  Like Dave there was no truck,I opened the invoice and it was on there? There was no extra tape on the box or a mark from like a nylon strap to hold it.  

As far as adding the smoke the stacks sit on the roof with no hole which is no problem, the big thing I see is the stacks appear to be about 3/4" on the inside and would look silly (to me) if it only had a small wisp coming out of them.  I have to do some testing and see.

Doug

My shippi ng box had no marks/tape that made it appear the truck was at one time attached.....so it sounds  like it happened more than just me.

 

GOOD thing is my truck is in the mail now...Menard's is first class.

Picked-up my Power & Light Building this afternoon at the local Menard's. I placed the order last friday and after some delay, I received notification yesterday, that it was in. Brought it home, unpacked it and using the adapter I plugged it in and turned on the switch. Only some of the lights came on...but I could get them all to light by playing with the switch and finding the sweet spot. The illuminated sign, however, does not work at all and when I checked for any loose wires the back side of the switch felt hot! I haven't read of anyone having any big issues with this release, so I was a little surprised when this occurred to mine. I have sent an email to Menard's CS and will see what they can offer as a remedy. The structure itself is quite nice overall and would be great addition when added to most layouts...

Last edited by UKE KAT

Got mine this morning. Had it sent to the store. That way I figured to kill two birds with one stone. I also needed lumber for my basement layout. That is where this building will be going. Did not open it till I got home but when I did the pictures do not do it justice. One heck of a building for the price. I cannot imagine what will be coming down the road but if this is a prelude then Menards I am ready to buy, buy, buy........................PaulDSCN2311

Attachments

Images (1)
  • DSCN2311

Just opened my Menard's Power and Light Building! Great looking building will look wonderful on any layout! One small thing, one of the roof vents was lose and tilted, but nothing a little glue cant fix. I still love the building and think Menard's is really showing how things should be made and for a fair price!

Just got home from a short stint in the hospital and there was a box waiting for me from Menard's with the Power and Light building.  What a great surprise.

In short, the building is terrific.  Well made, nice detail and a bunch of lighting.  I was pleasantly surprised at the size of it.  It is bigger than I imagined and it really looks like a big power plant building.   IMO another winner from Menard's.

The free vehicle is just icing on the cake.

Thanks,

Ed

 

 

Last edited by Ed Walsh

Add Reply

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×