Skip to main content

D500 posted:

Certainly imagination is critical with any modeling effort, trains or otherwise, but the lack of catenary crosses my line of an Imagination Bridge Too Far.

I..sort of...agree.  The only catenary electrics I have are postwar, and when running those, I don't hesitate to use "imaginary catenary."  But when running scale, I'd certainly prefer catenary, even if it was only dummy wire, and just for looks.

Trouble is, mine is (by necessity) a floor layout, and I can't imagine how I'd install catenary -- even dummy catenary -- on a basement-floor FasTrack layout.

Now, I love electrics, have several, but I find myself running only the NYC/some NH because these were outside third-rail locos (yes, the NH - some - were both). Being a NYC fan, running my P-2, T-3 and S-1/S-2 would be a tendency anyway.

I've fallen into the same pattern -- the only scale electric locomotive I run is my Lionel S1 NYC electric.  And I wouldn't mind a P- or T-motor to go with it.  But it'd still be nice to be able to accommodate a pantograph-equipped locomotive, if only I could figure out how.

 

 

Balshis posted:
D500 posted:

Certainly imagination is critical with any modeling effort, trains or otherwise, but the lack of catenary crosses my line of an Imagination Bridge Too Far.

I..sort of...agree.  The only catenary electrics I have are postwar, and when running those, I don't hesitate to use "imaginary catenary."  But when running scale, I'd certainly prefer catenary, even if it was only dummy wire, and just for looks.

Trouble is, mine is (by necessity) a floor layout, and I can't imagine how I'd install catenary -- even dummy catenary -- on a basement-floor FasTrack layout.

Now, I love electrics, have several, but I find myself running only the NYC/some NH because these were outside third-rail locos (yes, the NH - some - were both). Being a NYC fan, running my P-2, T-3 and S-1/S-2 would be a tendency anyway.

I've fallen into the same pattern -- the only scale electric locomotive I run is my Lionel S1 NYC electric.  And I wouldn't mind a P- or T-motor to go with it.  But it'd still be nice to be able to accommodate a pantograph-equipped locomotive, if only I could figure out how.

 

 

You make a double"H" cantery overhead wire system...the bottom slides under. Fast track...weight of track holds it...heavy gadge fishing line..like 35lb will work..or if real USE marklen ho wire...🔨📐🔩🔧📏👍🚎🚋🚈

Apples55 posted:
GG1 4877 posted:

_IGP0856_ed_IGP8175_IGP8181

I guess I like electrics

As much as I like GG-1’s, this screams for an intervention   

But seriously, that is a beautiful and impressive collection.

SUPER SWEET..but you should change your user NAME too ..G reat .G eneral 0 nly.. 0 ne ...net..org..com✌😛😀🚎🚋🚈🚎🚋🚈🚎🚋🚈

 

scale rail posted:

Don't know why Lionel, then Williams didn't do a better job matching their color to Milwaukee Road. Before MTH came out with their scale Milwakee electrics I ran three Williams "Little Joes". I had to paint them to match my passenger cars. Don

m

Because Milwaukee rd had those colors in early 50s...then they got refurbish or repainted..then the tints got darker on most because of painting over original paint..darkening it...by the time mkr changed its livery to newer units...the colors were 3 shades different...thus the toy manufacturing quandary😛🚎🎨🚃🎨🚋🎨🚈🎨🚂😛

I have about every book published about the Milwaukee Road with many early color pictures and I've never seen the colors like Lionel or Williams came up with. The Williams motors came out very late in the life of the Milwaukee. To me it looks like Williams copied Lionel not the Milwaukee. Colors were way off from the real RR. Floquil and other paints made Milwaukee orange and maroon and they were very close to true Milwaukee colors. MTH, K-line and Lionel while not perfect were a lot closer. Don

P7030018wide canyon copy

Attachments

Images (2)
  • P7030018
  • wide canyon copy
Last edited by scale rail
Marty Fitzhenry posted:

hudson - Copy

 

trust and Deans graduation 004

 

Very Nice...Hmmm..looks like RC model balsa 3/8×3/8 square spar and perlin stock for aircraft i use..patterned after pole barn timbre structure ...out in my neck of the woods...the real stuff is early post war vertical standing I beams with lateral wire and insulators between each beam...the track parallels hang dowm suspended by v shaped verticals....im going to make some for my outer most loop tk#4 on my little test track....when finished it will look almost identical....i want to avoid the trolley cantery effect...difference between a pantograph and a wheeled whip🚎🚋🚈EF3Class156.jpg~2

Attachments

Images (1)
  • EF3Class156.jpg~2: REMEMBER THE JETS

I wish the Henry Ford would move it. It will then be 5 miles from me.

Ending the GG-1 a bit 

Tinplate Art posted:

It should be noted the NYC S & T class electrics used third rail power, and not catenary like the PRR and MW electrics. The small tunnel pantographs were used on the many crossover switch tracks under GCT to maintain electrical continuity.

Tinplate Art posted:

It should be noted the NYC S & T class electrics used third rail power, and not catenary like the PRR and MW electrics. The small tunnel pantographs were used on the many crossover switch tracks under GCT to maintain electrical continuity.

modeltrainsparts posted:
NJCJOE posted:
modeltrainsparts posted:
briansilvermustang posted:

 

 Where were these photos taken? Do you have any showing the locomotive number?

Upstate NY.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x_2eaDVSnLA

I thought so -- they're in Cooperstown Junction (near Maryland, NY), about 35 miles from my house. One is now owned by the Henry Ford Museum. I don't know if it has been moved yet.

Ending the GG-1 a bit soon spoiled a spring break trip and I never got to see one run.

I wish the Henry Ford would hurry it up. It will be 5miles away once there.

M. Mitchell Marmel posted:
briansilvermustang posted:

?  

Contrary to popular belief,  the Washington,  DC subway opened in 1953, not 1976.    

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/...Railroad_train_wreck

Mitch 

 

You really have it in for GG-1’s, don’t you, Mitch!!!

This was the ultimate scrounge... the engine was removed, rebuilt, and ran for another 30 years.

Add Reply

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×