I did find some photos of the New Haven Flying Cloud and the rear wall is clearly flush with the rear ends of the side walls. I have never seen a Pullman heavyweight observation car with the rear wall in this position. Moreover, the insides of the side walls are unfinished and the glue is visible on the insides of the windows. Take a close look at my picture.

MELGAR

MELGAR posted:

Picture shows my Golden Gate Depot New Haven Railroad heavyweight observation car Flying Cloud received today July 9, 2019. I’m not sure the rear observation platform of my car is assembled correctly. The rear wall of the car is recessed about one inch ahead of the rear edges of the car sidewalls. It seems to me that the rear wall should be flush with the ends of the rear sidewalls. Could the rear wall have been left off my car or mis-positioned? Would like to see your photographs of the rear platform of this car.

MELGAR

MELGAR_2019_0709_17_GGD_MH_FLYING_CLOUD

yes it is assembled correctly. these are generic heavyweight cars from a pullman design. Here is a PRR heavyweight that is similar to mine:

member:Golden Spike Club Charter Member

rattler21 posted:

Mel,

Plenty of space for enjoying good brandy and fine cigars. 

No marker lamps? 

John in Lansing, ILL

Correct, no marker lamps, should have them. Also when I spoke to Scott at York some eighteen plus months ago, he said they would be putting candles on the tables of this production of dining cars, did not happen.

Arthur posted:
rattler21 posted:

Mel,

Plenty of space for enjoying good brandy and fine cigars. 

No marker lamps? 

John in Lansing, ILL

Correct, no marker lamps, should have them. Also when I spoke to Scott at York some eighteen plus months ago, he said they would be putting candles on the tables of this production of dining cars, did not happen.

At some point GGD needed to meet a price point for the cars. Add the missing lights yourself: adds to the fun.

Mel, like I said in my email to you, you can return your cars for any reason... I will refund the model price.

These cars are modeled after  PULLMAN designs used by many roads. Plastic productions are always like this. If you want a purely prototypical car, you could find a Precision Scale one for about $600, unpainted in 2R, then you will have to convert it to 3 Rail.

Scott Mann

MELGAR posted:

I did find some photos of the New Haven Flying Cloud and the rear wall is clearly flush with the rear ends of the side walls. I have never seen a Pullman heavyweight observation car with the rear wall in this position. Moreover, the insides of the side walls are unfinished and the glue is visible on the insides of the windows. Take a close look at my picture.

MELGAR

UH did you purchase one ?  why all the hype  I have precision scale models I will sell you for 900.00 Big difference.

Bob

Add Reply

Likes (0)
Post
OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
330-757-3020

www.ogaugerr.com
×
×
×
×
×