Skip to main content

My layout has be disassembled for many years, prompted by a move that never happened.  That hasn't stopped me form still collecting trains.  I take some of my trains to a friends house to run now and then, but for the most part my trains are boxed on a shelf until I have the time and money to start a new layout.  The reality is I have more rolling stock then I'm ever going to be able to use, but I find it hard to pass up a good deal and still like buying the things that interest me.  The funny thing is that my focus has changed several times before I even get to the planning stage.  My original focus was BN and UP, but somewhere along the line I switched gears to NS, with a smattering of other lines that I found interesting.  This triggered a sell off of a lot of BN items and the purchasing of a lot of new items that fit my new interests.  I look forward to the day when I can start my new layout, but at the same time I do enjoy just collecting.

Anyone else out there have a large collection with no layout?

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

I do.   I have a "temporary layout" which consists of some Fastrack on the floor of my garage.  It is a double tracked loop which is approximately 9'x16'  with O84 & O72 curves and switches with a 4 track yard inside.  I've had it set up since August 2014, so my poor pickup has had to sit out in the weather since then. 

 

Larry

Last edited by PSAP2010

Bossman, I could have written that paragraph. I haven't had a large layout in 15 years. I do have a single loop carpet central. The lack of a real layout has not slowed my acquisitions. I keep looking at my collection to see if I can thin out a few things, and it doesn't happen. Meanwhile more items keep showing up at my door.

I have put up a wall of shelving to display my engines, but there are racks full of rolling stock that need to see the light of day.

I remain convinced I will have that layout some day.

Paul

 

 

 

 

While I do have a O-gauge layout, I possess engines and rolling stock in "S" with no permanent layout.  From time to time I will put down a loop of MTH/S-helper track on the living room floor and run my 1:64 stuff.  Since it is similar to o-gauge Fastrack, the MTH s-gauge track is pretty quick to set up and then put away later.

Given that there is still about a 50' "hole" in the layout where I'm still laying track, I'm still in the "no layout" category. My collection is run on our club's modular layout. Today is a snow day. When I get home from work, hopefully I'll get to the attic and get some more track laid. Still amazed at how fast I burn through cases of Gargraves 37" straights. It's beginning to look like 5 will be enough.

*** Update *** Since I retired January 2018, all of my track is laid and wired. We've had trains running for almost 2 years now.  Funny, how work got in the way of trains...….

Last edited by Gilly@N&W

I do not have a layout as took mine down that was in the beginning stages ( had 3 loops and that was about it with a couple of switches but it was 8' x 16' but we moved to a even smaller place so now I'm buying still but wife is complaining your still buying but your running out of room my reply your still buying purse and there's no more room for them either.  

I hope someday to close-off the detached garage and use it for a train room. ( add heat/air conditioning ) which would give me about 14' x 18' But I'll probably lose that too even thou it's suppose to be mine. ( yeah I've heard that before as boxes and other junk start taking over lol. ( glad I have a pick-up truck   

But yes at present I do not have a layout but still am buying

I have a 12' x 20' loop.  I have a train sitting on the loop but rarely run.  I still buy trains but not as many as I used to.  I feel the same way FEET feels.  I am in my 60's and my health isn't that great either.  If I go my wife will sell all my trains in a heartbeat and go to Aruba.  What a waste.  Collecting all those trains and letting them just sit there waiting to be sold.  One of these days I'll stop procrastinating and put up a layout.  Maybe.

Rick

 

I have a double track floor layout for my O scale trains and a separate oval track on the floor for just subway trains which keeps me very busy. Not having a permanent layout did not stop me from adding some buildings,accessories, scenery and lots of trains.

* I do have an N scale permanent layout, which helps me with the "I don't have a permanent layout blues" for O scale.

Last edited by N5CJonny

I fall within this group. Lost my train space when we sold the family business. This action has not hampered collecting whatsoever. The problem is that there's no room in my modest home for neither a layout or the trains. Incredibly, things continue to be set outside my front door and I bring them in. I'll display a few items for a period of time, then off they go to the storage unit. It is them that I'm confronted with the fact that I have more stuff than even the largest layout could ever digest. I guess it must be some sort of out of sight, out of mind thing. Is there a twelve-step program out there for this?

Other than this years first ever tinplate Christmas layout, I haven't run any trains in three years. I'm feeling a bit left out the fun.

Last edited by Mill City
Gilly@N&W posted:

Given that there is still about a 50' "hole" in the layout where I'm still laying track, I'm still in the "no layout" category. My collection is run on our club's modular layout. Today is a snow day. When I get home from work, hopefully I'll get to the attic and get some more track laid. Still amazed at how fast I burn through cases of Gargraves 37" straights. It's beginning to look like 5 will be enough.

We will get you finished this winter!

Peter

 

..... I have a 32'x40' hobby building but all my trains are still new in the boxes.....

I have a friend that was in a similar position up until about 5 years ago. He decided to take action and had a carpenter build a massive table. As he opened items, he found about a 90% defect rate. Things would not work, issues everywhere with almost everything he unpacked. Today all his trains are gone, the table was demolished, and he even let his TCA membership lapse. Don't let this happen to you. If he had a loop on the carpet he could have tested everything, learned the ins and outs and peculiarities of the pieces in his collection. I think he would still have his trains today if he just did that little bit.

Last edited by bigo426

I had an awesome ceiling layout up until about 3 years ago when a divorce happened. I have been selling off a lot of my collection but keeping the "chosen" special items for a hopeful layout again one day. If I sell off a lot of items I will treat myself to one or two new items such as Atlas O Zephyr cars to complete my set. I don't think I will ever stop treating myself to a nice piece of rolling stock every once in a while. I will be in the hobby for the long run!

bigo426 posted:
 

..... I have a 32'x40' hobby building but all my trains are still new in the boxes.....

I have a friend that was in a similar position up until about 5 years ago. He decided to take action and had a carpenter build a massive table. As he opened items, he found about a 90% defect rate. Things would not work, issues everywhere with almost everything he unpacked. Today all his trains are gone, the table was demolished, and he even let his TCA membership lapse. Don't let this happen to you. If he had a loop on the carpet he could have tested everything, learned the ins and outs and peculiarities of the pieces in his collection. I think he would still have his trains today if he just did that little bit.

Thanks for cheering us up.

I have a suspended layout attached to my work shop, but I have only had trains on it once in 2015. I am planning to take the track down and make a garden layout this summer. I guess that counts me as not having a permanent layout, as there are no buildings or scenery. The only embellishments are three wood bridges, and a steel bridge across the door. My modest collection is on shelves on the walls of our closed in deck.

Don

Dan65train posted:

Some may call it a test track but  if you can count  5' of straight track hooked to a transformer a layout....... Then I have a layout

I have you beat by about three feet! My test track is about eight feet, maybe a little longer. I just grabbed several sections of old Gargraves and hooked them together on the counter top in the shop, and alligator clipped the wires from a Z4000. What a waste of power!

Don 

rail posted:
Dan65train posted:

Some may call it a test track but  if you can count  5' of straight track hooked to a transformer a layout....... Then I have a layout

I have you beat by about three feet! My test track is about eight feet, maybe a little longer. I just grabbed several sections of old Gargraves and hooked them together on the counter top in the shop, and alligator clipped the wires from a Z4000. What a waste of power!

Don 

I have about 3' of O-27 and use a ZW 

GVDobler posted:
bigo426 posted:
 

..... I have a 32'x40' hobby building but all my trains are still new in the boxes.....

I have a friend that was in a similar position up until about 5 years ago. He decided to take action and had a carpenter build a massive table. As he opened items, he found about a 90% defect rate. Things would not work, issues everywhere with almost everything he unpacked. Today all his trains are gone, the table was demolished, and he even let his TCA membership lapse. Don't let this happen to you. If he had a loop on the carpet he could have tested everything, learned the ins and outs and peculiarities of the pieces in his collection. I think he would still have his trains today if he just did that little bit.

Thanks for cheering us up.

I plan to get a set of Crest rollers and build a test track. You have given me some very sound advice, thanks. I like to work on this stuff, if mine don't work hopefully i can repair them.  Some engines i have run on a short piece of track.  One thing i did do was remove the battery's in all engines that had them.

gunrunnerjohn posted:

Waiting for a move that hopefully will happen this summer, then I'll have a permanent place to finally build a real layout.  Now I run anywhere I can.  I have my carpet central that goes around three rooms, but that's not the same as having a real place to run the trains. 

We moved in late summer 2013 after living in the previous house for 35 years, I am still recovering (we had movers too) and looking for stuff, everything is in a different place... Never moving again, this is it! It is also absolutely amazing how much stuff one can accumulate in 35 years.

Jeff T posted:

Guilty. Moving this summer. Unfinished basement is my wish list! And at least a 3 car garage! 

Unfinished basement (large) was top priority on my list as well. We got a two car garage and a lawn service, no more mowing.  Thought the 2 car would be plenty with mowing stuff gone. After being here about 2-1/2 years, a third garage bay may have been a good idea? Oh, well, see above...about never moving again, the 2 car will have to do.

Good luck to both of you if your moves go through.

I have a modest collection and don't have a permanent layout. When I want to run trains, I take down the sections of my little portable or my sections of mounted GG track. It has to be put away after I run the trains, so I don't run them often. It is a pain carrying all of that stuff from the shed to the house and back. I haven't been buying much in the way of O-gauge in large part because I have just about everything I want and to a lesser extent because I don't have room for more. Plans are in the works for more room and a permanent layout at a later date.

I have been doing more with my N-scale lately because of the portability issue.

It's probably been about 10 years now since I had a real, permanent, layout set up. I had 2 reliable engines at the time and about 30 pieces of rolling stock on an 8X12 board crammed into a 10x12 room.  Since then I've pretty much just had an oval on the floor or a table when the mood to run trains struck me.  At the moment it's about 3'x8' of fast track with a KW.  meanwhile, the collection has grown substantially to over a dozen engines, and a few hundred pieces of rolling stock.  Perhaps when the housing situation gets sorted out I'll be able to build a proper home for the trains to run.  The thing I miss is switches.  Running on an oval is ok, but building trains on a yard and having a choice of routes to take is much more fun for me.  On the floor or in a small area I haven't had a chance to pull out the switches.  

JGL

The big three resource constraints (Time, space, $$) keep me from even attempting a large permanent layout.  Instead, I created an 8 ft by 16 in portable shelf "layout."  Its actually more of an operating diorama with two parallel tracks and a siding.  This modest project allowed me to add more detail that in any layout I've attempted previously.  My Gargraves track is painted and ballasted and I've added some basic ground cover.  My Plasticville coal tower kitbash project is well underway.   With such limited space I don't plan to collect rolling stock, but I do like watching my steamers pull up to the coal dock or spot a hopper or two.  At the other end is a future deport site.  I plan to enjoy watching my steamers make a station stops, bells clanging and whistles blowing.  When I'm not railroading the layout is stored in a closet so the space is given back to my family. 

I've never had so much fun with the hobby since I left HO for O Hi Rail and abandoned big layout plans.  Rivet counting days behind me, I'm now enjoying trains more than ever before with a project that is manageable and affordable.  Of course, if I ever want to highball on the main line my version of a Carpet Central is always an option.  For me, trains on tracks is more fun than trains in boxes.  I left the latter behind with my HO stuff.   

JohnGaltLine posted:

It's probably been about 10 years now since I had a real, permanent, layout set up. I had 2 reliable engines at the time and about 30 pieces of rolling stock on an 8X12 board crammed into a 10x12 room.  Since then I've pretty much just had an oval on the floor or a table when the mood to run trains struck me.  At the moment it's about 3'x8' of fast track with a KW.  meanwhile, the collection has grown substantially to over a dozen engines, and a few hundred pieces of rolling stock.  Perhaps when the housing situation gets sorted out I'll be able to build a proper home for the trains to run.  The thing I miss is switches.  Running on an oval is ok, but building trains on a yard and having a choice of routes to take is much more fun for me.  On the floor or in a small area I haven't had a chance to pull out the switches.  

I pulled out a few switches, this is my "yard", the tracks go round through two other rooms.  I have all O72 command switches so I don't have to wire controllers.  A couple more switches are in the other room to allow me to transfer between tracks in either direction.  When my grandson gets the urge to come up and play, we dig out various operating accessories, and frequently we build temporary extensions to the existing track for industries.  I had the whole room filled with track the other day, it took me several hours to pack up the crane, culvert loader/unloader, and all the extra track and switches.

Carpet Central

Attachments

Images (1)
  • Carpet Central
Last edited by gunrunnerjohn

My storied career in trains began with HO where I had a reasonably sized layout. Got the O bug mostly because I liked having the sound as well as liking the size. Had a layout 24'x15' in downstairs family area. Darned if I didn't get into N with the excuse of adding it to the layout for a forced perspective (at least that's what I quite feebly explained to the wife). Next I decided too much family area being used up. That led to a modular N scale with couple loops of track for 0 in a storage room. Guess you have already got the idea? Needed more storage area. Down came that layout(if you could call it a layout anyway). I have now downsized to  a 5'x 1 0' layout. Yes, it's probably just a matter of time before I will be buying stuff and operating it on my layout in the sky.

No layout. Only at Christmas, and I keep stuff out till mid February or so. I have lots of postwar Lionel waiting for me to catch up on other bills and build that "dream house".  I'm getting closer.

The basement will be all trains, with a fridge and bathroom. Also a walkout to our sauna by the pond. I will never have to leave home again!

In the meantime I keep acquiring and storing. Like someone above said, " boxes keep showing up on the porch and I keep bringing them in".

Matt

I have 2 loops of track that I run on my hardwood floors and have been doing so for the past 2-1/2 years. The outside loop is approximately 8' X 32' and the inside loop is 6' X 30'. The straight going down the hall connecting the living room and dining room is about 27'.

Since I'm running Chessie trains exclusively I made sure to paint my interior walls yellow, orange and Enchantment Blue so the train would "blend" in and become part of the decor. Just kidding...

Hardwood System 001Hardwood System 002

Attachments

Images (2)
  • Hardwood System 001
  • Hardwood System 002

I don't, and never will.  I run sets (set collector), only have about a dozen sets, so it's not super massive. I run inside on the floor, just track in winter, and in summer put up banquet tables and add plasticville and temporary scenery, figures, accessories in the garage. New layout every summer. End of summer, I pack up until Christmas, then around the tree, then inside with more track (like photo) for winter.

As a toy train runner, I like the temporary quality of what I do.photo [6)

Attachments

Images (1)
  • Cork Floor Central
Last edited by pdxtrains

Yep, a definite rubber-gauger here with several items from Flyer S Gauge up to a little G and Standard Gauge, but no layout yet. My small O collection is awaiting a layout also, and a while back I bought a bunch of 0-27 / 0-42 track from a friendly forum member. Messing with SCARM as we speak, and a couple of brand-new Z1000s wait in the wings.

At the present time, I have a Desktop Central made up of VEB Stadtilm track and a couple of switches (East German S gauge). I use it to test-run and play with .....um.... operate my small group of Flyer locomotives with a couple of old Flyer transformers. I call it the "Cold War" layout............

I'm with you guys I just threw this carpet central together because I couldn't stand not running trains anymore.   I'd really like to find a nice club to join.  I was lucky enough to find a woman who one day passed what was stuffed in all my closets and once she discovered what they were she said they were way to cool to keep them boxed up all the time.  Together we plan to either in the future add on our house or relocate to have a nice train room.   She's a realtor so there's hope!

Attachments

Images (1)
  • image
Last edited by jeremy ferrell
rail posted:
Randy T posted:

I haven't had a layout at home for 15 years but I belong to club on Long Island with 4000 sf layout  VBG

Hi Randy,

What club do you belong to? My brother lives on Long Island, and when I visit, I try to visit a club layout or hobby shop.

Don

Don,

 

I belong to TMB train club.   Click on link in my signature.   Our last open house will be Feb. 6 and 7 from noon to 4:00 PM.   

Right now I would consider myself a collector.  I don’t have any room or time for a layout since I’ve been taking care of my parents who are getting up in age and sometimes they have mobility issues that I need to tend to.

Off the top of my head and without the aid of my inventory list I have a Lionel Vision Line 700E Hudson still new in the box and some really nice NYC passenger cars to go with it.  I don’t belong to a club so I don’t know when I’ll be able to run them.  Hopefully sometime soon.

I did that for many years, I called it a "railroad in exile" or " a railroad looking for a place to happen". There was even a time when I called them "3 dimensional wallpaper" I had so many display shelves in my apartment.

I've moved on from those days. Now I no longer call my trains a "collection". It's a FLEET, and I have a railroad to run it on.

Last edited by Big_Boy_4005

We have both. Most of the collectibles, pre-war, post-war, Standard and O, on shelves in the house  

Our layout is O gauge, Gargraves and Ross, with newer scale size engines (mostly steam and a couple of early diesels) and scale size rolling stock. It is located in our separate  train shed room, 12 x 16.

We have fun!

John

 

Last edited by WP

I don't have a layout but I consider myself an operator.  I have a closet we built to store my trains and I run at my train club. I have been a member for over 25 years and I'm very active in the club. I have a four foot track in my basement equipped with a transformer and DCS that I call a test track - not a layout. 

I do both. I have a layout.

But, I also have a non-running, display only collection of NYC steam in G, O, S, OO, HO, TT, N, and Z scale.

I also collect 40' boxcars. They have to be different road names and done in a basic box car red-brown color.

If I couldn't run a layout i would be happy display these and my favorite trains on a wall.

My GS-4 and Daylight heavyweights would go up along side my dad's S scale Flyer.

 

 

 

Collecting is great if you can display it but most often you see collectors that just keep their stuff in boxes. I was one of the closed box collectors until I realized that the real fun is building and operating a layout. I still have a room full of stuff in boxes as its impossible to run everything but for the last 10 years a layout has been in operation.  I am now a self described collector, train scavenger and layout operator.  Its difficult to explain why all this stuff is there when most of it is not displayed or used,

Collecting is great if you can display it but most often you see collectors that just keep their stuff in boxes. I was one of the closed box collectors until I realized that the real fun is building and operating a layout.

What is fun for one person may not be fun for another.

It is very common for Collectors to have large portions of their collection put away in boxes. Why..... because for many collectors the fun is in the hunt, and knowing that they own particular items. (Let's not forget B.S.ing with fellow collectors) They don't need to see them all.
When setting up a display, sometimes less is more.

 

 

C W Burfle posted:

 

What is fun for one person may not be fun for another.

It is very common for Collectors to have large portions of their collection put away in boxes. Why..... because for many collectors the fun is in the hunt, and knowing that they own particular items. (Let's not forget B.S.ing with fellow collectors) They don't need to see them all.
When setting up a display, sometimes less is more.

 

 

One of the best collector comments of all time.  Well done.  A lot more to collecting than a bunch of boxes....

Some of us don't have a layout for various reasons.  I'm in no rush to build a layout that's substandard to get trains running.  

Along with GR John, I'm a big fan of Fastrack and it's CC switches. While we haven't had a permanent layout in almost 10 years, we do set up a Holiday layout every December that usually lasts through Easter. Once it comes down, the Fastrack makes frequent appearances on the floor with the full compliment of sidings, spurs and yard with minimal wiring.  CC uncoupler sections would be great Lionel.

As far as the collection goes, I just thinned it out over the Fall but have just about managed to replace all of the breathing space that I had created. Funny how that happens.

Mike

 

Member of the club!

We moved to our present house in 96 to take care of my mother, after she died in early 97 the house was mine (only child). The only place I have to put up a lay-out is in the basement since one of our boys and family live with us. The basement needs alot of work: clean out, get rid of my father's print shop, seal walls, etc. Belonged to two modular clubs, both gone, and would run on them when I could. Cassie (grandoughter) and I joyed running on Henning lay-out last open house and would like to be invited back. Don't go to any LHSs so not to be tempted then along comes Menards ( still have not bought but would like to). I still add to my collection but since $$ are low am very selective I will buy cheaper just to have at times. Have a dream lay-out in mind for a retirement cottage but don't know if we will have the $$ to get into the village the way the stock market is going, at least it turned around yesterday, but one day does not a trend make.

I need alot of inspiration and $$ to work on the basement to have a small lay-out to run on!

Last edited by redball342

I have always built a layout whether yearly at Christmas time or all year around in the basements. During the years I have managed to collect more that I can ever run on my layout. A few years ago I  sold off 90% of what I had.  But as I look around I see the stash growing larger once again.  For the last 10 years I have actually had 2 layouts. One in the house in Florida , the other here in Maryland.  We have the house in Florida under contract for sale and I am in the process of moving it all to Maryland. Most likely I will sell of some stuff once again.

 

No layout, either permanent or temporary and a holiday carpet central just once about five years ago. With a very large number of items stored in their boxes just collecting is less and less satisfying as the days, months, and now the years come and go. Without running or displaying my collection, buyers remorse increases daily.

When I went to college the layout came down.  Moved out of state after college and the trains stayed home.  Though I was buying and selling in the meantime to start checking off "must haves" for that "someday" layout.  Moved home after a couple years and was allowed my old 4x8 table in the basement for about a year until my parents decided they wanted the basement back.  Now everything's in a storage unit until next summer when my financial planning will come to fruition and I'll be shopping for what I have been referring to as a "train room with a house attached/over it".

A small loop (sometimes I can sneak two) does end up under the Christmas tree every year and last year I even had my (at the time) two year old niece working the controls pretty well.  Looking forward to this year!

No layout; I'm amassing a collection of "O" Gauge trains concentrating in streamlined ones. I had a tabletop layout of "N" scale trains back in the early 70s but sold off everything. Still in the same 1 BR apt I moved to at the age of 22, in Brooklyn Heights, NYC. I have a massive book and art collection, though have sold off some parts—mostly my pulp and digest-size magazines—in the last couple of years.

I had 2 display cases custom-made by Classy Woods; also have 2 of their 30" single loco display cases. Also, have a bookshelf repurposed to hold my trains (which includes a shelf of Strombecker wooden trains I've had since I was a child). Here are the 2 Classy Woods display cases:

Train-Cases-2019

The repurposed book case:

Train-Shelves-2019

Top of both cases are plastic 1:50 scale models I built from kits in the 70s.

Attachments

Images (2)
  • Train-Cases-2019
  • Train-Shelves-2019

I had a layout in the previous house, but when we moved I dedicated the basement space as a big game room for the kids and built a smaller "hobby room" just to work on building structures and boat models.  I do miss being able to run the trains but I've taken a particular liking to building kits and scratchbuilding structures and learning scenery.  My thought is to work on learning how to create hyper detailed structures like those by some model masters on this forum and then in retirement find a place to build a working layout with the prebuilt modules.

In my hobby room I've built floor to ceiling shelves that are 4 feet by 2 feet that I use to build/store/display my structure modules.  I have lots of unfinished kits but nothing "done" yet...

Add Reply

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×