Skip to main content

Happy New Year Switcher Fans.

I’m pleased to have the privilege of posting this first Switcher Saturday of 2024 and hope that we will continue to enjoy and share in this popular thread on the OGR Forum every week. SWSAT is a discussion about switcher locomotives. In the beginning, the only switchers were small “tea kettle” steam engines – 0-4-0s and 0-6-0s. On Switcher Saturdays, we certainly have plenty of those. However, as time went by, larger and more powerful switcher locomotives – steam, diesel and electric –  could be found shunting cars around railroad yards and also out on main lines, branch lines and sidings. So, we’re interested in seeing your model switchers of all ages, sizes and types – tinplate, diecast and brass – toy trains and scale models, in gauges from Z to O and up to G – and also the real thing in 1:1 scale.

Please remember that by posting on the Forum you are consenting to observe the OGR Terms of Service. Post photographs that you have taken. If you post a photo taken by someone else, you must give it proper attribution and you must have the owner’s written permission to post his or her work on the Forum, so as not to violate their Copyright. Failure to follow the rules could result in legal action, financial penalties, and loss of Forum membership.

And now, to the first switcher of 2024.

New York Central System 0-6-0 #231 is an MTH Premier model (20-3281-1) delivered in December 2007 with 3-volt PS2 at MSRP $599.95. The MTH model is built to the 0-6-0 steam switcher design developed by the United States Railroad Administration during World War 1. It is highly detailed, including the deck plate between the engine and tender, and a wireless drawbar. It runs very smoothly, was made in Korea, and is listed for O-31 curves. I run mine conventionally with a BCR2.

I think that Lionel’s recently released Legacy version of the USRA 0-6-0 uses the MTH tooling.

The tender is marked for CR&IRR (Chicago River and Indiana Railroad), a New York Central subsidiary. #231 was one of 14 locomotives in NYC’s B-62 class (road numbers 221 to 234) which probably were the only USRA 0-6-0 switchers on the New York Central System. The NYC acquired most of its 0-6-0 switchers by 1913 – years before the USRA 0-6-0 was designed. It began to purchase 0-8-0 switchers in 1916, and the USRA 0-8-0 design became the NYC’s standard heavy switcher (U-3 class) by 1918.

The USRA 0-6-0 engine weight was 165,000 pounds and the tender weight was 144,000 pounds. It operated at a boiler pressure of 190 pounds-per-square-inch on 51-inch driving wheels with a tractive effort of 39,100 pounds.

I took the photos and videos of #231 on my 10’-by-5’ layout (Atlas O-54 curves) with caboose #1179 of NYC subsidiary Boston & Albany at the tail end.

MELGAR

MELGAR_2023_1224_32_NYC_231_10X5MELGAR_2023_1224_36_NYC_231_10X5_SS71MELGAR_2023_1224_45_NYC_231_10X5_SOUTHMELGAR_2023_1225_01_NYC_231_10X5_DOWNTOWNMELGAR_2023_1225_09_NYC_231_10X5_JCTMELGAR_2023_1225_11_NYC_231_10X5_BRIDGE_CLOSEMELGAR_2023_1225_15_NYC_231_10X5_TUNNELMELGAR_2023_1225_17_NYC_231_10X5_NE

Attachments

Images (8)
  • MELGAR_2023_1224_32_NYC_231_10X5
  • MELGAR_2023_1224_36_NYC_231_10X5_SS71
  • MELGAR_2023_1224_45_NYC_231_10X5_SOUTH
  • MELGAR_2023_1225_01_NYC_231_10X5_DOWNTOWN
  • MELGAR_2023_1225_09_NYC_231_10X5_JCT
  • MELGAR_2023_1225_11_NYC_231_10X5_BRIDGE_CLOSE
  • MELGAR_2023_1225_15_NYC_231_10X5_TUNNEL
  • MELGAR_2023_1225_17_NYC_231_10X5_NE
Videos (2)
MELGAR_2023_1224_54V_NYC_231_10X5_SOUTH_47S
MELGAR_2023_1225_33V_NYC_231_10X5_BRIDGE_TUNNEL_45S
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Thank you. Melgar, for getting us off to such a good start with Switcher Saturday in 2024. Always love to read the historical background you provide.

My contribution is my first MTH PS3 locomotive, a Great Northern VO1000 diesel switcher, shown in the video below, running on DCS and hauling heavy freight through My Little Town:

Arnold

Attachments

Videos (1)
20240101_152828
Last edited by Arnold D. Cribari

Hello SwSat Nation!  MELGAR, we’ll never get on the wrong track with your steady hand on the throttle!  Thanks for subbing for Patrick!

I decided to go to the archives today for a fan favorite and a real oldie but goody.  My American Flyer B6 0-6-0 was built circa 1938.  It was a gift from a friend of my father that I received when I was around ten.  As you’ll see, Flyer built them to last, it runs very well today.

John

8A7891BC-C79B-48FA-8F6F-86325AEBBFD40AB3D84B-76B1-4098-AE0E-E0235C33F1D67CB9BFB1-D645-4DD1-9745-7018C8D36197

Attachments

Images (3)
  • 8A7891BC-C79B-48FA-8F6F-86325AEBBFD4
  • 0AB3D84B-76B1-4098-AE0E-E0235C33F1D6
  • 7CB9BFB1-D645-4DD1-9745-7018C8D36197
Videos (2)
1975E465-8DDB-405E-BB3D-2A560CD587D9
EDE5339F-BF5C-4E92-B8E2-6EBCDC0F284B
@Steam Crazy posted:

Hello SwSat Nation!  MELGAR, we’ll never get on the wrong track with your steady hand on the throttle!  Thanks for subbing for Patrick!

I decided to go to the archives today for a fan favorite and a real oldie but goody.  My American Flyer B6 0-6-0 was built circa 1938.  It was a gift from a friend of my father that I received when I was around ten.  As you’ll see, Flyer built them to last, it runs very well today.

John

8A7891BC-C79B-48FA-8F6F-86325AEBBFD4

@Steam Crazy,

John,

That is a beautiful model.

Seems to me that American Flyer could have been competitive with Lionel if they had remained in O gauge.

Was this model made when American Flyer was still in Chicago or after the move to New Haven - which I believe occurred around 1938.

I had Lionel trains as a youngster but when I first saw American Flyer S gauge trains I liked them better but thought they were too small!

MELGAR

Happy SWSat!

Thanks for notching the throttle up this morning Mel.

I'm pleased to report on the return on New York Central 7000 from the good folks at Trainz. The engine had arrived to me in early December DOA. Lights and sounds worked but it wouldn't move. Turned out the boards had to be reprogrammed (first time I've heard that), and a bad plug repaired.
The repair was completed quickly but the return trip via FedEx was an adventure. The Holidays slowed it down and then the idiot driver kept going to the wrong door on my office building and thought we were closed.

Anyway, I'm happy to finally add the engine to the fleet. This H-16-44 was released by Lionel in 2003, and has TMCC, Railsounds, and Odyssey speed control. The Lightning stripe scheme is my favorite.

The FM H-16-44 was a diesel-electric locomotive produced by Fairbanks-Morse from April 1950 – February 1963. The locomotive shared an identical platform and carbody with the predecessor Model FM H-15-44 (but not the FM H-20-44 end cab road switcher which used a different carbody and frame and a larger prime mover), and were equipped with the same eight-cylinder opposed piston engine that had been uprated to 1,600 horsepower (1,200 kW). The H-16-44 was configured in a B-B wheel arrangement, mounted atop a pair of two-axle AAR Type-B road trucks with all axles powered. In late 1950, the AAR trucks were almost exclusively replaced with the same units found on the company's "C-liner" locomotives.

The New York Central owned 13 units # 7000-7012 that survived into the Penn Central era. The New Haven and Pennsylvania RR also owned H-16's that all moved to PC for a total of 48.

2024-01-05 20.22.422024-01-05 20.23.002024-01-05 20.30.24

Doesn't look like the snowblower will be put to work with this weekend's storm here on LI but just north of the Island is gonna get clobbered.

Have a great weekend.

Bob

Attachments

Images (3)
  • 2024-01-05 20.22.42
  • 2024-01-05 20.23.00
  • 2024-01-05 20.30.24

Thanks Mel for getting us rolling with a nice presentation on your MTH 0-6-0. Today, I'm running the complete FARR #5 PRR freight consist plus WBB PRR gondola with my WBB PRR NW2 subbing for my 6-8404 PRR turbine on point:

The first four FARR #5 PRR freight cars and cabin car were issued with the 6-8404 turbine in 1985. The 6-8404 turbine is essentially a reissue of the PW 682 turbine but in DGLE with silver smokebox and "6200" of the original prototype on the cab. The "add-on" stock car came along in 1990.

The WBB NW2 in PRR is a reproduction of the venerable PW 623 NW2 in ATSF Variation A. The WBB version is conventional with 8-wheel drive powered by a flywheel-equipped DC can motor vertically-mounted on each truck. True Blast provides the not-so-audible sound.

Attachments

Videos (1)
20240106_045800

Mel, I don't know the answer to your question about where my engine was made, but I agree about it's beauty.  The only way I can describe it is it has "presence".  AF did make some concessions to cost;  the left and right sides of my loco are identical!

I also had Lionel as a kid and was intrigued by AF.  I thought about HO for awhile, too - due to it's realism - but when I saw the scale, detailed, 3 rail O scale offerings available around 2000, I got hooked on them for life!

John

@Steam Crazy posted:

Mel, I don't know the answer to your question about where my engine was made, but I agree about it's beauty.  The only way I can describe it is it has "presence".  AF did make some concessions to cost;  the left and right sides of my loco are identical!

I also had Lionel as a kid and was intrigued by AF.  I thought about HO for awhile, too - due to it's realism - but when I saw the scale, detailed, 3 rail O scale offerings available around 2000, I got hooked on them for life!

John

Does it have any kind of a tag or label somewhere, like Lionel does?

I looked up some history. The company originated in Chicago in 1906 or '07 and took the name American Flyer in 1908. It was sold to A.C. Gilbert in 1937 and soon moved to New Haven. Scale length O gauge models of a 4-4-2 Atlantic, 4-6-2 Pacific, and 0-6-0 switcher were introduced in 1938.

MELGAR

There is enough rain in Northern California today for Southern Pacific to offer a Wildflower Special this Spring. Yea, I know, wishful thinking. My 3rd Rail model of a 0-6-0 switcher pulling an excursion train near the lush orchards and fields of cantaloupes of the San Joaquin Valley. is how I like to remember the Espee.

0-6-0_3rd_rail_buttonwillow_station_feb2017

Attachments

Images (1)
  • 0-6-0_3rd_rail_buttonwillow_station_feb2017

Thanks so much MELGAR for notching out the throttle and getting SWSAT off to a terrific start for this new year!!!  Got to LOVE a NYC B6 and your photos, historical background, model info., and videos are superb!!!

Wonderful posts everyone!!  You all are creating a fantastic start for 2024!! Wishing you all a very happy new year!!

This first week of the new year I've been attending a music conference deep in the mountains of NC, where internet and cell reception was spotty.  I'm now in Roanoke for the night,  where cell and internet are working  exceedingly well!  Will make the final leg of my journey back home tomorrow.

I'm posting an old photo of my Reading Train Master ( Williams by Bachman ).    Its' disappearance had been an unsolved mystery for about two months.  With all the excess storage boxes/clutter I presently have in my train room I had practically given up on looking for it, although I retained a hunch it would show up at some future time.   The mystery was solved on New Year's Eve!  As I was searching for some other items the Train Master appeared ... wahlah!!  Needless to say,  I was thrilled beyond belief!!  

I also raided my archives and show some photos of my C&O 0-8-0 switcher being serviced on the locomotive service track.  New photos to come next Saturday!

IMG_0871

A Chesapeake and Ohio 0-8-0 has backed up onto the engine service track after having set out a flat car loaded with US Army Jeeps.  IMG_0031

Jitterbug Gleason stands on the front of the locomotive.  He's about to clean the headlight lens.  Barney Pearson, standing on the  high sideboard, has just topped off the sand domes.  Hostler, Link Philpot glances over the running gear and is ready to tighten any loose bolts with his trusty wrench.  Foreman Winky Janks, with yellow hard hat, gives an overall inspection.  IMG_0794

With headlight lens nice and clean, Barney has now just finished polishing the bell.  IMG_0795

It's now time to take on coal and water. IMG_0767

The hostler has nudged the engine forward just a bit so it a couple on to an air dump car.  IMG_0549

Attachments

Images (6)
  • IMG_0871
  • IMG_0031
  • IMG_0794
  • IMG_0795
  • IMG_0767
  • IMG_0549
@trumptrain posted:

Thanks so much MELGAR for notching out the throttle and getting SWSAT off to a terrific start for this new year!!!  Got to LOVE a NYC B6 and your photos, historical background, model info., and videos are superb!!!

Wonderful posts everyone!!  You all are creating a fantastic start for 2024!! Wishing you all a very happy new year!!

I'm posting an old photo of my Reading Train Master ( Williams by Bachman ).    Its' disappearance had been an unsolved mystery for about two months.  With all the excess storage boxes/clutter I presently have in my train room I had practically given up on looking for it, although I retained a hunch it would show up at some future time.   The mystery was solved on New Year's Eve!  As I was searching for some other items the Train Master appeared ... wahlah!!  Needless to say,  I was thrilled beyond belief!!  

IMG_0871



Glad you found it Pat. Can't wait to see your new pix next week.

Bob

MELGAR, I found the article I mentioned in my last post.  It appeared in the April 1998 edition of Railroad Model Craftsman.

While it didn’t offer any more detail about my 0-6-0, there was some additional AF history.  According to the article, the 0-6-0, the Atlantic and the Pacific you mentioned originated with a company called W. O. Coleman in Chicago.  Coleman also produced an HO line.  AF purchased Coleman and published  it’s first catalog in 1938.

In 1939 AF introduced 3/16 scale trains that ran on O gauge track.  AF claimed the 3/16 trains looked more realistic on narrow radius curves.  Until the war, AF produced the three O scale engines, tinplate O and the 3/16 line.

As we know, AF turned to S gauge after the war.  Marx became the main manufacturer of 3/16 O gauge trains and Lionel produced trains that were smaller than O scale, but in between 3/16 and 1/4.

John

Add Reply

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×