Skip to main content

All right Lionel,

We've been waiting long enough. It's time to do the N&W J 611 justice and give all her fans what we've been waiting patiently for - a full-blown Vision line product. One that rivals the recent Big Boy. How about the locomotive, tender and auxillary tender together, with whistle steam and one additional steam effect, like the cylinder effect that's so prominent. Speakers in both tenders to get the great sound that's in the Big Boy. And please skip the depleting coal load. Go ahead and ask $2999 MSRP and let the pre-orders roll in. I'm tired of waiting - I need this train!

While you're at it, a legacy version of the 1218 and 2156 (with whistle steam, of course) would be much appreciated, too.

Thanks so much.
Last edited by J Class
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Originally Posted by J Class:
All right Lionel,

We've been waiting long enough. It's time to do the N&W J 611 justice and give all her fans what we've been waiting patiently for - a full-blown Vision line product. One that rivals the recent Big Boy. How about the locomotive, tender and auxillary tender together, with whistle steam and one additional steam effect, like the cylinder effect that's so prominent. Speakers in both tenders to get the great sound that's in the Big Boy. And please skip the depleting coal load. Go ahead and ask $2999 MSRP and let the pre-orders roll in. I'm tired of waiting - I need this train!

While you're at it, a legacy version of the 1218 and 2156 (with whistle steam, of course) would be much appreciated, too.

Thanks so much.

 Go ahead and ask $2999 MSRP

 

 

 

Do not need it that bad.

Originally Posted by John Pignatelli JR.:
Originally Posted by J Class:
All right Lionel,

We've been waiting long enough. It's time to do the N&W J 611 justice and give all her fans what we've been waiting patiently for - a full-blown Vision line product. One that rivals the recent Big Boy. How about the locomotive, tender and auxillary tender together, with whistle steam and one additional steam effect, like the cylinder effect that's so prominent. Speakers in both tenders to get the great sound that's in the Big Boy. And please skip the depleting coal load. Go ahead and ask $2999 MSRP and let the pre-orders roll in. I'm tired of waiting - I need this train!

While you're at it, a legacy version of the 1218 and 2156 (with whistle steam, of course) would be much appreciated, too.

Thanks so much.

 Go ahead and ask $2999 MSRP

 

 

 

Do not need it that bad.

LOL, why not $3999 MSRP so folks can say I paid $3999 for this beauty.

 

   Bill T.

I would not be too surprised if it is a Vision Allegheny.  Regardless, a Vision 611 will not float my boat.  The Legacy version I have is quite fine enough.  I still want a Vision A-B-B-A set of F3s, but that probably won't happen. 

 

Lionel did a JLC Allegheny about the time that they did the original JLC Big Boy.  That original BB contributed many of the castings, etc., to the latest Vision BigBoy, and they can do the same thing with their Allegheny, so I expect they will.  

The Legacy J was just delivered with the mistake of no whistle steam. Not likely thas gonna happen.

 

The legacy Y6's are the way to there buyers right now, best bet is to buy one of those and change the number, not likely there will be a VL version now.

 

I'd prefer to see something that hasn't been rehashed  by Lionel multiple times, and has numerous issues that need correction...... a VL Niagara.

 

 

A Vision Line Allegheny is my prediction.

With ALL the bells and whistles. Blowdown, whistle steam,

swinging bell (IF prototypical), steam chest emission, and

perhaps an applance or two on top of the boiler emitting steam.

Will it cost more than a Big Boy? Of course.

 

My hope is that Lionel avoids choosing something that is not on the typical wish list. A double headed Centipede. It could be run by how many hobbyists? Ten percent ?

In addition, a Vision locomotive should be a steamer. A diesel or electric has insufficient "Gizmos" to make it an offer that hobbyists cannot resist. Spinning fans on a Centipede?

The marketing people who picked that are the same marketing people who told me at York,

 

"Lionel cannot put whistle steam in locomotives because . . .

a) It is too expensive

b) We cannot fit it in the boilers

c) Jon 'You know who' spends all his research time working Ipad apps

d) The economy sucks

 

Yes, as you see above, too late for the Y6-b. That would have been a great choice.

C'mon Jon, give us a Vision Allegheny with pizzazz !!!

Last edited by Scrapiron Scher

We have to consider what locomotives would be good candidates as Vision products before we can even think of asking to make a specific one.

 

Like Rick said, Lionel already did the regular Legacy version of the 611 J within the last 2 years, so that's not going to happen, nor a Southern #4501 Mikado or even a GS-4 Daylight.

 

I for one agree that a Vision Allegheny is a great idea, and I also root for a Vision Niagara, or even a regular Legacy with whistle steam version at least.

 

As for my own, I'd love to see Vision Line runs of the Reading/Chessie Steam Special T-1's. Those engines are beautiful, and it's been 24 years since Lionel last did the T-1's. Considering their popularity, #2100 being restored, their significance in modern Lionel history, and their wide variety of colors to be offered, these would make great Vision items at best.

 

Last edited by Mikado 4501
Originally Posted by Scrapiron Scher:

A Vision Line Allegheny is my prediction.

With ALL the bells and whistles. Blowdown, whistle steam,

swinging bell (IF prototypical), steam chest emission, and

perhaps an applance or two on top of the boiler emitting steam.

Will it cost more than a Big Boy? Of course.

 

My hope is that Lionel avoids choosing something that is not on the typical wish list. A double headed Centipede. It could be run by how many hobbyists? Ten percent ?

In addition, a Vision locomotive should be a steamer. A diesel or electric has insufficient "Gizmos" to make it an offer that hobbyists cannot resist. Spinning fans on a Centipede?

The marketing people who picked that are the same marketing people who told me at York,

 

"Lionel cannot put whistle steam in locomotives because . . .

a) It is too expensive

b) We cannot fit it in the boilers

c) Jon 'You know who' spends all his research time working Ipad apps

d) The economy sucks

 

Yes, as you see above, too late for the Y6-b. That would have been a great choice.

C'mon Jon, give us a Vision Allegheny with pizzazz !!!

I Hope the next VL is an Allegheny... Lionel has one more VL purchase from me if they make it an Allegheny. Would not buy if it where a J, but I would love for them to put a whistle steam effect into the Legacy version like the new J3a Hudson though. Would be great if they package with the new 21" passenger cars. But I have a feeling the next package deal their will be the UP FEF with passenger cars as UP cars were missing from the substantial list of road names in the first run. UP is almost always in the first run of anything. I would also love a VL Erie Triplex which I don't think will happen as it would make me happy and I choose not to buy the MTH Premier version that is coming soon. Now an Allegheny would be great... prolly deliver in Dec 2016 which would give me too long to wait. Its got to have the depleting coal load though. I think if this feature were lost there would be public outcry like when the whistle steam went away. Is a swinging bell prototypical? I would love that option. One of my favorite VL features. Its hard not to ring the bell on the ATSF 3000.

As for VL diesels I agree that the Centipede was a dumb idea with rotating fan blades. But that is what is great about Lionel, they take risks with new things. A cock up like that makes me wonder about the marketing department but hopefully it provided some market knowledge. I do love the Genset switcher though... and proves that VL diesels have some value the 3 separate diesels with independent smoke is sweet. I don't own any diesels but I want this one. I would also buy my first diesel if it were a UP ABBA F3. I'm not sure what else I would want other then Legacy and each unit smoking would provide, probably all four powered with sounds and smoke and a new kinematic connection that reduces the massive gap between units.

Originally Posted by WestinghouseEMDdemoguy:
Vision Line Maersk fp45 with opening cab side panels that expose the engine instead of a detailed crew area, or both. Add vision line Maersk intermodal freight set and we have a winner!

True, Lionel should not overlook VL cars as well! I would love some VL coal cars. Would look great behind a VL Allegheny or Triplex

Budget has been kind of tight for a bit, so I have passed on the spendy things, but an SP&S 700 would be something that I would sell some things to get.

 

 Unfortunately, when Lionel did the Legacy SP GS4, they didn't offer a 4449 Road number, poor choice, but I bought the 4436 any way.

 

Also, Unfortunately, I am sure that the OR&N 197 is way to obscure to even Hope for, I doubt that would even be likely once IF/WHEN her restoration is complete and she is back in steam again.

 

I would take a PASS on that UGLY Allegheny Beast, I would like to see more that are actually running, and I think that some smaller types would be popular, though I admit, I like the BIG stuff as much as the next guy.

 

Doug

Last edited by challenger3980

This is a slam-dunk (with appropriate mechanical improvements, of course):

 

NYC_Niagara_1

 

(Actually, I'd be happy with a 4-chuff, more robust re-issue of the TMCC version. Love that air horn.) 

 

========

 

(BTW, above, challenger3980 said something like "UGLY Allegheny beast". Now, that's just silly. I can only assume that there is another loco called an "Allegheny" that he and only he has seen.) 

Attachments

Images (1)
  • NYC_Niagara_1

Add Reply

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×