Skip to main content

Here's my take on the 2022 pricing and Lionel Catalog:

I've recently returned to the hobby after a few decades away.  I'll be building a new layout this year and I know almost nothing about the new technology (TMCC, Legacy, etc..).  Although I'm interested in the new Class A Vision steam engines I still need to back fill some things on my wish list ie Big Boy.  I will probably wait until I have my new layout up and running to purchase anything big.

I'm looking at getting a few things to get started:

  • Lionel Base 3
  • Cab3 App
  • BN SW1
  • BNSF and/or BC Rail ES44AC
  • BN SD-40
  • CP Veterans SD90
  • Miller High Life box car
  • 1776 box car
  • Polar Express

Okay, now I am more on the fence on which Class A I was thinking about getting. Why, well, I am sort of interested in what the heck "Commonwealth Trucks" are, and notably "cast pilot without after-cooler".

After cooler

I guess that is the "after-cooler"? Sorry that is a little blurry. I am also guessing that the art work for all the Class A tenders are show with the extensions as they all look alike to me, even though some say extensions, others say commonwealth trucks. I'm curious, what does a Class A tender look like without extensions? Or is that just some more fiction going on there? Anyone care to educate me please or correct what Lionel is offering?

Yes, that is the "after-cooler". Later A's had them.

If you will look at the "Pilot" model photo, look at the very top of the coal bunker of the tender and those pieces sticking up are the extentions in order for the tender to hold more coal. No "fiction"!

The "Commonwealth" trucks will be the same trucks found on the Class J tender. The Y6b model has "Buckeye" trucks. Very different. Sorry, I don't have pictures here on my tablet to show the difference, but, you can look them yourself.

Last edited by Big Jim
@Big Jim posted:

Yes, that is the "after-cooler". Later A's had them.

If you will look at the "Pilot" model photo, look at the very top of the coal bunker of the tender and those pieces sticking up are the extentions in order for the tender to hold more coal. No "fiction"!

The "Commonwealth" trucks will be the same trucks found on the Class J tender. The Y6b model has "Buckeye" trucks. Very different. Sorry, I don't have pictures here on my tablet to show the difference, but, you can look them yourself.

Yeah, on the "Which Class A are you getting?" topic, I popped the pictures of the coal bunker as well as the dog houses on the tenders. The artist filled in the windows black on some of the models on the catalog, this making it hard to see what is going on. I forget all of what else I had posted over there, but someone else had also commented on the commonwealth trucks and buckeye trucks stated exactly what you said above Jim. Also, during the Train World video, Ryan credited those(in general) who took the time to point out differences like the cover over the turrets, as well as a few other things with the models. They remarked on this on the Class A part of the catalog which helped me decide that I will be getting 1211 model.

I ended up ordering the Louisville and Nashville vision horse car, the Amtrak veteran's NPCU, Amtrak station sounds diner, N&W hopper two pack (can't believe they didn't offer a six pack to go with the A), and the chapel car.

In a perfect world I would've liked a Class A, the Ski Train set, and the rocket train. The heritage ES44s are disappointing because it makes me think we're still at least a couple years out from having real ET44AC tooling in O scale and I'm sure everyone on this site is tired of hearing me beg for it.

@B rad posted:

Do you all think the cab3 bases will be available without having to preorder? I'm thinking I'd like one but not too sure enough at the moment to preorder. Sounds like they are a year out as it is.

Brad

I think if you want to hold off they'll be around.  Train World made it sound like they are ordering plenty.  I think once the dealers see the demand they'll order accordingly.

Last edited by MartyE
@B rad posted:

Tons of places. Legacy station preorder $400. Trainworld $439. Charles Ro $439. Marios Trains $459. Retail $499. Many many others offering preorder discounts as well.

Brad

Correct.  Doesn't take too much of a search to find discounts. 

All of the above are great dealers ... plus note that Nassau Hobbies has the CAB3 for $399 pre-order.

@RickO posted:

Hah! Not this one though. The dealer that goes and grabs some Menards beta locos and puts them up on the big auction site for double.   ( maybe they'll sneak in a $50 shipping charge on the cab 3)

No thanks. I'd rather pay MSRP at Ro, Trainworld, or Muffins.

That's why I like Marios.

Guaranteed free shipping and no tax outside of their state.

Yea yea.. I know it's up to the buyer to pay the tax. How many times have I heard that one on this forum.

I'll be sure to do that because my wife is a CPA.

Whatever... Catch me if you can. 😄

Last edited by B rad

I was glad to see they had some Aberdeen, Carolina and Western finally.  Albeit they aren't the SD-40-3's I was hoping for.  It would have also have been nice, instead of offering the plain jane passenger cars, if they offered the canopy and patio cars that ACW has.

Sadly, I could cough up these things before I could afford to buy anything from this catalog.

Anthony

Cab3, Aberdeen Carolina & Western locomotive and passenger cars, Santa Fe Doodlebug

When Dave & Ryan did a video with Trainworld they mentioned that they may be offering some of the other cars for the Aberdeen Carolina & Western train.  I think they had enough lead time to use existing tooling for the cars they are offering this time around and probably needed more lead time for the other more rare canopy and patio cars.  My guess is that set will be so successful this time around they will offer the other cars later, knowing they will be a big hit.

@RickO posted:

Hah! Not this one though. The dealer that goes and grabs some Menards beta locos and puts them up on the big auction site for double.   ( maybe they'll sneak in a $50 shipping charge on the cab 3)

No thanks. I'd rather pay MSRP at Ro, Trainworld, or Muffins.

I've dealt with Nassau Hobbies for years (and years) - along with Ro, et. al.  Never had an issue with the owners of Nassau; never had a problem with the product from Nassau.

I know nothing about your references -- but I assume, for your sake, that you can verify.

@RickO posted:

Links to ebay sales are not allowed. Your welcome to search the Menards f 3.

You'll find a vendor from Freeport NY selling them for $350 plus shipping.

Click on "visit the store" and Viola Nassau Hobby....but what do I know?

It's not my problem - it's yours.  I have nothing in this except that Nassau has been a good shop to deal with.

And, who the heck is "Viola"?

I was looking at the coal hopper cars(GLA's) and saw these weren't diecast cars as past runs. I don't remember if the prior offerings of the GLA hoppers have been all diecast(in recent years), but I do know if they were, I ordered them. I'll have to look further at this as I may not order them just because of that. After all, who wants light cars(yeah, I know you can add weight to them) being pulled behind a beast like the Class A?

I was looking at the coal hopper cars(GLA's) and saw these weren't diecast cars as past runs. I don't remember if the prior offerings of the GLA hoppers have been all diecast(in recent years), but I do know if they were, I ordered them. I'll have to look further at this as I may not order them just because of that. After all, who wants light cars(yeah, I know you can add weight to them) being pulled behind a beast like the Class A?

The GLA cars have only been done in plastic. The coal load is removable so I just put rocks in mine to add weight.

I was looking at the coal hopper cars(GLA's) and saw these weren't diecast cars as past runs. I don't remember if the prior offerings of the GLA hoppers have been all diecast(in recent years), but I do know if they were, I ordered them. I'll have to look further at this as I may not order them just because of that. After all, who wants light cars(yeah, I know you can add weight to them) being pulled behind a beast like the Class A?

Dave, you might be thinking of the die-cast offset hoppers. They are some of the finest scale rolling stock Lionel has ever made.

I stalked the internet for a cabbage unit all last year. It took a bit of strength to ignore one I saw on eBay earlier this week. I let it go because I reserved the Lionel Downeaster variant last week! My plan was to find the original cabbage and have it custom painted. I'm telling myself I saved money.

I also ordered some F40s. I'm going to sell off my MTH F40s. I'm a fan of kinematic pilots.


Amtrak NPCU “Cabbage”

Attachments

Images (1)
  • blobid0
Last edited by CharmCityAirLine

I've been waiting for Lionel to produce Amfleets again for a long time! Happy to see a cab car being offered again as well. Picking up the following from this catalog:

  • Amtrak Legacy F40PH Phase III  (Hoping to get this one repainted as MBTA to pair with my Atlas MBTA Comet Commuter cars that I also ordered)
  • Amtrak Genesis LionChief Plus 2.0 Set
  • Amtrak Amfleet Phase VI coach/cab car 2-pack
  • Amtrak Amfleet Phase VI coach 2-pack

Very excited for these to come in!

I’m thinking F40PH and a Cabbage unit. Anyone know if the AMFLEETs are scale? If not, does anyone make scale AMFLEETs?

They are 18ish inches long, which does look pretty good but not to scale.
Note that they do not match up nicely with other brands' Amfleets.
If you are looking for a cab car, Lionel makes the only model available, so plan on buying Lionel Amfleets too.
Your train's Amfleets should be all one brand, but any Amfleets look fine with other brands' other rolling stock.
For example, I have MTH Amfleets running with Golden Gate Viewliners.

Frankly, I prefer MTH and GGD Amfleets, but I really wanted that cab car.

Here is a comparison of Lionel and MTH Amfleets (Lionel left)
No photo description available.No photo description available.

Last edited by CharmCityAirLine

They are 18ish inches long, which does look pretty good but not to scale.
Note that they do not match up nicely with other brands' Amfleets.
If you are looking for a cab car, Lionel makes the only model available, so plan on buying Lionel Amfleets too.
Your train's Amfleets should be all one brand, but any Amfleets look fine with other brands' other rolling stock.
For example, I have MTH Amfleets running with Golden Gate Viewliners.

Frankly, I prefer MTH and GGD Amfleets, but I really wanted that cab car.

Here is a comparison of Lionel and MTH Amfleets (Lionel left)
No photo description available.No photo description available.

That is good to know. I had figured MTH(Atlas) AMFEET would be the same dimension as Lionel AMFLEET. I’ll have to take a look at Golden Gate Depot.

I’m just starting out my fleet and knowing myself, I’ll notice my 21” streamliner passenger cars are longer than my AMFLEETs. Especially when running together. I know it’s not prototypical, but my “happiness” mixes modern electrics sharing the right of way with early diesels and steam power. It’s all about where you draw the line. 😁

Already Preordered:

Base 3

Amtrak F40PH Phase V Livery NPCU (side note-love these cab units. They're not just great for push-pull with the powered F40ph units with which they can pair. They're great for push-pull with any Amtrak TMCC equipped or Legacy loco(I assume conventional, too), which is great because the NPCU is typically in push-pull with a Genesis(now offered by Lionel in traditional size) and the Dash 8 which Lionel offered scale versions of in Phase III Pepsi Can and Phase IV liveries.

Amtrak F40PH Phase IV Livery Powered Unit

Still Deciding on if I'll buy a freight unit from this offering. If I do, it will be one of the following:

RS-27 Penn Central, C&NW or SOO

SD90MAC Norfolk Southern(UP patched)

I ended up with just the Aberdeen Carolina and Western F Units and heavyweights.  I thought about some others (the other ACWR cars, rocket train, a couple of the Atlantics), but since I also have a 3rd Rail P42 (Metro North) and a bunch of the Atlas Comet cars (also Metro North) on order, I decided that was more than enough for one year.

Seems like all I'm getting is the US Army 0-4-0 and the Railway Cannon. That CSX F40ph is super tempting but I would only be getting one of the engines and all of my other engines and rolling stock are traditional sized so that probably wouldn't work out all too well. At least the 4 wheeler is already a small engine so that should blend in """fine""".

I have a few things already preordered from the new Catalog!

- The Vision Line Norfolk & Western Class A #1210 WW2 Era version

350C9961-5166-4442-BA82-923CA1686A7C

- The Vision Line Pennsylvania Railroad “What If” Class A #3701, an exclusive run for MrMuffin’sTrains

0EBFAC6E-A810-40DA-8E6A-F9A6BEA562F549DDD33A-49BE-4F17-8060-0C339102F3E1

- The Legacy Reading & Northern F9 AB unit set

58D896FB-A7F6-4870-80E2-503CCDA4BA0A

- The Legacy CN Heritage BC Rail ES44AC #3115

7A2CA979-CF20-40B2-B6A9-9EAB4FBAD9E7

- The Legacy Canadian National Veterans ES44AC #3015

D8B32270-D913-4493-8337-84E3A17B4382

- The Canadian National Veterans Bay Window Caboose

ACA77D17-A449-4D8C-BCB3-00F2EB74542E

Attachments

Images (10)
  • 350C9961-5166-4442-BA82-923CA1686A7C
  • 0EBFAC6E-A810-40DA-8E6A-F9A6BEA562F5
  • 49DDD33A-49BE-4F17-8060-0C339102F3E1
  • 58D896FB-A7F6-4870-80E2-503CCDA4BA0A
  • 7A2CA979-CF20-40B2-B6A9-9EAB4FBAD9E7
  • 829AE3ED-23C4-4A50-AA0E-7D1DFD705F34
  • A065571F-E78F-4C7D-8BE2-147783D49F63
  • 24661F1F-AFC6-486A-AFC4-095538FEC033
  • D8B32270-D913-4493-8337-84E3A17B4382
  • ACA77D17-A449-4D8C-BCB3-00F2EB74542E
@N&WGuy posted:

I have a few things already preordered from the new Catalog!

- The Vision Line Norfolk & Western Class A #1210 WW2 Era version

350C9961-5166-4442-BA82-923CA1686A7C

- The Vision Line Pennsylvania Railroad “What If” Class A #3701, an exclusive run for MrMuffin’sTrains

0EBFAC6E-A810-40DA-8E6A-F9A6BEA562F549DDD33A-49BE-4F17-8060-0C339102F3E1

- The Legacy Reading & Northern F9 AB unit set

58D896FB-A7F6-4870-80E2-503CCDA4BA0A

- The Legacy CN Heritage BC Rail ES44AC #3115

7A2CA979-CF20-40B2-B6A9-9EAB4FBAD9E7

- The Legacy Canadian National Veterans ES44AC #3015

D8B32270-D913-4493-8337-84E3A17B4382

- The Canadian National Veterans Bay Window Caboose

ACA77D17-A449-4D8C-BCB3-00F2EB74542E

Will the safety valve steam be moved away from the whistle steam so it doesn’t blend together? Or think it would take away from the accuracy of the train too much?

I know that, my point was that they’re basically on top of each other.

I don’t think it’ll be too big of an issue since the safety valve steam effect won’t be constantly on. I have a Legacy Pennsylvania S1 duplex with the safety valve effects on it and it only randomly pops off every once in awhile. The effect itself once on last for about 20 or 30 seconds before shutting off again.

So, where should they move whistle steam?  Under the bell?

For the money these things cost, locomotive appliances should be in their proper locations.  Particularly as others have talked about getting other details correct for particular Class A's.

Rusty

No I like it in the correct spot. I’d just rather have cylinder steam.

This video is why I say that it literally pours out of the cylinders.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=koyKe6kFmqQ

Last edited by Robert Cushman
@N&WGuy posted:

I don’t think it’ll be too big of an issue since the safety valve steam effect won’t be constantly on. I have a Legacy Pennsylvania S1 duplex with the safety valve effects on it and it only randomly pops off every once in awhile. The effect itself once on last for about 20 or 30 seconds before shutting off again.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=satRPEonEvQ

32.40 on this video is the safety valve effect. It’s very cool.

Finally settled on one of the Amtrak Phase 3 F40PH's and one of the Phase 4 Cabbages.

Do they match? NOPE. But I like these schemes most.

I missed out on the first run of these in 2016, and after missing out on most of the second run of the B6sb Switchers in 2020 among other locomotives, I'm not letting the same happen again.

I would've liked to preorder more like one of the Berks and the Black River set, but funds right now aren't permitting. I still have the Strasburg no. 90 on order, anyways.

I bought more than I initially thought I would. I pre ordered both of Mr Muffins NKP custom runs (Atlantic and Harry Painted 0-6-0). I also ordered a Class A 1218, a PRR 0-4-0, phase 3 f40ph, and the swift vision line stock cars. Oh! And I decided to take a leap and get the base 3

Much more than I expected, but I talked myself into the class A after I got a great deal on some older NS excursion cars.

Last edited by Keith Crook 020419
@2012ford posted:

Well I went with the base 3 the AC&W F9 and 2 pk heavyweight cars, csx 2 pk heavyweight cars csx f40ph #1 armed forces es44 2022 and cp 7020.

I’m surprised there hasn’t been much mention of the CSX business train. I thought that was a really cool item and I would have preordered some of it if I had a scale/legacy size layout.

Well, I guess I have to order something or I would not be in this hobby.  I always buy from sommerfelds in Butler, WI(Milw). Always fair and they do repairs.  Ordered two of each of GBW rs27.  I know they are MTH tooling, which I had one of but at least now I can run with the Legacysystem.  Still looking at a few other items but these are the top of the list.  Hope with having tooling already maybe Lionel will be able to turn some of these faster(ha ha).  

I pulled the trigger on the Amtrak 6 car Phase III Heritage set.  Skipped the diner as I'm not interested in the sounds but will pick up a K-Line or equivalent and get it painted to match.  Now I have most of what I am looking for on a circa 1990 Broadway Limited.  Still need the baggage / dorm, but I have a donor car that is close with some rework and I am patiently waiting on GGD 2nd run Slumbercoaches.

After picking up the diner (no sound) / coach ATSF expansion set to complete my Santa Fe #42 / 47 I was impressed with the overall build quality of the cars.  That was what put me over the top as this is my first Lionel pre-order.

I ended up going with the Canadian National Veterans ES44AC #3015 and the matching Canadian National - Bay Window Caboose. I also decided to get two of the Canadian Pacific Veteran SD90Mac units, CP #7020 (Army/Solid Green) and CP #7023 (Air Force/Grey on Grey). I already have a MTH Premier CP #7021 (Army/Desert). I am very interested to see how the Lionel versions compare to the MTH in regards to the CP Veteran units.

@NS1975 posted:

I ended up going with the Canadian National Veterans ES44AC #3015 and the matching Canadian National - Bay Window Caboose. I also decided to get two of the Canadian Pacific Veteran SD90Mac units, CP #7020 (Army/Solid Green) and CP #7023 (Air Force/Grey on Grey). I already have a MTH Premier CP #7021 (Army/Desert). I am very interested to see how the Lionel versions compare to the MTH in regards to the CP Veteran units.

I'm getting four of the CP military tribute locomotives. I think they are a big hit for Lionel.

Add Reply

Post
This forum is sponsored by Lionel, LLC

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×