size discrepancy between stock cars | O Gauge Railroading On Line Forum

grazOGR Forum Member DIGITAL SUBSCRIBER

Size question:

Lionel 40' scale stock car vs. Atlas Trainman 40' scale stock car.

The Lionel is considerably smaller in stature while the Trainman is much taller. It's probably the same size as a standard PS-1 boxcar.

Both are marked as depicting a car built in 1950.

Any idea as to which is depicting the correct size?

Thanks,
Mike

2/9/138:43 PM

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

colorado hirailerOGR Forum Member

I'm no authority on either stock cars or scale fidelity of Lionel cars, but I have seen

in prototype photos stock cars of varying lengths and heights. While I don't KNOW that the Lionel car is undersized, such is not unheard of in the tinplate world, and much else made by Lionel is not scale. I am sure that across Lionel's various series of stock cars, they vary in size and some are larger and probably scale.

2/9/139:55 PM

falconserviceOGR Forum Member

This is in the wrong forum.

The Lionel and TrainMan Live Stock Cars are models of different builders cars.

The Lionel O Scale 40' Live Stock Car was said to be an ACF design.

Andrew

2/9/139:58 PM

<div id="{%=id%}" class="reveal-modal small h-alert-modal-popup" data-reveal>
    <div class="first-modal-focus focus-utility-element" tabindex="0" aria-label="Inside Modal"></div>

<h4 id="{%=id%}_title" class="margin-bottom-10 popup-title"></h4>
    <div id="{%=id%}_body" class="margin-bottom-10 popup-body">
        </div>

<ul id="{%=id%}ButtonGroup" class="button-group h-popup-buttons even-button-group even-1">
    <li id="{%=id%}Okay_buttonContainer"><a id="{%=id%}Okay" href="javascript:void(0);" class="button success no-margin-bottom h-alert-modal-ok-button" role="button">OK</a><script type="text/javascript">
        (function() {
            function {%=id%}Okay_click(event, data) {
            {%=id%}Popup.hide();
        }
        
                $('#{%=id%}Okay').on('click', {%=id%}Okay_click);
        })();
    </script></li></ul><a href="javascript:void(0);" class="close-reveal-modal" aria-label="Close Modal">&#215;</a><div class="last-modal-focus focus-utility-element" tabindex="0"></div>
</div>
<script type="text/javascript">
        (function() {
            {%=id%}Popup = new SS.Popup.ModalPopup('{%=id%}');
        })();
    </script>