Skip to main content

I have had some communication asking me "Why do I go to this  amount of effort?"  For a "Reply all" response:

My answer is that this approach literally gets one to  work out of the lock step box of tangent lines and angular corners which I find boring, toward the shapes of an artist's pallet. 

After all, our RRs are comprised of an abundance of curves and various bulbous topographical shapes.   My thought is to develop a interesting and cohesive package presentation. 

My background in  aviation sheet metal manufacturing and designing fiberglass race boat molds schooled me in purposeful soft lines.  

John and I just want others to see how basic and straightforward it is to create a fun project.  Again, this is just one beggar telling another beggar where to find bread.

Last edited by Tom Tee
gunrunnerjohn posted:

It's certainly not the smoothest paint job, but it's only a background color and sealing for the Homasote.  I don't intend for the layout to be brown, so I'll just cover it up with scenery.

I also added handles to the lift-out do it's easy to deal with.  I do have to get the proper paint to paint the metal J-channel a similar color, that's not urgent right now.

Hi John,

I plan to put handles on my lift-outs as well. My question is if there is no one around where will you put it when you lift it out? Will it have structures on it or be part of the land form? Enlighten me.

Dave

luvindemtrains posted:
gunrunnerjohn posted:

I also added handles to the lift-out do it's easy to deal with.  I do have to get the proper paint to paint the metal J-channel a similar color, that's not urgent right now.

Hi John,

I plan to put handles on my lift-outs as well. My question is if there is no one around where will you put it when you lift it out? Will it have structures on it or be part of the land form? Enlighten me.

Dave

The plan is to simply rotate it 45 degrees, turn it somewhat vertical, and lower it through the hole and set it aside.  There won't be any track on it, and any scenery will be firmly attached and low profile.

Randy Harrison posted:
gunrunnerjohn posted:

Well, here's what it looks like without clamps and wood holding it in place.   Another step...

Bravo, John and Tom!!!! The bench work is beautiful!

Thanks, it's certainly taking shape.  Seeing the fascia the way it's intended to look really makes a difference!

geysergazer posted:

John, it'll be a shame to mess up all that beautiful cabinetry with a bunch of track and scenery 

Well, I could move chairs in and make it a giant dining table, but I think I'll go the original planned direction.

The lift up like Alex built a short while ago and like John Allen did fifty five years ago is neat after a fashion.

However the supporting staff acts like a  tree growing just inside a turntable wall.  You can not turn completely around.  It becomes somewhat restrictive,  impractical.  Unless there was extensive delicate untouchable coverings on the lift out.   However, John is not going there.

John, I just got finished getting up to speed on your wonderful work! You and Tom are making magic come to life! I really enjoyed reading everything you and Tom have posted about your build! Its just Amazing what you 2 have done making your layout table look like a high class furniture! I wish I would have been able to see this before I started my build, but then again I would still be at the starting faze! LOL

I really cant wait to see what's next! But John If you don't mind I would like to point out something. I kind of did this with Paul 2 from the forum. Kinda for a laugh and to let you know that I am really looking at what you 2 have going on!

It looks like you might want to take a minute after you have your morning coffee and run the Vacuum! 

mike g. posted:

I really cant wait to see what's next! But John If you don't mind I would like to point out something. I kind of did this with Paul 2 from the forum. Kinda for a laugh and to let you know that I am really looking at what you 2 have going on!

It looks like you might want to take a minute after you have your morning coffee and run the Vacuum! 

Mike, the vacuum is certainly going to be used.   I couldn't see doing a major cleanup when I was just going to trash it in the next day or two.  Now that we have the basic benchwork mostly finished, I'll be doing a clean-up.  Note that I've already picked up all the drop cloths that were covering the carpet in preparation for that exact step.  If you think the carpet is bad, you should see the corner where the table saw is currently sitting!

 

As you approach the table saw you  would feel as though you are walking uphill.   Not sure how John will approach that pile.  I usually save my saw dust to mix in with the gypsum. 

To a mild extent the plans are lost on the floor somewhere and we are just making it up as we go along or so it could seem. I think the only remaining original feature is...............the carpet.

gunrunnerjohn posted:

I'm regrouping, catching my breath, and prepping some stuff for the track laying step.  I was really letting other things slide for a time, have to get back to those before I can move ahead.  It's also giving me a little time to think and make sure I haven't missed considering something going forward.

So. gunrunner, still taking a breather from working on your layout? Does that mean you'll now be accepting new customers for engine upgrades, conversions, and repairs?

Last edited by ogaugeguy

Actually, I'm holding off any major new repairs/upgrades, I'm still catching up.  I'm currently engaged in sorting all the boxes that were in the back of the area, that's a significant undertaking.  I need to do that to make some room to continue the layout build, next is the inclines for the grades and elevated sections and laying track.  I'm also trying to finalize the track plan, I have deviated quite a bit from where I was originally.  I blame Tom for that, after doing all the neat curves and extensions to the benchwork, lots of new possibilities are popping up.

2I can see the lure of some of the Atlas, Ross, and Gargraves realistic looking track. I like the Fastrack for several reasons, but I'm sure it makes some more noise. On the 1/4 inch indoor/outdoor carpet, it's quiet enough for me...it's quietest if you run prototypical speeds.

The quietest I ever heard was on tubular at a train meet. I think it was 027.

John,

I have installed the YLB 10500 or 10510 in 30 steam engines so far.  There is no room in the Vision Line Big Boy Tender for a YLB. I will add a double pick-up roller to my tender.  At very slow speeds, the Big Boy Coal tender drops sound on a Atlas #5 Double Slip Switch.  Some of my smaller engines have tethers, so they won't need batteries.  I have twelve steam engines with tethers or no room for batteries. I evidently miss-counted steam engines initially. The new total is 42.  And they are all completed.

Thanks again for a solution that has solved the biggest issue on my model railroad.

I will be deleting my posts in this thread in order to keep it on topic.  Your layout is going to be excellent.  I look forward to following the thread.

Sincerely, John Rowlen

Last edited by John Rowlen

John,

I put "the beater" on the tracks and got all features working except the coal.

It was a bright spot in my day after Katie said Lionel had no replacement parts for the missing cowcatcher and coupler on my AC-12 Southern Pacific #4294 that came back from Lionel Service with them missing. How much skill does it take to put all the parts back on an engine after it has been worked on?

Sincerely, John Rowlen

Attachments

Videos (1)
MVI_0811_TrimBigBoy1
Last edited by John Rowlen

John,

Thank you for delivering more YLB Batteries to Henning's Trains. I have finished the 30 steam engines and will see if any diesels have issues with the Atlas O switches. It is strange that an Atlas O Trainman U23b, with only two pick-up rollers, stalls on the Atlas O #5 Double Crossover switches.  Atlas needs to put four pick-up rollers on all of their engines.  The Master line engines are fine with four pick-up rollers.

Thank you again.

Sincerely, John Rowlen

If you were to build a fair replica of your house, including your new train room, then build a replica of your new layout (a static graphic model would be fine) in the appropriate room, you could say that your "new layout finally getting a train room".

This is not a new idea, of course; maybe even mentioned in the last 22 Forum pages.

Life has intervened in my construction plans and I'm currently working on finishing our loft that used to be storage.  Since it needed climate control, I went with the ductless heatpump up there.  For a modest extra sum, the ductless outdoor units will handle two indoor units.  That being the case, my trainroom got upgraded climate control.  18,000 BTU of heat or A/C on tap now.

Attachments

Images (1)
  • mceclip0
Last edited by gunrunnerjohn
SantaFeJim posted:

GRJ,

I just saw that unit on Amazon for $1,100 earlier this week.  Did you find a better price elsewhere?

On a scale of 1-10, with 10 being a real pain in the doopa, how hard was it to install?

No way I'd try to install this, and after seeing the process, I'm glad I didn't!  The units themselves are not that expensive, but it takes considerable labor to install them.  One of them, the one on the 3rd floor, has about 60 feet of refrigerant lines going to it.  Just watching the process convinces me that is not a job for a novice.  You also have to be EPA licensed to buy refrigerant of any type.  Add to that the tools you need for the installation, a boatload of brass hardware, vacuum pump, coolant pressure gauges, etc., it's not worth it to attempt these installs on your own.

To answer the question, it was easy, I use the telephone as my primary installation tool.

Suffice to say, it took three and part of the time four guys two days to install the attic and trainroom units, as well as the outside unit.  They had ladders, hardware, an extensive assortment of hardware, cable runs for up the wall, etc.  It took two of these guys one day to install the main level gas furnace and A/C unit!  A big part of the install is connecting the two inside units with the outside units.  Then there's the 50A circuit to the outside unit that has about 80-90 feet of cable back to the power panel, the drains from the two units, etc.

There are lots of projects that a homeowner can reasonably tackle, this isn't one of them, at least IMO.

My whole house has new heat and A/C for all levels, I should be good for many years to come.

Attachments

Images (3)
  • mceclip0
  • mceclip1
  • mceclip2
Last edited by gunrunnerjohn

Mark, there's also the minor inconvenience of having to be EPA certified to handle refrigerant.

The same as me not letting these guys design a circuit for me, I wouldn't try to do their job.  That's not to say I don't understand the elements that go into the job, but they arrive with two large trucks full of equipment and tools.  By the time I buy all the equipment and tools  needed to do the job, I'd have already paid for professional installation.  Since I'd only get to use all the equipment and tools once for the most part, it doesn't seem to make sense.

I remember seeing these units in Europe in the 2000-2007 and wondering why I'd never seen them in the US.  In the last few years, they've been popping up everywhere.  It so happened that my particular situation lends itself to the dual head unit perfectly, and having individual climate control for the added areas is way better than trying to tie them into the main system.

John:

I had an old wall unit for the garage shop replaced with a mini-split about 6 months ago. The installers (Goettle) did a great job. They removed the old unit, plugged and patched in the hole (quite large) and since the hole was there installed all wires and hose inside the wall, then installed the handler high up towards the ceiling out of the way. The unit plus installation was not cheap but with its quality and efficiency bills will be less expensive from now on.

Joe

Added photo - the patch work for the old unit is just behind the hand cart.

2019-10-27 Fronts 003

Attachments

Images (1)
  • 2019-10-27 Fronts 003
Last edited by Joe Fauty

Had Mitsubishi setup with 5 wall units hooked up to a big unit outside. Have hot water heat on the first floor and forced air on the second floor. The spit system was about the best way to go. Was more money but think it was worth it. Had them put a unit in the train room. They all have AC  heat and a dry setting  mode to dehumidify. Took 4 guys about a day and a half to install. Just love it only run it in the rooms being used at the time. Supper quiet system can't really hear the outside unit running. Not like the noise the compressor for the second floor AC system makes. Yea they were talking tear out the ceiling in the train room to install ducts for a forced air system for the first floor. It would be about half the price as a split system for equipment and install. I really did not want to take all the trains and stuff out so they could run ducts. Not to mention the mess taking out the ceiling. Anyway a great system.

Last edited by Gweedo

They are awesome units.  We've had our Mitsubishi units for two years now and love them, extremely quiet and efficient.  We have four head units, two on each floor and they work great.  The tech had to run a vacuum pump for six hours to reach the proper amount of vacuum.  It was a good and much needed break for him because it took them a day and a half to drill the holes through the red brick on the exterior of the house.  Then they had to deal with the tops of the sill plates above the windows.  And of all things it was 90 degrees that week.  Burned up 2 masonry whole saws in the process!

Looking forward to seeing your progress on the layout!

Had a similar plan to add one of those units to my basement when we bought our house in 2016.  It’s a walkout finished basement containing my woodworking shop, theatre room and an area for the train layout.  It has no a/c and the only heat is a wood burning stove.

Decided to wait a year for my bank account to recover after buying the house.  In the meantime, started to track how many days I would need a/c and heat with a digital thermometer that records history.  Figured that info would help in buying an appropriate size unit.

Now going on three years and have had no days that I needed a/c.  The heat is only justifiable  during an average of 14 weeks.  So far, on occasional fire in the wood burning stove or an electric space heater is all that is needed to make it comfortable.  The highest recorded temp was 74 and the lowest was 59.  Current temp is 68. Hard to justify the expense for a nice split unit so far. Besides, the wife likes the excuse to have an occasional fire while watching a movie on the projector.

We did buy a dehumidifier that I run occasionally during the humid Virginia summers. Highest recorded humidity so far has been 64 percent.  Prior owners did a nice job of sealing the basement and adding a good layer of spray foam  insulation in the walls.

Last edited by jstraw124

Alex, track is next.  My daughter threw a monkey wrench into my layout construction, she showed up with a couple of kids!  We're making room for them, so in addition to doing the heat and A/C, we're also finishing the 3rd floor loft.  Life occasionally intervenes when you're making other plans.

jstraw124 posted:
Now going on three years and have had no days that I needed a/c.  The heat is only justifiable  during an average of 14 weeks.  So far, on occasional fire in the wood burning stove or an electric space heater is all that is needed to make it comfortable.  The highest recorded temp was 74 and the lowest was 59.  Current temp is 68.

My situation is a bit different.  Since we were installing the loft climate control, the add-on to do the basement was less than if I were buying the whole system just for that area.  Also, closing off the basement vents will allow the main system to better distribute even heat to the upstairs.  I suspect that sometime in my future I'll be replacing the sliding door with something that holds the heat in better, that's in the future...

Last edited by gunrunnerjohn
gunrunnerjohn posted:

Alex, track is next.  My daughter threw a monkey wrench into my layout construction, she showed up with a couple of kids!  We're making room for them, so in addition to doing the heat and A/C, we're also finishing the 3rd floor loft.  Life occasionally intervenes when you're making other plans.

jstraw124 posted:
Now going on three years and have had no days that I needed a/c.  The heat is only justifiable  during an average of 14 weeks.  So far, on occasional fire in the wood burning stove or an electric space heater is all that is needed to make it comfortable.  The highest recorded temp was 74 and the lowest was 59.  Current temp is 68.

My situation is a bit different.  Since we were installing the loft climate control, the add-on to do the basement was less than if I were buying the whole system just for that area.  Also, closing off the basement vents will allow the main system to better distribute even heat to the upstairs.  I suspect that sometime in my future I'll be replacing the sliding door with something that holds the heat in better, that's in the future...

John I hear ya LOL , I’m just Breaking your Chops lol. I’ve been trying for the last two years, and I get get to first base. 

Alex 

gunrunnerjohn posted:

Us "old guys" are more reliable, that's why they want to hire us.

You can't beat experience, plain and simple. Most managers forget things like that. I myself often get the "are you sure about that" question from my boss. I can do stuff blindfolded while he and some others can get what it is when I show them.

Monkey wrenches always happen John, Alex & Mark. Maybe we should toss darts at the dart board and play those numbers in the lottery, lol.

gunrunnerjohn posted:

Alex, track is next.  My daughter threw a monkey wrench into my layout construction, she showed up with a couple of kids!  We're making room for them, so in addition to doing the heat and A/C, we're also finishing the 3rd floor loft.  Life occasionally intervenes when you're making other plans.

jstraw124 posted:
Now going on three years and have had no days that I needed a/c.  The heat is only justifiable  during an average of 14 weeks.  So far, on occasional fire in the wood burning stove or an electric space heater is all that is needed to make it comfortable.  The highest recorded temp was 74 and the lowest was 59.  Current temp is 68.

My situation is a bit different.  Since we were installing the loft climate control, the add-on to do the basement was less than if I were buying the whole system just for that area.  Also, closing off the basement vents will allow the main system to better distribute even heat to the upstairs.  I suspect that sometime in my future I'll be replacing the sliding door with something that holds the heat in better, that's in the future...

Be sure to check out the various methods of insulating that slider before deciding to replace. There are a lot of options.

Dave NYC Hudson PRR K4 posted:
gunrunnerjohn posted:

Us "old guys" are more reliable, that's why they want to hire us.

You can't beat experience, plain and simple. Most managers forget things like that. I myself often get the "are you sure about that" question from my boss. I can do stuff blindfolded while he and some others can get what it is when I show them.

Monkey wrenches always happen John, Alex & Mark. Maybe we should toss darts at the dart board and play those numbers in the lottery, lol.

John and Dave, That is exactly why they hired me.  The trouble was the pace for tech support was too taxing for me.  My blood pressure went up every day.  If I hadn't already been on anti-anxiety medication, I probably wouldn't have lasted as long as I did.    At least I can better appreciate what the person on the other end of the phone has to deal with when I call for tech support or customer service, now!  

Mark Boyce posted:
Dave NYC Hudson PRR K4 posted:
gunrunnerjohn posted:

Us "old guys" are more reliable, that's why they want to hire us.

You can't beat experience, plain and simple. Most managers forget things like that. I myself often get the "are you sure about that" question from my boss. I can do stuff blindfolded while he and some others can get what it is when I show them.

Monkey wrenches always happen John, Alex & Mark. Maybe we should toss darts at the dart board and play those numbers in the lottery, lol.

John and Dave, That is exactly why they hired me.  The trouble was the pace for tech support was too taxing for me.  My blood pressure went up every day.  If I hadn't already been on anti-anxiety medication, I probably wouldn't have lasted as long as I did.    At least I can better appreciate what the person on the other end of the phone has to deal with when I call for tech support or customer service, now!  

One of the guys who worked with me was in our CS. A nice short old guy who would have his ear to the phone and be understanding, concerned for the customer's needs, willing to do whatever was humanly possible, and communicate to the highest degree. They don't make guys like him anymore(or they're really hard to find nowadays). He was a lesson in excellence of job knowledge and implementation. That's why whenever I call up a place, I think of him on the other end and I am calm and rational.

To add to the contractor/ train guy stories.

About 20 +  years ago I was doing a big renovation of a large house on the north shore of Long Island. I met the GC there to go over the project. The house was nothing remarkable except for the NYC skyline views from the pool deck. As we got down to the basement I came across a closed door. I asked what was behind it and the contractor wasn't sure. We opened it and turned on the lights and a huge O gauge layout with all the bells and whistles was sitting there. My jaw hit the floor and before the job was done I had trains running on the layout and helped the non-train savvy new owner understand how it all worked. The layout could run 4 trains simultaneously with automatic block control.  I wish I had taken some photos but we weren't carrying cameras around with us yet. 

John- best of luck settling in your daughter and grand kids.

Add Reply

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×