Skip to main content

I picked up this NIB Lionel 84122 FGE 40' Scale Reefer from the bay for an incredibly low price.  It looks great.  The only problem is that the doors are supposed to open, but I can't figure out how.  There's a lot of delicate pieces attached to the door area, so I don't want to break it.  Does anyone know how to open the doors?  I see some sort of metal strip in the top and bottom door channels that look like they're supposed to keep the door from sliding around once opened.

IMG_5016

Attachments

Images (1)
  • IMG_5016

During York Week, I received some pieces that didn't come from York. So I didn't display them in the York thread. I only got to photograph these (outdoors) today. but I kinda wish I had gotten out of the house earlier since the 4:30pm-ish sunlight was rapidly fading on me.

Every so often I go looking for some overseas O gauge. Not looking to convert or anything, just adding some oddballs to the collection. At the beginning of York Week, I won a Cabin Fever auction lot of three Lima O scale coaches and one gondola. The same week, a Google search for "Lima O scale coaches" turned up a listing on Trainz for a quartet of Lima coaches for less than $50 (before shipping). Now, these cars do turn up on Ebay, but not cheaply (what on Ebay is?), and the shipping costs often rival the price of the car because virtually all of these cars come from the UK. In this case, the cars were already stateside, so significant savings ensue:

Lima got into O scale around 1972, so they're in the same era as the cars Atlas O's Trainman line are descendants of, as well as AHM's O scale line (I have a near-complete set of both). I have a feeling there's no telling how old these cars are, beyond Lima closing up shop in 2004 and its new owner Hornby not continuing the O scale line.

Captions reference the photos above them...

Lima 6611 [SBB+CFF]
The first four cars came from Trainz, and feature cars from four different railroads. This first one is marked for SBB+CFF, the Swiss Federal Railways. Model number 6611

Lima 6610 [SNCF]
Second one is marked for SNCF, the French federal railway. Model# 6610

Lima 6609 [Deutsche Bahn]
Third one is lettered for Deutsche Bahn "Scharnow Reisen" which near as I can tell is some sort of German travel agency. Not sure if the name is there as an advertisement, or some special excursion offered by the agency. Model# 6609

Lima 6620 [BR Great Western]
Last one in this selection is a different body, that of a British Rail Mark 1 coach, lettered for Great Western. (Model number 6620) Noteworthy for being a different size than the three Continental cars above it due to UK clearances being tighter than the rest of Europe. I thought it interesting to compare this car with a Lionel Hogwarts' Express car, based on the same car model:

Lima and Lionel MK1 length
By the way, the Commonwealth trucks on the Lionel car are accurate for Mark 1's, the newer of two types they were equipped with. The ones on the Lima cars are a carryover from the ones they made for their continental coaches, so not prototypical for the Mk.1.

Lima and Lionel MK1 ride-height
While the Mark 1's were around 64' long, there were versions built as short as 57' for certain areas where sharp curves gave regular-length coaches too much overhang. The Lionel carbodies measure a scale 53', a making them a bit short of the...mark

Going by these photos, the Lima version is a 64' car.

Lima + Lionel BR MK1-width

Now, if Lima did accurately scale their Mark 1 coaches (I don't see why not, given their market), this seems to show the Lionel car in a better light width-wise...but they still sit waaay too high on their trucks, a concession to the 036 curves they're expected to operate on maybe, but the amount of air between the trucks and carbody is just goofy-looking.

Lima 6645 MK1 brake coach [LMS]
From the Cabin Fever lot, we have another Lima BR mark 1 "brake coach", this time from the LMS, or London, Midland and Scottish Railway. Coincidentally, Lionel also modeled this type in addition to the standard coach for the Hogwarts set. I just happened to pull that version from my set break-up cars (themselves a York show acquisition from Grysboski's) when grabbing an example for these photos. According to the product database at Hattons UK, the product number for this car is (31)6645

Lima 6603 [SNCF]
Back to the other style of European coaches, this one (model number 6603) is decorated in an SNCF "Le Capitole" scheme, according to the 'International Forum of Lima Train Enthusiasts', which I linked to in the second paragraph.

Lima 6671 [SNCF]
A SNCF restaurant car, model 6671. Interestingly enough, this car was equipped with Kadee couplers. The coach above it must have been positioned by its original owner as a transition car to unmodified Lima rolling stock, as it has a Kadee on one end and a Lima coupler on the other. Technically, I might not need to engineer a Lima-to-3rail coupler adapter to put this entire collection of cars behind a typical 3-rail consist, as the Kadee coupler will mate with our 'lobster claw". But I'm probably still going to do it -- these are still 2-rail cars, and handling more than one at a time might prove troublesome as my 'test track' is still tubular.

Lima and MTH coach
The restaurant car coupled to an MTH car for size comparison. I don't know if these Lima cars are 1/45 or 1/43. These are, according to the above-quoted forum, based on a UIC type 'Y' passenger car, and not too closely at that. Like the MTH coaches, they were intended as a catch-all models of standardized European passenger cars of the time. They looked a good deal chunkier sitting in my test-track 'yard', but now that I put it next to the MTH car, I can chalk that up to their larger windows.

Lima atop MTH coach
The French-designed Type Y's were 80'6" long, as opposed to the 86' Type X designed by Deutsche Bundesbahn (the West German state railway that became Deutsche Bahn after the East/West reunification), so the Lima version is also a teensy bit short of full scale, as demonstrated by perching it atop the 18" MTH Premier coach.

Lima coupled to MTH-2

So, European coaches are wider than UK coaches. The MTH coach proves that ours are fatter still . Oh, and the MTH car did indeed hitch to the Kadee on the Lima. Too bad there wasn't enough light for a closeup.

Lima 6721

This two-axle gondola (model 6721 - a UIC type 2 open wagon) was part of the Cabin Fever lot. I don't have a plan for this one--it'll likely be another oddball that shows up on the back of a train in some random future video. It had its original box like the LMS coach above, but with obvious water damage. Only two cars in this lot (and none in the other) had their original boxes, and they'll both need repairs. Trainz, to their credit swaddled each of the unboxed cars in about 17 feet of bubble wrap (I measured it)  so they arrived in fine shape in their appropriately huge box packed with crinkled paper stuffing. The rest of 'em join the other cars cluttering up my living room couch waiting for me to fabricate appropriate boxes for them

---PCJ (and now to find some dinner )

(Late edits 12/11/23):

--The coaches and gondola car are 1:43 scale.

--The gondola car is of the Italian State Railways (FFSS), as per the Lima 1976 catalog

[More edits: Replaced dark photos with better-lit ones shot 5/20/24 (and again on 06/02/24)]

[Previous: Fall 2023 York haul] - [Next: More Lima UK coaches]

Attachments

Images (14)
  • Lima 6721
  • Lima + Lionel BR MK1-width
  • Lima coupled to MTH-2
  • Lima 6611 [SBB+CFF]
  • Lima 6610 [SNCF]
  • Lima 6609 [Deutsche Bahn]
  • Lima 6620 [BR Great Western]
  • Lima and Lionel MK1 length
  • Lima and Lionel MK1 ride-height
  • Lima 6645 MK1 brake coach [LMS]
  • Lima 6603 [SNCF]
  • Lima 6671 [SNCF]
  • Lima and MTH coach
  • Lima atop MTH coach
Last edited by RailRide
@RailRide posted:

During York Week, I received some pieces that didn't come from York. So I didn't display them in the York thread. I only got to photograph these (outdoors) today. but I kinda wish I had gotten out of the house earlier since the 4:30pm-ish sunlight was rapidly fading on me.

Every so often I go looking for some overseas O gauge. Not looking to convert or anything, just adding some oddballs to the collection. At the beginning of York Week, I won a Cabin Fever auction lot of three Lima O scale coaches and one gondola. The same week, a Google search for "Lima O scale coaches" turned up a listing on Trainz for a quartet of Lima coaches for less than $50 (before shipping). Now, these cars do turn up on Ebay, but not cheaply (what on Ebay is?), and the shipping costs often rival the price of the car because virtually all of these cars come from the UK. In this case, the cars were already stateside, so significant savings ensue:

Lima got into O scale around 1972, so they're in the same era as the cars Atlas O's Trainman line are descendants of, as well as AHM's O scale line (I have a near-complete set of both). I have a feeling there's no telling how old these cars are, beyond Lima closing up shop in 2004 and its new owner Hornby not continuing the O scale line.

Captions reference the photos above them...

01 Lima SBB+CFF 2501

The first four cars came from Trainz, and feature cars from four different railroads. This first one is marked for SBB+CFF, the Swiss Federal Railways. Model number 6611

02 Lima SNCF 5187

Second one is marked for SNCF, the French federal railway.

06 Lima DB Scharnow-Reisen

Third one is lettered for Deutsche Bahn "Scharnow Reisen" which near as I can tell is some sort of German travel agency. Not sure if the name is there as an advertisement, or some special excursion offered by the agency.

03 Lima Great Western Mk1 5015

Last one in this selection is a different body, that of a British Rail Mark 1 coach, lettered for Great Western. (Model number 6620) Noteworthy for being a different size than the three Continental cars above it due to UK clearances being tighter than the rest of Europe. I thought it interesting to compare this car with a Lionel Hogwarts' Express car, based on the same car model:

04 Lima and Lionel BR mk1s

By the way, the Commonwealth trucks on the Lionel car are accurate for Mark 1's, the newer of two types they were equipped with. The ones on the Lima cars are a carryover from the ones they made for their continental coaches, so not prototypical for the Mk.1.

05 Lima and Lionel BR mk1s

While the Mark 1's were around 64' long, there were versions built as short as 57' for certain areas where sharp curves gave regular-length coaches too much overhang. The Lionel carbodies measure a scale 53', a making them a bit short of the...mark

Going by these photos, the Lima version is a 64' car.11 Lima Mk1 vs Lionel Mk1

Now, if Lima did accurately scale their Mark 1 coaches (I don't see why not, given their market), this seems to show the Lionel car in a better light width-wise...but they still sit waaay too high on their trucks, a concession to the 036 curves they're expected to operate on maybe, but the amount of air between the trucks and carbody is just goofy-looking.

09 Lima LMS BR MK1 5051

From the Cabin Fever lot, we have another Lima BR mark 1 "brake coach", this time from the LMS, or London, Midland and Scottish Railway. Coincidentally, Lionel also modeled this type in addition to the standard coach for the Hogwarts set. I just happened to pull that version from my set break-up cars (themselves a York show acquisition from Grysboski's) when grabbing an example for these photos.

07 Lima SNCF coach

Back to the other style of European coaches, this one (model number 6603) is decorated in an SNCF "Le Capitole" scheme, according to the 'International Forum of Lima Train Enthusiasts', which I linked to in the second paragraph.

07 Lima SNCF restaruant car

A SNCF restaurant car, model 6671. Interestingly enough, this car was equipped with Kadee couplers. The coach above it must have been positioned by its original owner as a transition car to unmodified Lima rolling stock, as it has a Kadee on one end and a Lima coupler on the other. Technically, I might not need to engineer a Lima-to-3rail coupler adapter to put this entire collection of cars behind a typical 3-rail consist, as the Kadee coupler will mate with our 'lobster claw". But I'm probably still going to do it -- these are still 2-rail cars, and handling more than one at a time might prove troublesome as my 'test track' is still tubular.

08 Lima vs MTH 1

The restaraunt car coupled to an MTH car for size comparison. I don't know if these Lima cars are 1/45 or 1/43. These are, according to the above-quoted forum, based on a UIC type 'Y' passenger car, and not too closely at that. Like the MTH coaches, they were intended as a catch-all models of standardized European passenger cars of the time. They looked a good deal chunkier sitting in my test-track 'yard', but now that I put it next to the MTH car, I can chalk that up to their larger windows.

08 Lima vs MTH 2

The French-designed Type Y's were 80'6" long, as opposed to the 86' Type X designed by Deutsche Bundesbahn (the West German state railway that became Deutsche Bahn after the East/West reunification), so the Lima version is also a teensy bit short of full scale, as demonstrated by perching it atop the 18" MTH Premier coach.

12 Lima euro coach vs MTH coach

So, European coaches are wider than UK coaches. The MTH coach proves that ours are fatter still . Oh, and the MTH car did indeed hitch to the Kadee on the Lima. Too bad there wasn't enough light for a closeup.

10 Lima 2axle euro gondola

This two-axle gondola (model 6721 - 16-ton open wagon) was part of the Cabin Fever lot. I don't have a plan for this one--it'll likely be another oddball that shows up on the back of a train in some random future video. It had its original box like the LMS coach above, but with obvious water damage. Only two cars in this lot (and none in the other) had their original boxes, and they'll both need repairs. Trainz, to their credit swaddled each of the unboxed cars in about 17 feet of bubble wrap (I measured it)  so they arrived in fine shape in their appropriately huge box packed with crinkled paper stuffing. The rest of 'em join the other cars cluttering up my living room couch waiting for me to fabricate appropriate boxes for them

---PCJ (and now to find some dinner )

I think you have an excellent group there,  I believe you are running your equipment outside, which let's me compare to the bigger "G"gauge, In doing so the difference between 1/43 and 1/45 isn't near as bad as the difference of 1/18 and 1/20.  However as is said It's your railroad  nobody else should decide on give you any grief about what you run.

@VinceL posted:

Received Santa's Workshop yesterday from Charles Ro.

There is a mysterious hole in the roof.  Removing the roof, you can see a piece of black tape was placed on the underside of the roof to cover the hole.  It looks like Lionel had plans to put something else on the roof and then changed their mind.  Pretty crappy.

20231027_103102

I have to agree with you. Though it has tape underneath, the hole makes it look like a piece of trim is missing. I was also disappointed that there is only one dialogue, though it automatically repeats after a few minutes.

@Guttersnipe posted:

I think you have an excellent group there,  I believe you are running your equipment outside, which let's me compare to the bigger "G"gauge, In doing so the difference between 1/43 and 1/45 isn't near as bad as the difference of 1/18 and 1/20.  However as is said It's your railroad  nobody else should decide on give you any grief about what you run.

I'm just photographing them outside since the lighting is better. The living room where my test track loop (and a disproportionate part of my collection is currently located) doesn't have overhead light fixtures, and it's hard to get even lighting for pictures most days.

---PCJ

@Bmurphy20 posted:

I have to agree with you. Though it has tape underneath, the hole makes it look like a piece of trim is missing. I was also disappointed that there is only one dialogue, though it automatically repeats after a few minutes.

After contacting TalktoUs, Lionel shipped me a smoke stack that they say is supposed to go in the hole in the roof.  Well, the smoke stack is too small.  It does not even cover the hole.  I have notified TalktoUS that the smoke stack that they sent is not the part that goes in the hole.  I know Lionel made a smoking hobo shack.  I am wondering if Lionel was going to make the Santa's Workshop with a smoke unit and the hole was for a smoke stack that actually emitted smoke (which would probably be larger than what Lionel sent to me).  I will post here after I hear back from Lionel.

@RailRide posted:

I'm just photographing them outside since the lighting is better. The living room where my test track loop (and a disproportionate part of my collection is currently located) doesn't have overhead light fixtures, and it's hard to get even lighting for pictures most days.

---PCJ

Been there done that.  Hopefully very soon, maybe Santa will somehow provide you with the room to build a permanent Track situation

@Bmurphy20 posted:

I have to agree with you. Though it has tape underneath, the hole makes it look like a piece of trim is missing. I was also disappointed that there is only one dialogue, though it automatically repeats after a few minutes.

Have you guys considered using either or both Evergreen and/or Plastruct materials and plugging the hole with a kitchen type vent?

@RSJB18 posted:

Just received this 2-4-2 for the Christmas trains. It's from the Lionel Christmas Express RTR set. It's a no-frills basic LC / bluetooth equipped loco w/ smoke. More than adequate for looping under the tree.

Gotta wonder who chose the tender though........ it's almost as big as the engine.



2023-11-06 14.19.422023-11-06 14.19.54

Bob

That is a massive tender for that loco.

@VinceL posted:

After contacting TalktoUs, Lionel shipped me a smoke stack that they say is supposed to go in the hole in the roof.  Well, the smoke stack is too small.  It does not even cover the hole.  I have notified TalktoUS that the smoke stack that they sent is not the part that goes in the hole.  I know Lionel made a smoking hobo shack.  I am wondering if Lionel was going to make the Santa's Workshop with a smoke unit and the hole was for a smoke stack that actually emitted smoke (which would probably be larger than what Lionel sent to me).  I will post here after I hear back from Lionel.

I have exchanged a couple emails with TalktoUs today.  Lionel finally admitted it was "a tooling issue."  I guess the factory used the wrong tooling for the roof.  They said if desired, it could be returned to the dealer for a refund.

@VinceL posted:

I have exchanged a couple emails with TalktoUs today.  Lionel finally admitted it was "a tooling issue."  I guess the factory used the wrong tooling for the roof.  They said if desired, it could be returned to the dealer for a refund.

I wonder if the ‘She Shed w/ Sounds’ and ‘Grandpa’s Workshop w/ Sounds’ which look to be based on a similar structure have the same roof detail?

It’s got a pretty big coal pile! Maybe it’s only taking care of the kids on the naughty list!!!

It's a once a year Christmas Train, mainly for little tykes, they don't care they are just happy to see the chu chu, and we are happy that they like chu chu's someday they will want to be like grandpa and have one of their own and then the fun really begins

Add Reply

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×